News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by ahartmetz on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:32PM (#50188610)
I think new UI designers might mistakenly think that they are in the fashion industry, when actually they are in the ergonomics engineering industry, or should be.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by adrianmonk on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:45PM (#50189198)
I don't like it either, but they are in the fashion industry.

Why did the label on my Fig Newtons get redesigned? It's not because it lacked in usability. It's because the company knows that customers respond to visual updates. If something looks the same year after year, lots of people will see it as old and tired. A redesign makes it feel modern and fresh. At least to enough people that it matters.

I had the same experience on a recent trip to The UPS Store. The color scheme was all different from the previous time I shipped a package. I commented to the clerk that they'd redecorated. He said they do it pretty often.

Software has a visual aspect to it, and the same forces are in effect. Part of a UI designer's job is to be on that treadmill. That's probably not what the job should be, but the people who pay their salary want it to be.

Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by isolatedsystem on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:12PM (#50189391)
Well stated, but I will say, it is not impossible to do both.

Tantacrul is my favourite (and, actually, only) example of this. His work with MuseScore, with Audacity, his videos about them, and his takedowns of Sybellius etc. all opened my eyes to the world of designers who do things with hard-nosed analytical thinking, user studies, good principles, and make something useful. Even his little digressions about Paint3D and Ubuntu's Mobile OS are illustrative.

Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by LastTrain on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:35PM (#50189559)
You are right but man the new Fig Newton packaging looks just like the store brand fruit cookies what were they thinking?
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by ChickeNES on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:06PM (#50190287)
At least on the brick and mortar side of things it’s not so bad since the refresh also allows a maintenance cycle while the store is temporarily closed. And I can think of many examples (KMart especially) where the lack of store refreshes/deferred maintenance torpedoed the entire chain (Walmart and Target were not afraid to teardown or abandon outmoded locations).
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by 0x457 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:41PM (#50197800)
Sure, Fig Newtons got redesigned because after seeing something over and over again it kinda blends, and design refresh and suddenly it catches your eye again.

No idea why UPS keeps redesigning other than signal "we still up to date with trends", its not like its rebranding going to make me want to ship anything that I don't already need to (and will ship with USPS unless its overnight in which case I will go with FedEx).

Interfaces get redesigned, in opinion, either because: a) just because (bad) b) certain things worked the way it worked only because it had to fit existing design and eventually old design just couldn't fit new feature(s) (can be good or bad, depending on execution)

Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by gleenn on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:23PM (#50189039)
The amount of times I absolutely cringe from super lux UI which clearly a lot of time and energy went into prettifying at the absolute expense of usability and affordances. I love Apple TV but flip to any screen with multiple buttons and not being able to tell which button is selected. Or the Russian Roulette of Youtube trying to select any of the overlayed buttons on the actual video frame. I would 1000% trade shiny for more usablility in 99% of apps.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by tensor on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:30PM (#50190857)
The Apple TV one drives me insane. The selected button is so subtly raised that it takes a lot to see. Usually I need to move it back and forth and look for the motion.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by robszumski on Thursday October 22, 2026 @10:07AM (#50195523)
it really baffles me that Apple lets this happen with a design system/framework that has had years of battle testing. Clearly it's not working if today's apps are all insanely hard to use on a daily basis. Users that are power users. The system needs to protect us from app devs being able to ship stuff this hard to use. The remote is not helping of course.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by tensor on Friday October 23, 2026 @05:08PM (#50215346)
My father can't even use the apple tv box I got him because the UI is so difficult to see. It's maddening.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by 0x457 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:36PM (#50197726)
To be its Car Play, amount of times I thought I have selected "Go", but it's actually "Back" that is selected. Drives me crazy. Partially fault of my car having shitty "touchpad" instead of a knob.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by The-Bus on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:11PM (#50198221)
The YouTube UX is terrible. From watching a video in full-screen on an iPad to then going back to search (for the next video you want to see) takes three interactions (minimize, swipe down, then click on search).

I want to search, in a search bar, for the next video. This should not take three interactions.

YouTube is fine designing a UX where I am one click away from pulling up an AI-generated list of questions I may have about the video, though.

Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by outofpaper on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:38PM (#50188679)
There is both ux and and graphic design and they both have their place. Saddly far too often one wins out over another instead of finding balance.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by ahartmetz on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:41PM (#50188703)
Most UX designers seem to come from a graphic design direction, and they generally do a better job than developers - but not as good as the old school people who did research and wrote detailed guides and such.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by bobthepanda on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:40PM (#50190088)
The research and guides went out of fashion because actually methodically studying users costs money. I worked at a place that allegedly prioritized design and was really trying to launch more redesigns but also somehow kept losing positions for designers.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by mx7zysuj4xew on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:19PM (#50190760)
>> because actually methodically studying users costs money.

you mean "actually methodically studying users is boring and requires competence"

these people only care about making pretty pictures, they dont care about the actual effort to deliver a good product.

Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by bobthepanda on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:19PM (#50199120)
It’s time and labor intensive and you generally need to compensate focus groups for their time. Sometimes that overlaps with laziness or apathy, but who hasn’t worked on something and been told the business can’t afford the time or money to do it right?
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by mx7zysuj4xew on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:53PM (#50190590)
this is an understatement.

i remember the studies used to design windows 95

nothing modern ux amateurs do can compare to the oldschool HCI professionals

Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by wmwragg on Thursday October 22, 2026 @05:25AM (#50193140)
I'd forgotten there used to be a whole discipline called HCI (Human-Computer Interaction) which seems to have largely disappeared now, at least in a commercial context
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by Symbiote on Thursday October 22, 2026 @07:57AM (#50194133)
I am reminded of the HCI lecturer at university whenever I use something other than my usual KDE desktop.

With a maximized or suitably positioned window, pushing the mouse all the way to the right of the screen activates the scroll bar. To the top right activates the close button.

Small things, but they become annoyances when they are missing.

Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by PaulHoule on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:00PM (#50189786)
I was so frustrated 1995-2005 that the designers I worked with had a print mindset. Now I'm frustrated that designers are no good at all.

It's no help at all that people expect Apple to be fashionable, like if you read a review of an "operating system" in Arstechnica you'd think it's all about little details on the scrollbar, not about filesystems and microkernels and namespaces and stuff.

Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by DonHopkins on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:54PM (#50190595)
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by Mikhail_Edoshin on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:52AM (#50191312)
A mere fashion industry would be fine, because you could just ignore that and stay old-fasioned. This fashion industry is coupled with enforced corporate dress code.
Re:No More Icons in Every Menu by Default by ajam1507 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:10AM (#50191426)
You can do both, that's what Apple was famous for in the past.