News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by ChuckMcM on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @12:35AM (#5025050)
I agree with the emotion but I can also see the argument that the agreement was made under duress.

If you are about to die and the only person who could save you, offers to do so, but asks you to agree to something reprehensible in exchange for saving you, what do you do?

At the risk of creating a strawman (the goal is illustration not substitution) let us construct a scenario, you're hanging by a rope which is breaking, you have maybe 10 minutes before it breaks. And the only person who can save you says, "Ok, I'll save you on the condition that in the near future I will come to you and ask you to do something for me, and you must agree to do what ever I ask."

What if your savior asks you to blow up an airplane? Or sell your spouse into the sex trade? or any of a dozen things you would never do voluntarily and are counter to your values. This is the kind of thing that novelists use to create tension, its very effective.

So AIG claims here that the Government went too far in its ask, and has crossed some line into moral turpitude. Who is the bad guy? the good guy? Doesn't really matter though, its one of those chickens they talk about that come back to roost. Never a good thing.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by earbitscom on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @12:59AM (#5025092)
Actually, it's more like a guy who just conned your family out of their life savings is hanging by a rope, which is breaking. You don't feel inclined to save them, but unfortunately, they're hanging over a crowd of innocent bystanders. You agree to save them, mostly so that the others are not injured. While you do, you make them agree to give back all of the money they stole under shitty terms. They do so by screwing over the guys who helped them pull the con job, who are now coming to you asking for their share of the money they stole from your family.
Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by ChuckMcM on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @01:09AM (#5025109)
I like it! Ideally that will come out in court (should it go to trial, although I consider that unlikely). Someone should make a Matrix spoof where the kid at the Oracle's house says,

Boy: Do not try and recover the money. That's impossible. Instead only try to realize the truth.

Neo: What truth?

Boy: There is no money.

Neo: There is no money?

Boy: Then you'll see that it is not the banks that are broke, it is only yourself.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by cpeterso on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @02:41AM (#5025269)
I think you just wrote the next Cohen Brothers film. ;)
Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by makomk on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @07:23AM (#5025885)
Not exactly. The key thing you're missing is that AIG weren't actually the main beneficiaries of the AIG bailout, the people who bought CDSs from them were. Effectively, a bunch of other companies convinced AIG to to sell them insurance for way less than it should cost, in many cases on property they didn't actually own, by conning them as to how risky it would be.

To continue the metaphor, it's like if a guy conned your family out of their life savings, and then the Government generously seized your home in exchange for paying the guy who scammed you the rest of the money you owed him which you couldn't afford to pay.

Edit: see, for instance, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-fiderer/the-cdos-that-de...

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by jfager on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @07:52AM (#5025965)
AIG isn't a company run by widows and orphans. The department that issued that insurance was full of the most stereotypical Wall Street shark assholes around, who thought they were smarter than everyone else and getting a big free payday. They got scammed in the way a casino scams the idiot wearing sunglasses at the craps table.

Yes, the government bailout of AIG went towards paying off their counterparties. But those were actual debts that AIG owed because of their own stupidity and greed. Had AIG gone bankrupt instead, the counterparties would not have received anywhere near full payment, and there's a compelling case to be made that that's how it should have been. But this idea that AIG somehow got screwed by having to pay off their shitty bets with our money is laughable and disgusting. If the shareholders want to sue someone, it should be their own board.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by makomk on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @12:48PM (#5027312)
Guess who owned most of the AIG shares that were diluted as part of the Government bailout, though? It certainly wasn't the guys that were running the shop - it was your pension scheme, and everyone else's pension scheme.

Also, I got my analogy wrong. It would be more like if the Government seized 92% of your house in exchange for loaning you the money to pay off the scammer with interest, which they knew you could repay.

Even after the massive swindle, AIG's problem was liquidity and not insolvency - they had enough assets to repay everyone and if they'd actually gone bankrupt, the shareholders may well have come out better in the end, but their counterparties would've been screwed because they'd have had to have waited for the bankrupcy proceedings to get paid.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by sswaner on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @11:41AM (#5026980)
By that standard you must also reject legislation that limits interest rates charged by payday loan shops? It is very much the same situation: What is a reasonable interest rate for a loan made to someone or some corporation under duress?
Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by shiven on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @12:12PM (#5027121)
legislation that limits interest rates charged by payday loan shops

If the government were a payday loan shop and gouging thousands of independent companies everyday, your analogy would hold water. Till then, this is merely a straw-man argument.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @07:14AM (#5025875)
I'm confused about the analogy - who did AIG shareholders con?
Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by tatsuke95 on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @08:15AM (#5026028)
This is standard operating procedure on the internet: everyone who wears a suit is a parasitcal criminal.

Back in reality, most banks have paid back their TARP funds, as did AIG, generating a hefty return over 3 years to the Treasury. You know what bailout is still significantly in the red? The auto industry. But we hear little about that because those guys don't work on Wall Street.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by sageikosa on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:27AM (#5026310)
I seem to remember a number of them didn't need to take the funds, but were arm-twisted into it so that it would look like a general national problem as opposed to bailing out some well-connected (yet incompetent) cronies.
Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by tatsuke95 on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:40AM (#5026376)
It wasn't about cronyism: they couldn't "bail out" specific, failing banks or else it would be obvious to stakeholders where the "bad" banks were. Every bank that would have received funds under these circumstances would be susceptible to a run. It was a crafty play, done against the will of the some of the banks.

The industry needed an infusion of cash, and they spread it around a bunch of the biggest players.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by sageikosa on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @01:08PM (#5027438)
The bad banks got to hide behind the good banks, the good banks can't possibly win under such a scenario, since they get lumped in as "the banks" by the masses that don't care about specific behavior but craft their ideas based on "industry".

Ford ticked up after not taking a handout, larger well governed banks had no such opportunity.

Deposits up to $100K (or thereabouts) were insured by the FDIC, so even under a run, the savers in the bad banks were not going to be left high and dry; and perhaps wiser about where they put their money in the future. Perhaps the Federal Government didn't want to see the FDIC invoked.

Instead, a precedent was set; bad behavior was not punished (by way of market action), and good behavior is tainted by association (via political demonizing).

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by kahawe on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:17AM (#5026256)
> The auto industry

In all fairness, I do not remember "the auto industry" almost bringing the whole capitalistic system (and with it our Western world) close to a grinding halt, according to what we were lead to believe, in the last 5 to 10 years. And after the gang-rape that GM did over here in Germany and continues to do now, oh yes you do hear about them here.

> a suit is a parasitcal criminal.

From what I have seen, the average folks still buy into the opposite extreme where every suit and especially every banker is some sort of god-like being, far removed from our mere mortal realm and surely a gravely respectable person, much more so than the average Joe. Quite frankly, I find the extreme prevalent on the internet to be far more beneficial because it moves things into a direction where the strange money-fetish has to make way for a more realistic view of this profession so prone to scams, frauds, "gamblings", cut-necks and other shenanigans. It will hopefully help people to view a bank not much different from some regular store, a place offering a service, regardless of dress code.

Also, I do not think the auto industry runs Stasi-like intelligence operations where they constantly collect and pool your most private and financial information and credit ratings and use all that to evaluate how they are going to deal with and sell to you - or potentially put you out on the street.

As someone unfortunate enough to be working in IT in this "parasitic" industry I cannot see this industry getting hit and dis-credited hard enough after they have repeatedly gotten away with much more than murder over decades. There is no reason other than money that anyone works in this and it cannot be a coincident that they pay much more than a lot of other industries; and I don't think there are a lot of other industries with a more backward, pre-history corporate and work culture.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by tatsuke95 on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:38AM (#5026356)
>"In all fairness, I do not remember "the auto industry" almost bringing the whole capitalistic system (and with it our Western world) close to a grinding halt"

I don't care about "could haves". These industries were all bailed out; some returned a profit to the taxpayers, some are still in the red without a chance of paying any of it back. Yet we continuously denigrate the industry that paid the money back as the "criminals".

>"From what I have seen, the average folks still buy into the opposite extreme"

Really? You must be living in a different world than I am. Just skim this thread, or any thread on Reddit...

>"Also, I do not think the auto industry runs Stasi-like intelligence operations where they constantly collect and pool your most private and financial information and credit ratings and use all that to evaluate how they are going to deal with and sell to you - or potentially put you out on the street."

Banks aren't planning to put you on the street. Where does this come from? Banks want to lend money and be paid back, with interest. This whole debacle worked out really well for them. They only had something like 3 trillion wiped from their collective balance sheets.

By the way, the auto-industry parents run huge financial companies.

>"it cannot be a coincident that they pay much more than a lot of other industries"

Sort of like IT? Or medicine?

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by kahawe on Thursday January 10, 2013 @09:25AM (#5036964)
>Really? You must be living in a different world than I am. Just skim this thread, or any thread on Reddit...

Yes, I am. And I hope you do realize that neither of those two are even remotely representative for the vast masses of average folks out there.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by illuminate on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @04:01PM (#5033490)
"In all fairness, I do not remember "the auto industry" almost bringing the whole capitalistic system (and with it our Western world) close to a grinding halt, according to what we were lead to believe, in the last 5 to 10 years"

Their finance departments were used for much more than car loans.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by icambron on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @05:20AM (#5025580)
I know you don't mean to draw a parallel, but I'm nevertheless going to point out that the illustration isn't very...illustrative. AIG was in a situation where the expectation was for it to go out of business because of its own (possibly illegal) mismanagement. It was offered a deal whose price, rather than being morally repugnant or open-ended, was merely expensive. And no one was going to die in any case. So let's try this:

You've decided to push a rather nice antique couch off the back of a high-flying plane for reasons all your own. While it falls, someone radios you and says, "look, I'll snatch this couch out of the air with this really expensive-to-fly jet with grappling hooks I have, but afterwards you'll owe me 80% of what you make selling it or renting it to those weird antique museums". Turns out the guy calling you really just wants to prevent the couch from crashing into a residential area, but he figures that in order to afford this crazy couch-saving stunt, he needs a big chunk of equity in the couch, which will be splinters if he doesn't save it anyway. And you, having decided that dropping a valuable piece of furniture from 30,000 feet was a bad idea after all, take the deal.

It turns out that you made a good move, because later you sell the couch and make lots of money, a lot of which goes to the crazy couch-saver guy. And you still think the deal sucks, so much so that, apparently, it was illegal for some reason, and you should get to keep a higher percentage of the couch's proceeds.

Now, what part of that seems like duress?

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by tripzilch on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @07:52AM (#5025962)
I am loving all of these crazy analogies!

Man, if I were a timetravel agency, I'd be selling front-row tickets to the 21st century as "comedy night".

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by roc on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @01:07AM (#5025104)
Except that bankruptcy (particularly corporate bankruptcy) is hardly as permanent as death. And no-one making decisions at AIG was personally on the hook for remotely that level of responsibility.

Conflating their position with calamitous death seems borderline disingenuous. You're soliciting emotional reactions to an unforeseeable emergency. But AIG was in a situation that years of rational business decisions put in the cards. They not only should have known it could happen, but they'd also know that their gains from having done it far outweighed the personal potential losses.

Which is almost certainly why the gambles were made in the first place and puts the lie to any analogy to human desperation in a split-second survival scenario.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by ChuckMcM on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @01:13AM (#5025122)
If you review the situation with AIG, the only available bankruptcy option available to AIG was Chapter 7, aka liquidation. There was no scenario without the government stepping in that they could have used Chapter 11 to re-organize.

In this case, a corporate liquidation is exactly like death, the assets are divided up amongst the creditors and the company ceases to exist.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by roc on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @01:23AM (#5025152)
Nothing that can happen to a corporation is like human death for the humans making the decision, nor for the humans who stand to lose money for having invested in that company, nor for the humans who are employees at the corporation.

It just isn't the same. Not remotely. There's no parallel.

AIG, via its decision-makers, took the bet that the bailout would work out for them for the same reason they took the bets that put them into that position and the same reason they're taking the bet that it's worth suing the federal government: a sober analysis of risk/reward suggested it was the best business move.

No-one acted out of desperation. No-one was going to be hung for their misdeeds. No-one was jumping out a window for grief or committing seppuku for shame.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by afarrell on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @01:31AM (#5025164)
No, liquidation of a corporation is only like a human's death in that it implies the division of the entity's assets.

But the humans making the decision to accept the deal do not feel fear that they will cease to exist and they will leave their loved ones behind. They don't have the animal fear of physical pain either. Unless they have been terribly reckless with their personal finances, they are not at any risk of actual death. At most, they have dread of embarrassment and the shame of having failed the trust of their employees.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by pohl on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @08:31AM (#5026080)
No, liquidation of a corporation is only like a human's death in that it implies the division of the entity's assets.

The resemblance between this and becoming worm-food is uncanny, though.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by tripzilch on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @07:57AM (#5025981)
> In this case, a corporate liquidation is exactly like death

If you actually believe this, then I believe you are a terrible person.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by kahawe on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:29AM (#5026321)
Except "death" is not a viable nor reasonable choice for a human being, while bankruptcy and/or liquidation are both very normal and reasonable choices for an organization especially if that organization got itself into that trouble in the first place and had it been any other (smaller) business, this would have instantly been the end of it.

The very fact that the government even stepped in is a major exception to the system as a whole, so this is more like the flying spaghetti monster sending you back to earth after your suicide and you then wanting to sue His Noodly Appendage for not having been able to play the lottery on the day of your death and/or not picking up Charon's ferry bill for you.

And there is no law against offering a tough deal when the odds are stacked for you and your partner has their back against the wall - a principle the banks and insurances use and (strongly) abuse each and every day against those who have no choice. Again, had this been some even-bigger-money-giant buying AIG out and then running the place into the ground again, it would have also been the end of it.

They are twisting a rule that was obviously meant to keep capitalism and business separate from government just to get some money out of it when without that governmental divine intervention they would not even be existent in the first place.

I am all for playing devil's advocate and looking at the flip-side of things and great you made an attempt but, sorry, this is wrong on so many levels, there is no right way of looking at it.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by wslh on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @06:48AM (#5025821)
> If you are about to die and the only person who could save you, offers to do so, but asks you to agree to something reprehensible in exchange for saving you, what do you do?

I see it differently: if you are walking down the street and see that a shop is closing its doors, do you help the owner to stay open knowing that he can sue you later?

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by latinohere on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:12AM (#5026238)
You are being extremely disingenuous. You are equating the dead of a person with the dead of a company. By doing this you are biasing the argument in your favor because people know is bad to let people die. All in all I cannot take your argument seriously if you do stuff like that. You are apealling to emotion rather than reason.
Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by ChuckMcM on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @11:17AM (#5026879)
Time to have some serious, un-edited conversation here folks.

The comments around this question have been really interesting to watch. But the underlying subtext of corporations 'good' vs 'bad' and the level of seriousness it entails when they are dissolved is even more amazing.

First off, on a discussion group that is pretty much focused on creating innovation through technology, the concept of corporations is pretty much fundamental. If you hate corporations and everything they stand for then starting one should be the last thing on your mind. Further helping other people create theirs should also be pretty low on your list. Without the existence of these collectives there is no framework for seed rounds, 'happy exits', or IPOs. There is no 'acqui-hire' and no structure in which to build a vision that is greater than yourself.

But the second bit that must be understood is that "corporations" are composed of people, just as a marriage is composed of people. These companies are things that people invest time, emotion, and money into to further their goals. When they fail, people feel badly, sometimes really badly about that.

If you decide to live in the community of people who build companies from the ground up, or work to make them great, then someone you know personally will commit suicide when they come to the realization that their company has failed and they could have prevented it. I know it is hard to imagine this as a young person who has yet to face their own mortality in any serious way, but please try to understand this scenario.

You have been working with folks for 3, 4, 5, or maybe 10 years on building something together. Imagine someone you knew in 6th grade is is now graduating with you in college. There are challenges that you don't think you can overcome, personal hardships that you weather together, shared victories you've achieved. You've shared in people making progress toward their life goals, perhaps they have saved up enough to buy their first house, maybe their kids have made it into an Ivy League college, maybe their kids have married your kids. And now, all of this and more is going to be destroyed. These people, these friends and colleagues, are going to have their lives turned upside down, and some more than others. Some will lose their houses, their kids will be told they have to come home because there is no money for school, reputations will be smeared, and good people who did nothing but great work will be villified by a public which has been fed information in a way that creates the most rage and the least understanding.

If you, latinohere, or anyone else reading this, ever get the "opportunity" to be standing at that abyss and look into it, you may feel that your own death is actually preferable than having to live with that. Sadly I know friends who decided it wasn't worth it and they ended their own lives rather than live with the knowledge they had led people into a place that turned out not as they had hoped. And in that moment, that moment of decision, do you take this "deal" which converts a bad outcome to a slightly less bad outcome. it really comes down to people living and dying. Corporation or not, real people who have to live with themselves the day after and the day after that.

Re:Rescued by a Bailout, A.I.G. May Sue Its Savior by sswaner on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @11:39AM (#5026972)
Chuck: Well said.