Re:900 foot-wide asteroid to make close approach to Earth today
by pavel_lishin on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @04:48PM
(#5033740)
Right. But unless you want the products to stay on the asteroid, you have to ship it somewhere. Shipping it somewhere would also move the asteroid.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:900 foot-wide asteroid to make close approach to Earth today
by will_work4tears on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @05:31PM
(#5033972)
So you are saying if they mine 10 tons of Iron, and bring it to earth, sans the rest of the asteroid, it'll blow up and cause destruction on earth? I think I missed that part in physics.
Otherwise I don't see your point.
Re:900 foot-wide asteroid to make close approach to Earth today
by dredmorbius on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @09:09PM
(#5034901)
Apophis has a mass of 27,000,000 tonnes.
10 tonnes is 1/2,700,000 the total mass of the asteroid.
This would be the equivalent of trying to reduce the impact of a 180 lb human by trying to reduce his mass by 0.001 oz (or 82 kg man by 0.03 grams for civilized humans).
Too small to matter.
Re:900 foot-wide asteroid to make close approach to Earth today
by will_work4tears on Thursday January 10, 2013 @04:03PM
(#5039723)
Yeah, it was just an example number, earlier I mentioned mining it down to nothing and I still got "it's just as deadly" kind of comments. Unless I'm missing something from physics, stretching the potential energy of the out across ~10 years from mining it will not be the same as letting it hit the earth.