Re:Queen of the Bagel Business
by syngrog66 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:05PM
(#50358183)
It sounds like it could be more lucrative to be a restaurant/baking consultant/trainer than to run a restaurant directly. Devilish details in the execution, requiring just the right individuals and timing and probably luck. With lots of ways to fail.
Re:Queen of the Bagel Business
by nickff on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:13PM
(#50358265)
The problem with being a consultant in that industry is that your prospective clients usually don’t understand that they have a problem until it’s too late. Additionally, the restauranteurs who need help are usually under-capitalized. A friend of mine used to do this sort of (consulting) work, and it was relatively low-earning for him (he was an accountant).
Re:Queen of the Bagel Business
by halfmatthalfcat on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:21PM
(#50358373)
> When I tell her she makes it sound easy, she responds smoothly. “It is,” she says, reminding me her own shop sells 1k bagels on the weekends.
> To start a bagel shop today, she says, costs ~$500k.
"To START" - key quote. Rent, machinery, staff, etc. And then you have to do volume (~1k/day) to even start to cover costs. Then you need ancillary products like coffee (huge margins), cream cheese, etc.
I've been making bagels for almost 4 years and looked into the economics, it's hard and you wont break even for at least a couple years. As someone in tech, trying to get to my current salary would take around 5 years, that doesn't include the time investment, especially with a family.
Re:Queen of the Bagel Business
by realo on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:50PM
(#50358689)
I am sure she makes nice pastries, but those are not bagels.
Bagels are cooked in firewood ovens. And they are certainly not "fluffy"!
Best bagels are in Montreal.
Around here we have a nice bagel shop also. Look for "Bagel Maguire Cafe" in your search engine of choice ... you can also find pictures of their big firewood oven.
"... The dough is boiled in honey water, hand-rolled and baked in a wood-fired oven; it contains malt but no salt or eggs, giving a crisper, sweeter, flatter and denser bagel than New York's. The texture difference traces back to which region of Poland each city's immigrants came from. "
Re:Queen of the Bagel Business
by unwind on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:00AM
(#50366494)
Why would you ever list steps of a recipe out of order? I haven't been to Canada but none of the recipes I've read this this was posted have you forming the bagels after boiling "the dough". Weird.
Re:Queen of the Bagel Business
by ddellacosta on Friday November 06, 2026 @01:08PM
(#50395998)
The article is about someone in New York State making New York-style bagels, so what does Toronto have to do with it?
The only "grain of truth" in the parent comment is how it shows that there are plenty of people who can't figure out how to talk about what they like without denigrating stuff they don't, for no good reason. Maybe Montreal bagels and New York bagels are simply different, and that's okay? Not everything has to be a competition.
Re:Queen of the Bagel Business
by thomassmith65 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:36AM
(#50403320)
I'm guilty of misreading the article. I got it into my head, based on the first line, that it extols the virtues of Toronto-style bagels.
My problem with 'Toronto-style bagels' is not that they are bad, but that they are not really 'a thing'. Upon rereading the article, I now realize nobody was making that claim.
Montreal-style bagels, on the other hand, are very much a real thing. They have a singular reputation within Canada. That's a mildly interesting fact, hopefully. No reason anyone else has to like them.
On the other, a consultant needs to grow/maintain their brand. That's a skill like running business is a skill.
> To start a bagel shop today, she says, costs ~$500k.
"To START" - key quote. Rent, machinery, staff, etc. And then you have to do volume (~1k/day) to even start to cover costs. Then you need ancillary products like coffee (huge margins), cream cheese, etc.
I've been making bagels for almost 4 years and looked into the economics, it's hard and you wont break even for at least a couple years. As someone in tech, trying to get to my current salary would take around 5 years, that doesn't include the time investment, especially with a family.
Bagels are cooked in firewood ovens. And they are certainly not "fluffy"!
Best bagels are in Montreal.
Around here we have a nice bagel shop also. Look for "Bagel Maguire Cafe" in your search engine of choice ... you can also find pictures of their big firewood oven.
And I swear to god did I just google my way to an airport cafe
https://thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/montreal-bagel...
and this, from an AI:
"... The dough is boiled in honey water, hand-rolled and baked in a wood-fired oven; it contains malt but no salt or eggs, giving a crisper, sweeter, flatter and denser bagel than New York's. The texture difference traces back to which region of Poland each city's immigrants came from. "
I've never heard of anyone outside Toronto advertising "Toronto-style bagels"
The parent comment may be worded obnoxiously but, in broad strokes, it's correct.
The only "grain of truth" in the parent comment is how it shows that there are plenty of people who can't figure out how to talk about what they like without denigrating stuff they don't, for no good reason. Maybe Montreal bagels and New York bagels are simply different, and that's okay? Not everything has to be a competition.
My problem with 'Toronto-style bagels' is not that they are bad, but that they are not really 'a thing'. Upon rereading the article, I now realize nobody was making that claim.
Montreal-style bagels, on the other hand, are very much a real thing. They have a singular reputation within Canada. That's a mildly interesting fact, hopefully. No reason anyone else has to like them.