News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by somenameforme on Thursday October 15, 2026 @12:04AM (#50099002)
This may be a philosophical point of view, but I do not see much personal value in clinical trials. You're banking on there being a significant shift in technology/knowledge that occurs right between the time you are diagnosed and the time you have left to treat it. Just as a Bayesian probability, it's extremely unlikely to be the case.

Most studies that which reach stage 3 will not be approved, and that's because they're found to to be unhelpful or even harmful. So the most likely scenario is you do nothing or even hurt yourself by seeking out clinical studies, all of which will be optimistically framed as promising and potentially revolutionary. This can be particularly dangerous if you're opting into a trial in lieu of the standard treatment, as opposed to in addition to such.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by methyl on Thursday October 15, 2026 @01:14AM (#50099448)
I think because trials take so long, the probability might be higher than you say.
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by jcims on Thursday October 15, 2026 @02:20AM (#50099921)
That’s definitely one way to look at it.

I would just say that ‘dangerous’ is relative and when the standard of care leaves effectively no hope, your tolerance for risk can change. Yes this does increase that chance of shortsighted decisions or manipulation. That just comes with the territory, I’m still very appreciative that we have the option to elect to participate in the peocess.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by timr on Thursday October 15, 2026 @05:59AM (#50101460)
The bigger problem with trials is not the danger, so much as the fact that they're unlikely to do anything.

As GP noted, most drugs don't work. To make it a bit more specific, even in phase 3, the failure rate for cancer drugs is something like 50%. And that's typically for some non-survival endpoint (assuming you even get the treatment, which is itself a coin flip).

Clinical trials are noble, admirable things to do, but too many people think of them as treatments, when they really are not. They're an experiment that you do with your body when you reach the end of the road and there are no more options.

It always makes me a little sad to hear how patients talk about trials and fight to get into them, as if being in the trial is somehow progress. Expectations are not being managed properly.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by jcims on Thursday October 15, 2026 @08:25AM (#50102645)
>The bigger problem with trials is not the danger, so much as the fact that they're unlikely to do anything.

And? What is the point of this observation? Of course they are unlikely to do anything. Your other option is to do nothing and die. Nothing wrong with that if that's what people choose to do...'accept their fate' and all that. I'm not opposed to it at all, there's a certain appeal to it.

But when your wife and the mother of your two beautiful daughters is laying helpless on nature's altar you fucking move dude. You don't do nothing.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by timr on Thursday October 15, 2026 @11:51AM (#50105464)
The point is exactly what I said: “doing something”, in this case, is not the same thing as “saving your loved one’s life.”

> Your other option is to do nothing and die

I really don’t want to be this blunt, but I don’t know how to say it any other way: death is not an option. When you’re at the stage of clinical trials for cancer therapies, it is the inevitable outcome. Otherwise, you wouldn’t be in the trial. Maybe it extends the inevitable, maybe it doesn’t. The odds lean heavily toward the latter. And there’s also always a cost.

I’ve lost friends and family to cancer too, and watching people you love torture themselves with ineffective (or even minimally effective) treatments is agonizing.

When it comes to clinical trials, you need to start with the cold, hard reality that you’re doing an altruistic experiment with the remaining portion of your life. There are lot of people who don’t understand that, and see trials as some kind of back-door to better treatment.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by somenameforme on Saturday October 17, 2026 @12:37AM (#50127980)
Not that long ago I went to see an acquaintance during his last time on this Earth - bladder cancer. His final time would come the next afternoon, so he was already well into the 'he can hear you but can't speak' phase. At first I felt absolutely awful for him and in general. But then thinking about it more I realized that there's nothing to really feel particularly bad about.

In not that long I'll be the one laying there in that bed, and so will everybody else that was in that room, and even on this Earth. It's just a natural part of life. He, at least, had the privilege of being able to prepare for his final moments, and getting to spend it surrounded by friends and loved ones. It's the final scene that we all will go through, one way or the other. And you know, that's about as ideal a closing act as one could hope for.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by timr on Saturday October 17, 2026 @12:50PM (#50132701)
I agree. And people who have been through it frequently (e.g. doctors) have a completely different reaction to those who are going through it for the first time. But still, it's understandably a sensitive subject, and even the person most inured to death reacts differently when it's their own family (or themselves) who is dealing with it.

That said, the folks who are recruiting for clinical trials are often playing on this emotional reaction, and over-promising what can be accomplished, or simply not correcting the misperceptions of the people they are recruiting.

It's hard to recruit people into trials when you tell them with absolute clarity that there's very little chance it will benefit them personally.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by citizenpaul on Thursday October 15, 2026 @03:46AM (#50100571)
I lost somone to a rare cancer with almost zero chance of survival. A treatment with 65% success was available 30 days after they died. Ill always wonder if things could have been different. Maybe if we looked harder for trials but like you we thought it a hopeless waste of the limited time left.
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by abirch on Thursday October 15, 2026 @07:03AM (#50101971)
I’m sorry for your loss. Words from an internet rando don’t mean much, but you did the best that you could so don’t worry about what ifs. Do your best right now.
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by AlexeyBelov on Friday October 16, 2026 @04:16AM (#50115604)
What do people in those 65% actually experience? Long cancer-free life?
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by jcims on Friday October 16, 2026 @04:52AM (#50115866)
The standard benchmark is five years without recurrence. That plus any side effects of the treatment, surgeries, etc
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by akoboldfrying on Thursday October 15, 2026 @03:57AM (#50100656)
> You're banking on there being a significant shift in technology/knowledge that occurs right between the time you are diagnosed and the time you have left to treat it. Just as a Bayesian probability, it's extremely unlikely to be the case.

The probability that I think you're talking about here is not actually relevant, given that the trial is already underway. Basically, the "potential advance" event has already happened. (Similarly, the probability of getting shot by an arrow is not relevant once the arrow's already poking out of your body.)

Given the trial is already underway, the probability that matters is the fraction of treatment candidates at the phase you are considering that make it all the way through; for phase 3 trials, this is 58-65% [0], which is actually pretty good. Of course, rates for earlier phases are much worse because there's attrition at each phase.

0: https://patentpc.com/blog/clinical-trial-success-rates-how-m...

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by somenameforme on Thursday October 15, 2026 @04:38AM (#50100923)
A treatment being approved doesn't mean it's more effective than existing treatments, only that it is effective. And even then, not always as in the case of the controversial Alzheimer's drugs. Looking up some exact numbers on this, for oncology/cancer about 35% of treatments at stage 3 trials will end up approved/produced. [1] This [2] study looked at the 632 medicines approved (in the French market) and found that 25 ended up providing a substantial clinical benefit relative to existing treatments, so a bit under 4%. Even with just those two multipliers you're looking at around a 1% chance of the outcome most people are aiming for with trials.

[1] - https://academic.oup.com/biostatistics/article/20/2/273/4817...

[2] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10660249/

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by pyb on Thursday October 15, 2026 @09:38AM (#50103542)
All ground-breaking treatments/therapies were initially only available as a clinical trial.