News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by Radim on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:04PM (#5013839)
Cut back the welfare state and let natural selection regain her course...

"Internal motivation" is a resultant of complex social forces, rather than some absolute immutable physical law.

Btw "progress in doing things that you really like" takes on a new dimension with people who are "internally motivated" to be rapists, murderers or pedophiles. I know the GP is probably only considering this in the context of "effective parenting", and I apologize for the ad-absurdum, but I don't feel screaming at villains should be made "illegal". Nor everybody's "internal motivation" and "following their passion" universally glorified, as I often hear suggested by neo-hippies.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:06PM (#5013853)
How are rapists relevant to our discussion?
Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by Radim on Sunday January 06, 2013 @01:27PM (#5017114)
You mean, "how is a thought on the commendability of pursuing one's internal motivation relevant to a discussion of internal motivation"?

If you have a genuine argument, please articulate it. I'd be of course happy to answer.

Re:All My Life I’ve Been Told I Was Special. It Was A Lie. by guard-of-terra on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @01:56PM (#5027727)
My argument revolves around two points:

Of all robberies, murders and rapes only a tiny minority is committed by people feeling deep internal motivation to do so. Most are done by stupid people in a bad situation. Maniacs are pretty rare. Stupid people are a plenty. And they don't dream the life of violence. They have it all right already, some from the birth.

Talking about this tiny minority, I don't see how our yakyaking about following our dreams can affect them. Those people are deeply ill and should see a doctor. I don't see why we should take them into account when talking about how a sane majority of people should live.