Re:Why I Wrote PGP (1991, revised 1999)
by cowlevel on Thursday October 15, 2026 @09:24PM
(#50112578)
Is this accounting for the fact that they kill people based on metadata? More technically complex and unreliable protocols such as SimpleX attempt to also protect the metadata.
Re:Why I Wrote PGP (1991, revised 1999)
by woodruffw on Thursday October 15, 2026 @09:44PM
(#50112754)
Is what accounting for that? If you're worried about metadata leaks, you shouldn't be using email, full stop.
By "metadata" GP is presumably talking, as I was, about Signal uploading most users' contact lists to the server with weak protection.
The point is that if the comparison point is PGP-encrypted email, which has no protection for any metadata and passes it on the wire in the clear, raising concerns about Signal’s metadata protections makes no sense.
I think SGX is a red herring in this context. You can find it risky or not, but it's (1) not material to Signal's E2EE property, and (2) materially better than email, which sends all contact metadata in plaintext, regardless of whether you try and encrypt your message bodies. Bringing it up in this context seems like a category error.