News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ad Blocking Raises Alarm Among Firms Like Google by AnthonyMouse on Monday January 07, 2013 @12:55AM (#5019619)
>If an ISP can show that there is meaningful competition for a customer then they can do whatever they want right up to charging more for access to particular content/services.

This would be one thing if you're talking about them charging their own customers for such things. Though the idea that any ISP that actually tried this in a competitive market would still have any customers left by the end of the week seems mighty suspicious.

But there is another point if we're talking about peering. Each consumer-level ISP has a hard monopoly over its own customers. There is no competition for access to those customers. If you want to reach them all, you (or your network provider) has got to come to terms with each and every one of those ISPs. And the only way you have any leverage is if you're a big fish whose services are too important for the ISP not to provide its customers high speed access to.

The little fish need network neutrality or they're screwed. Regional competition between ISPs wouldn't even fix it if we had any plausible way to bring it about.

Re:Ad Blocking Raises Alarm Among Firms Like Google by rogerbinns on Monday January 07, 2013 @03:49AM (#5020108)
> Though the idea that any ISP that actually tried this in a competitive market would still have any customers left by the end of the week seems mighty suspicious.

I'm fine with letting them try because meaningful competition means consumers can go elsewhere. I hope there are some interesting business models to discover such as ISP side security filtering, ISP prioritisation of traffic, cheaper prices for consumer concessions, allowing content providers to pay for priority etc.

Re:Ad Blocking Raises Alarm Among Firms Like Google by AnthonyMouse on Monday January 07, 2013 @12:26PM (#5022028)
Two things. First, I'm as up for a theoretical discussion as the next guy, but if we're going to have a serious conversation about what would happen if the regional market for internet service was highly competitive, shouldn't we have some kind of at least theoretical non-ridiculous mechanism of actually achieving that? Because "run twelve or more redundant sets of wires to every home" fails the non-ridiculousness bar, and "continue to have only one or two wires" fails the "highly competitive" test, so where does that leave us?

Second, you're still not solving the problem of ISPs having monopolies over their own customers. We don't want ISPs with customer block monopolies charging content providers for prioritization -- they'll charge monopoly prices and suck every ounce of margin they can out of the already-struggling content production business. Even if we had competition between ISPs at the regional level, they would each still have a monopoly over their customers from the perspective of content distributors.