News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Robot I Didn't Expect to Build by bilsbie on Thursday October 22, 2026 @10:46AM (#50196160)
A drop in replacement for a human in the very long tail of useful tasks is worth a lot.

And it’s a winner take all market as the learning curve and efficiencies of scale will drive down the cost for the most general purpose form of robot.

Re:The Robot I Didn't Expect to Build by giantg2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:08PM (#50197317)
Most tasks would me more efficient if not using a drop in replacement for humans. Rethinking the existing paradigms and redesigning the processes to be more efficient with non-humans would be more valuable.
Re:The Robot I Didn't Expect to Build by peterlk on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:41PM (#50197792)
I disagree that it would be more valuable.

It may be true that it might be more efficient, but it feels similar to the farming paradigm. You can actually get more calories per acre if you have ecosystems with varying heights. However, we don’t do this because it is much more scalable to drive massive machines over flat, unimpeded land.

It might be the case that my home would be more robot-friendly if I lived in a flat warehouse that was designed so that robots could easily handle tasks. But I don’t want to live in a warehouse, and I don’t want my house to be optimized for robots. And this isn’t even to mention the long tail of existing houses that do not adhere to a robot-optimized standard. The cost of replacing or retrofitting all of them would be astronomical.

Re:The Robot I Didn't Expect to Build by giantg2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:35PM (#50199313)
"However, we don’t do this because it is much more scalable to drive massive machines over flat, unimpeded land."

It's just that it's cheaper since we're talking about land and other physical constraints. With humanoid robots we're talking about labor. Many processes done by humans are designed to be possible by humans. As soon as you remove the ability constraints of humans, you can design more efficient processes. This is evident is all jobs pre- vs post-mechanization.

For example, do you need lights in a warehouse without people? Do you need maximum shelf height or forklift speeds for safety standards? Do you even need forklifts if the bots are stronger enough; if not, aisles can be narrowed and density increased. Etc.

Even for in-home assistance, you might be better off with multiple smaller bots tailored to different tasks. A bipedal robot designed for cleaning gutters or shoveling snow sounds like a poor design decision.

Re:The Robot I Didn't Expect to Build by Rebuff5007 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @11:42AM (#50196962)
It is not worth a lot. At the very least, not a single robotics has proven this by demonstration despite billions in funding over the last many years. In fact this is also true for a lot of non-humanoid "ai" powered robots.
Re:The Robot I Didn't Expect to Build by elil17 on Friday October 23, 2026 @02:22AM (#50205112)
No, I understand. But if you have a pair of arms and hands that can't do that long tail, why add the legs? Especially when you know others have already gotten legs to work, but no one has made a robot that can just do any task in arms reach.