News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pain of the New: The Hobbit at 48 fps by mattebb on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @09:49PM (#5035059)
There was no motion blur conversion, the 24fps version was made by taking every second frame.

The film was shot at 48fps with a 270 degree shutter angle, which is equivalent to a shutter speed of 1/72s. This was done to balance the look of the motion blur midway between the look that you'd get shooting 24 and 48 with a standard 180 degree shutter angle (1/48s and 1/96s respectively). So the motion blur should still be a bit sharper than a usual film, when watching the 24fps version, but not as extremely sharp as it would be at 1/96s since it would cause more stuttering and strobing.

I believe the author's point is not that the lighting was different, but that it 'appeared' different, which I agree with. The difference in the appearance I put down to getting twice as much visual information per second. Even though the spatial resolution is the same for each frame, you're getting twice as much. For example a small detail like a facial pore may not resolve between two 24fps frames, but you can see it in the 'in-between' extra frame. This could be especially an issue since the original plates were shot at 5k, resized down to 2k, potentially 'anti-aliasing' away details.

This is probably having a similar effect to when HD spatial resolution came in for television, everything looked more 'real' and productions had to adjust makeup and lighting techniques.

(disclaimer: I work in the visual effects industry)

Re:Pain of the New: The Hobbit at 48 fps by mattebb on Thursday January 10, 2013 @10:27PM (#5041189)
Edit, messed up frame rate calc, it's not 1/72s, it's 1/64s: 48/(270/360)=64