News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by mananaysiempre on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @08:35AM (#50258188)
Unladen Swallow died for lack of upstream interest.

PyPy lacks upstream interest, looked like it could have a shot after many years of development but recently NumPy removed support because they just couldn’t fathom how a non-dead project could be a couple of versions behind CPython.

Now the new JIT is dying because of what seems to be a lack of upstream interest. (The things TFA describes as being required are not unreasonable, but not realistic for a necessarily speculative long-running project without wild amounts of committed funding.)

I’m not optimistic.

Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by pansa2 on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:13AM (#50258720)
> Unladen Swallow died for lack of upstream interest

IIRC Unladen Swallow was, despite the extreme hype, nothing more than the internship project of a couple of students. It died because their internship was over.

Otherwise you're right, though. Lots of CPython alternatives suffer from lack of upstream interest - the Python language designers don't seem very interested in anything other than CPython. In particular, they appear to only consider CPython when adding features to the language. Two examples:

- Requiring `dict`s to be ordered because that's how they work in CPython, without considering how they work in other implementations

- Adding pattern matching syntax that's suitable for CPython's PEG parser, even though it's not LL(1) so can't be parsed by, say, MicroPython

Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by genxy on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @12:13PM (#50261420)
Core Python is antagonistic to all other Python implementations. There is only one Python.
Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by mont_tag on Thursday November 05, 2026 @08:42PM (#50387092)
FWIW, PyPy had ordered dict support before CPython.

Also the Jython devs said they would easily be able to support dict order.

Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by ZiiS on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @08:41AM (#50258245)
I know not everyone loves them; but `Claude rewrite the performance bottlenecks in Rust` works so well it is hard to see the security surface area and harder reason about performance as something that should be paid in core.
Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by greenavocado on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:25AM (#50258895)
Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by ddorian43 on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:42AM (#50259188)
Seems unmaintained from July.
Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by greenavocado on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @02:36PM (#50263733)
I think its a meme but an interesting proof of concept nevertheless
Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by skeledrew on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @10:39AM (#50260100)
> committee bureaucracy

That's what's kept the language and ecosystem improving and from becoming a hot mess. If something isn't properly specced then it really shouldn't be in prod. They allowed the experiment in the first place so it'd be easier to gather sufficient data to guide said speccing, but the ball was dropped by the proposers and so the experiment was an ultimate failure (unlike free threading) and prod is now being appropriately cleaned up.

Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by pjmlp on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @10:41AM (#50260138)
> Just think about the sheer amount of electricity and compute power being wasted every single day running inefficient Python across millions of machines worldwide.

Every single time I remember the first AI wave was done with Lisp and Prolog, both with tooling that supports machine code generation since about 50 years.

Re:Python's experimental JIT to be removed by samus on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @11:04AM (#50260454)
It's not red tape, it's about making sure that the effort actually delivers what it promises and can continue to so in the future. From the state of the draft PEP it seems it doesn't and it won't ever. The SC merely put the nail into the coffin.