Re:The Git Forge for Agent-Human Collaboration
by lizziepika on Monday October 26, 2026 @02:50PM
(#50248993)
Karthik's comments have been getting blocked. I don't agree with the screen recording because an agent session isn't just a reply of keystrokes. A session contains not just what happened, but why: the intent and reasoning from the prompts, the dead-ends, what was attempted but not shipped, and "why did we do it this way." That shouldn't disappear when a session ends.
Similarly, human review doesn't matter because humans type the code, it matters because someone still ahs to decide if something is right and if not, own the consequences.
And starting fresh with agents is pricey. Continuous memory is helpful so you can see why the last change was made, burning fewer tokens and not repeating mistakes so you don't need to relearn the codebase from scratch each time
Re:The Git Forge for Agent-Human Collaboration
by argee on Monday October 26, 2026 @04:18PM
(#50250309)
Thanks for the reply. It would be great if you could introduce yourself somewhere in this comment section or in your HN profile, I cannot tell whether you intend to speak on Karthik's behalf.
Similarly, human review doesn't matter because humans type the code, it matters because someone still ahs to decide if something is right and if not, own the consequences.
And starting fresh with agents is pricey. Continuous memory is helpful so you can see why the last change was made, burning fewer tokens and not repeating mistakes so you don't need to relearn the codebase from scratch each time