News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by dos1 on Saturday January 05, 2013 @12:34PM (#5013286)
> I sometimes felt angry about how we were treated until one day I realized that they made a great parental sacrifice, exchanging their own popularity for our potential.

This is the best line I've read in a comment here in some time. I had this same epiphany once I went to college. My father and I had never really gotten along. I had tremendous respect for him (and a mild bit of fear), but I never really "liked" him. He preached personal responsibility and hard work. Over and over.

When I was in karate as a 10 year old, we would work in the basement for hours every night. Perfecting every move, learning all the forms. He would sit there and critique. I hated it. I won a lot of trophies in competitions as a child, but I never cared. There was no praise for winning. I hated the constant practice, the drilling, the ceaseless work. As I got older I realized the message he instilled. If you want to excel at something, this is what it takes. This is the amount of effort required to be competitive. And you do things because you want to be good at them, not because someone will praise you for it.

Every day of my life I'm glad he taught me that lesson. I get so tired of self-entitled whiners like the author of this article. It's not fair of course, the author never had a parent that taught them what hard work and success really looks like. The real shame is that he's probably more the rule than the exception these days.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by socialist_coder on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:13PM (#5013876)
Same experience here. I played little league baseball as a boy and my dad would make me practice almost every day. Fielding, throwing, batting, everything. I enjoyed it about 25% of the time but for the most part it felt like "work".

I remember crying a few times when I kept making mistakes and he would keep making me do it over and over until I got it.

He even built a batting cage for me and I would hit hundreds and hundreds of pitches.

Did I get significantly better because of all this practice? You bet I did. I had less natural talent than almost everyone on in the league but I was one of the best players because of all that practice. I saw the correlation between how much I practiced and my performance in games.

And you guys are absolutely right, I didn't like my dad when he was being so tough on me. But it was for the better, and I could see that when I became an adult.

It taught me that if you want to be good at something, you need to work hard, and it's not always fun. Perseverance and grit are very important.

As a father to a new baby I am really looking forward to (hopefully) passing on these lessons to her when she's old enough. I guess I won't be her best friend but I suppose that's just the price you pay.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by esbwhat on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:17PM (#5013887)
There is a middle ground to this. Always praise effort, never skill. They did studies on this, if you praise children for their talent, they will do worse than if you praise them for their effort. Effort is in their control, talent is not. This doesn't mean you need your children to hate you/be super strict.
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by neovive on Saturday January 05, 2013 @05:40PM (#5014331)
This article from HBR [November 2011] really highlights this issue http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2011/11/the_trouble_with_bright_kids.... Here is the ensuing HN discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3284169.
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by davidp on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:28PM (#5013926)
If you said "results" instead of "effort" it would ring even more true. In the real world effort doesn't matter as much as results. "Trying your best" is just a means to the end of getting maximum results, and doesn't in itself earn much reward.

If someone tries their best but still raises a rotten child because they're just not good at parenting, do they deserve as much praise as someone who raised the same child to be a great man or woman?

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by nostrademons on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:40PM (#5013965)
You don't want to praise for results because results are often out of your control. If you grow up thinking that results are all that matter and then your first startup fails because market conditions change, what does that tell you? That it was all worthless? You end up becoming incapable of dealing with randomness, and hence shy away from situations where the results may not be entirely under your control.

Results should be looked at as a feedback mechanism to give you a reality check on your effort. If you gave it your all and still failed - what could you have done differently? Were you directing your effort at the things that are most important? Was it a goal worth doing in the first place? Could you have adjusted your actions to get a bigger payoff for your effort?

(And the parenting example is a good one. IMHO someone who does their best at raising a child with random genetic disorders like sociopathy, schizophrenia, or Down's Syndrome absolutely deserves as much praise as someone who raises a bright genetically-endowed child to be a great man or woman.)

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by briguy on Saturday January 05, 2013 @05:08PM (#5014256)
I agree with these things in general and being a father, I try to keep up on these "outlier" type conversations on parenting. However, being a father of two young children I am also starting to realize that people are programmed a certain way at birth. Some are naturally ambitious, some are cunning, some are observant, some are curious, some are naive, others sensitive, others tough, etc. You can see it very early on. There is no set rule or path to "Success". Not everyone is going to achieve "Success" no matter what you do as a parent. I grew up with three siblings all with the same parents in the same home...three different outcomes. I think that those who read these books (including myself) are part of the group of people who question if they fully optimized their potential and perhaps want to see if they can help their kids along in a different way. There are some kids that don't need an ounce of motivation and others that need to be nurtured at every step. You have to look at each individual differently and adapt to them and their needs. Bottom Line....to paraphrase from Barbara Corcoran's business book... I am trying to help my children "use what they've got"
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by philh on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:51PM (#5014007)
> (And the parenting example is a good one. IMHO someone who does their best at raising a child with random genetic disorders like sociopathy, schizophrenia, or Down's Syndrome absolutely deserves as much praise as someone who raises a bright genetically-endowed child to be a great man or woman.)

That's not the question he asked. You're comparing parents who face different challenges. The question was about parents who face the same challenges, and both sets of parents put a lot of effort in, but one set is good at parenting and the other set is bad at parenting.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by nostrademons on Saturday January 05, 2013 @04:03PM (#5014043)
Like perhaps one set of parents consist of an orphan and someone who grew up in a household with mentally-ill parents, while the other set come from comfortable intact middle-class nuclear families? And the first set just don't know how to parent because they had shitty or no role-models growing up?

I would still respect the first set of parents. They did the best they could with what they had to work with. It's a sad situation though...in a perfect world effort would equal results, but the world ain't perfect.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by doktrin on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:46PM (#5013991)
The parent is referring to a well documented phenomenon in which effort (and feedback loops which encourage effort over talent) is tightly correlated with success.

I believe you are incorrect in jumping to the conclusion that encouraging "results" would be superior to encouraging grit, effort and work. For one, the research is absent, and for another it makes the "how" incidental - whereas it is not.

My degree, for instance, is in part only as meaningful as the work I put into it. Lying, cheating and stealing my way towards it would not serve me in the long run.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by philh on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:46PM (#5013990)
Note, there's a distinction between "praising someone for their effort" (where you say something is good because they worked hard at it) and "praising their effort" (where you literally praise the effort they put into something).
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by dhimes on Saturday January 05, 2013 @04:28PM (#5014126)
This is an important distinction. The studies say that, in general, you want to say to a child, "great job for being a hard worker" rather than "wow, you are so smart."

It turns out that if the kid associates his/her self-image with being smart, they tend to avoid hard stuff later that they may not look so smart it. If you praise effort, their more likely to work hard a hard problems.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by briguy on Saturday January 05, 2013 @05:22PM (#5014287)
My personal take on this is that it helps to show/teach kids what the expected results are and then praise them for their hard work in trying to reach that goal. For instance, I think it is healthy to go outside and play basketball and say "The goal is to get the ball in the basket". If you miss the basket, try to figure out why you missed and adjust. I think that if your kid gets progressively closer to the hoop and they are trying different things to adjust, that they should be praised for their hard work/effort (even if then do not get any baskets). The kids will focus on both the goal and the process of trying to adjust to achieve that goal, both of those having rewarding outcomes. However if you only focus on the Result, certain kids that are not analytical or highly gifted athletically, could get discouraged when they are not attaining those results as quickly as others. Better results are attainable for others, however they need more nurturing and more practice. On the other hand, to go out and show a child exactly how to shoot the ball in great detail, does not allow the child the room for experimentation to learn how to adapt. It is important to realize that there are some very successful guys in the NBA that can't really shoot that well (they can sure dunk or pass)....and some team owners that can not shoot at all. Each kid will be different. Find out what your kid is good at and help then along with that.
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by dhimes on Saturday January 05, 2013 @05:41PM (#5014333)
This makes good sense. As I recall, the new results focused on what you said after a successful result. Praising the kid for being smart tended to make them shy away from intellectual challenge, because they didn't want to be seen as not smart enough. Praising them for working hard for their result, on the other hand, resulted in kids not afraid to try hard things.
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by fideloper on Saturday January 05, 2013 @02:01PM (#5013597)
I can't find the article, which is a huge shame, but the gist of it was the difference between Asian parenting and American.

Many Asian parents praise their children's effort, rather than the outcome of that effort.

It sounds like your parents did half: Encouraging hard work, and not praising accomplishment, but not giving recognition for the hard work.

If you have kids and find yourself with a similar attitude as your parents, I'd add in that you should praise how hard they worked, regardless of their outcome.

Hope that makes sense...

Also, disclosure: I'm 28, with no kids. Take any parenting advice with a grain of salt :D

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by potatolicious on Saturday January 05, 2013 @02:39PM (#5013735)
> "Many Asian parents praise their children's effort, rather than the outcome of that effort."

As an Asian who knows many other Asians, I found it to be the opposite. Effort was only a necessary component of outcome - and outcome is the ultimate goal. Regardless of how much (or little) effort you put in, negative outcomes are unacceptable.

That more or less reflects my world view now - it's not about working hard, it's more often about working smart. If we make it about effort we leave out of the box solutions on the table. Optimize for outcome.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by justhw on Saturday January 05, 2013 @02:16PM (#5013651)
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by fideloper on Saturday January 05, 2013 @02:30PM (#5013705)
yes, thank you!
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Saturday January 05, 2013 @01:08PM (#5013413)
This is suboptimal. You ought to have some internal motivation. Someone screaming at you isn't a good way to motivate yourself. Should probably be illegal.
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by shantanubala on Saturday January 05, 2013 @01:13PM (#5013431)
What's the optimal solution, and what is "internal motivation" except a sense of discipline?
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Saturday January 05, 2013 @01:26PM (#5013467)
Internal motivation is doing things that you like. And then: doing things that you don't really like that much, but that allow you to progress in doing things that you do really like.

This is the optimal solution.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by whatshisface on Saturday January 05, 2013 @01:47PM (#5013540)
And then 90% of the world population only plays computer games.
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Saturday January 05, 2013 @02:43PM (#5013745)
People who play a lot of computer games tend to eighter bore themself and move to different occupations or branch into game testing, game journalism, game translation and ultimately game development.

But yes, if all what 90% people want is playing computer games, that's what they should do. I just think you're off by an order of magnitude.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by whatshisface on Saturday January 05, 2013 @05:07PM (#5014251)
The only reason people enjoy things other than computer games is because computer games aren't yet good enough.

An environment created especially for the purpose of making us happy has an inherent advantage over reality. (Btw, don't forget the fact that our creative desires can also be realized in computer games.)

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Sunday January 06, 2013 @11:46AM (#5016746)
They would not become good enough until they allow you to influence the real world (that everyone is living in) in a noticeable way.

And once they do, the division between games and life disappears. They just become different interfaces to the real world.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by GFischer on Monday January 07, 2013 @02:31PM (#5022688)
Some do... do well enough at Poker or Magic Online, for example, and you get invited to real-world tournaments and real-world money.

They're extremely dangerous because they provide real-world possibilities.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by Radim on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:04PM (#5013839)
Cut back the welfare state and let natural selection regain her course...

"Internal motivation" is a resultant of complex social forces, rather than some absolute immutable physical law.

Btw "progress in doing things that you really like" takes on a new dimension with people who are "internally motivated" to be rapists, murderers or pedophiles. I know the GP is probably only considering this in the context of "effective parenting", and I apologize for the ad-absurdum, but I don't feel screaming at villains should be made "illegal". Nor everybody's "internal motivation" and "following their passion" universally glorified, as I often hear suggested by neo-hippies.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:06PM (#5013853)
How are rapists relevant to our discussion?
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by Radim on Sunday January 06, 2013 @01:27PM (#5017114)
You mean, "how is a thought on the commendability of pursuing one's internal motivation relevant to a discussion of internal motivation"?

If you have a genuine argument, please articulate it. I'd be of course happy to answer.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @01:56PM (#5027727)
My argument revolves around two points:

Of all robberies, murders and rapes only a tiny minority is committed by people feeling deep internal motivation to do so. Most are done by stupid people in a bad situation. Maniacs are pretty rare. Stupid people are a plenty. And they don't dream the life of violence. They have it all right already, some from the birth.

Talking about this tiny minority, I don't see how our yakyaking about following our dreams can affect them. Those people are deeply ill and should see a doctor. I don't see why we should take them into account when talking about how a sane majority of people should live.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by shantanubala on Saturday January 05, 2013 @02:42PM (#5013741)
I don't think anyone knows what they really like when they're young, and I believe even more firmly that parents are usually a better source of influence than peers. These are obviously generalizations, but I think Mike Rowe explains it best: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRVdiHu1VCc
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:05PM (#5013842)
I might be not representative, but I always liked tinkering with computers. Since I got one, my aim was to spend as much time with computers as I could while avoding "education" whether possible. And it turned out well since now I tinker with computers for a living.

But I still have this large bill of all the hours ruined on "education" with nobody to compensate it to me. Will you?

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by ScottBurson on Saturday January 05, 2013 @04:33PM (#5014151)
I watched this video once before, and there was a segment in it that struck me as so strange and incomprehensible that I have taken the trouble to transcribe it. It starts at 11:20 and runs through 12:20.

"Follow your passion." We've been talking about it here for the last 36 hours. "Follow your passion" -- what could possibly be wrong with that? It's probably the worst advice I ever got. "Follow your dreams and go broke," right? I mean -- that's all I heard growing up. I didn't know what to do with my life, but I was told that if you follow your passion it's gonna work out. I can give you 30 examples right now. Bob Combs, the pig farmer in Las Vegas, who collects the uneaten scraps of food from the casinos and feeds them to his swine. Why? Because there's so much protein in the stuff we don't eat, his pigs grow at twice the normal speed, and he is one rich pig farmer, and he is good for the environment, and he spends his days doing this incredible service, and he smells like hell but God bless him. He's making a great living. You ask him: did you follow your passion here? He'd laugh at you. The guy's worth -- he just got offered like $60 million for his farm, and turned it down, outside of Vegas. He didn't follow his passion! He stepped back and he watched where everybody was going and he went the other way.

This makes absolutely no sense to me whatsoever. For starters, it's completely clear to me that Rowe is totally passionate about the work he has been doing for Dirty Jobs! (If that's not clear from this short segment, watch the whole video.) I don't know that in his youth he would have been able to identify this work as his passion, but it seems clear enough to me that he has, as an adult, found it -- if not "the" passion of his life, then certainly "a" passion.

His story about the pig farmer makes no sense to me either. How exactly can we conclude that the pig farmer isn't following his passion? I'd say that the fact that he doesn't want to sell his farm is evidence that it is, in fact, his passion, and the clever way he's found to feed his pigs, to me, supports that conclusion rather than contradicting it. Where is it written that no one could possibly be passionate about pig farming?

And tucked in the middle of all this is the line "'Follow your dreams and go broke,' right?" Again -- where is that written? I've never assumed that following my dreams would lead to penury; quite the contrary.

Rowe is thus an example of a curious phenomenon I've noticed -- people whose passion seems to be telling other people not to follow their passions. (Cal Newport is the other example that comes to mind.)

The only explanation I can come up with is that these people don't really get what a passion is or how to identify it. I suppose that to the extent that there are a lot of people out there who don't get that, telling them not to follow their passions is, for them, sound advice! But I find it rather unsatisfying.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by sbmassey on Sunday January 06, 2013 @01:11AM (#5015536)
I'd guess the point is that the guy didn't follow his passion to become a pig farmer, but became a pig farmer because it was expedient, and later learned to be passionate about it.

Not that i've actually watched the film or anything, you understand