Re:Ad Blocking Raises Alarm Among Firms Like Google
by AnthonyMouse on Monday January 07, 2013 @12:26PM
(#5022028)
Two things. First, I'm as up for a theoretical discussion as the next guy, but if we're going to have a serious conversation about what would happen if the regional market for internet service was highly competitive, shouldn't we have some kind of at least theoretical non-ridiculous mechanism of actually achieving that? Because "run twelve or more redundant sets of wires to every home" fails the non-ridiculousness bar, and "continue to have only one or two wires" fails the "highly competitive" test, so where does that leave us?
Second, you're still not solving the problem of ISPs having monopolies over their own customers. We don't want ISPs with customer block monopolies charging content providers for prioritization -- they'll charge monopoly prices and suck every ounce of margin they can out of the already-struggling content production business. Even if we had competition between ISPs at the regional level, they would each still have a monopoly over their customers from the perspective of content distributors.
Second, you're still not solving the problem of ISPs having monopolies over their own customers. We don't want ISPs with customer block monopolies charging content providers for prioritization -- they'll charge monopoly prices and suck every ounce of margin they can out of the already-struggling content production business. Even if we had competition between ISPs at the regional level, they would each still have a monopoly over their customers from the perspective of content distributors.