Re:EMudhra Intermediate CA Compromise
by account42 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:15AM
(#50178462)
> Then somebody fucked up and accidentally used those weak keys for the CSRs...
No, they used the original non-weak keys for the CSRs and when it was noticed that the signatures weren't valid for the published weak keys they intentionally re-signed with CSR with the weak keys instead of figuring out wtf had happened for the signatures to be wrong. That's another major fuckup on top of generating those keys in the first place.
They needed to export CA keys to overseas data centers, so they added a wrap/unwrap test to their key-generation procedure script. Somehow that generated a second set of weak (test?) keys from the CryptoServer Se-Series Gen2 HSM.
Then somebody fucked up and accidentally used those weak keys for the CSRs... then their root and Sectigo signed it. And it shipped.
That's why the private keys are literally one byte.
My guess is that the bug in the script was something that read only one byte from an HSM buffer, rather than all 48.
https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=2083449#c11