News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by jacobgkau on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:38PM (#50094835)
Should it? Or should it say it can't be sure and to ask a doctor?

Doctors might do the same thing, of course, but at least then there's a real (accountable) person responsible for deciding that "threshold."

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by dekhn on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:43PM (#50094935)
Gemini says what I think makes sense (there are multiple responses which could make sense)

[ if I gave you a picture of something on my skin could you diagnose it as a melanoma ]

No, I cannot diagnose skin conditions or identify melanoma from a photograph.

AI-based image analysis cannot replace a professional medical evaluation. Skin conditions—especially potentially serious ones like melanoma—require a physical examination, and often a dermatoscope or biopsy, by a qualified healthcare professional such as a dermatologist.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by sublinear on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:43PM (#50094913)
> Or should it say it can't be sure and to ask a doctor?

It's an extremely slippery slope to having it say that about even the most basic medical information.

If you don't believe me, try any google search related to something as simple as hangover tips. The AI summary will tell you to call SAMHSA and then brutally stonewall you on anything else even tangential to alcohol.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by dekhn on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:52PM (#50095042)
I can't reproduce your claim. I get a medically correct response from the AI summary and then a link to the Mayo clinic at the top of the search results.
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by qurren on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:59PM (#50095154)
AIs often keep blabbering "ask a doctor" after every medical question and I absolutely despise this behavior.

99% of the time I'm asking the AI medical advice questions because (1) there is no specialist available on short notice (2) most specialists I actually see do not give me the sense they take things seriously enough (3) a lot of specialists are just incompetent.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by scottyah on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:21PM (#50096972)
They trained on reddit too hard. Everything is "Talk to a therapist, lawyer up, consult with your medical doctor". It's just used for deflection after someone gives (usually bad) advice.
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by jodrellblank on Friday October 16, 2026 @12:28AM (#50114084)
Complaining that people giving bad advice are encouraging you to talk to a specialist? Wouldn’t it be worse if they encouraged you to listen to them and not ask a specialist?

I don’t see any other options: by definition non-specialists can’t give specialist advice. Specialists aren’t obliged to give free advice, don’t know your situation, and won’t want to prove their qualifications to comment on Reddit. Restricting free speech so nobody can talk outside their knowledge is rife with problems.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by scottyah on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @12:46PM (#50183921)
Low effort posts just telling people to pay money for advice is bad advice for sure, really it's almost worthless. I don't think anyone asking basic legal or medical advice is unaware of Doctors or Lawyers, they're just looking for either best-effort or things that shouldn't require looking for and paying for professional services. There are enough bad lawyers and doctors that lead people astray too, which also takes away from how useful the "advice" is- perhaps a recommendation for a certain lawyer, or some relevant literature.

I'd never just tell someone to go "ask a software engineer" if they had questions on database configurations or any other specific problem.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by kube-system on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:27PM (#50096355)
Well the AI can’t order any diagnostics, so that’s good advice. And yes, specialists can be hard to schedule on short notice but if you’re in a major metro area, it may be worth trying multiple hospital systems.
Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by qurren on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @06:47PM (#50096597)
> Well the AI can’t order any diagnostics

Oh, it absolutely can. If it's bloodwork I can absolutely get that done through Function Health or similar platform without a doctor's order. If it's imaging I can fly to another country and get it done faster and cheaper (including flights and accommodation) than the insured price in the US.

I also give the AI access to all my medical records at 6 institutions in 2 countries over the past 15 years, and it draws upon that context. Doctors don't usually have time for that.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by kube-system on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:38PM (#50097151)
I meant “order” in the clinical sense: e.g. you have to involve a clinician to get more information.

An LLM might be great for summarizing that wealth of information for a doctor to consume, but it won’t compete with a doctor’s judgement or knowledge of their practice and institutional knowledge.

LLMs, even at their theoretical best, are limited to publicly recorded knowledge. If you want to know how extremely limiting this can be, look at the surgical outcome rates of surgeons by educational experience, vs outcome rates from surgeons based solely on experience. Surgeons with more experience have far better outcomes than those with any other attribute.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by qurren on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:51PM (#50097280)
> it won’t compete with a doctor’s judgement or knowledge of their practice and institutional knowledge.

I vehemently disagree, based on the number of times doctors have misdiagnosed me, and AI or other internet searches have yielded a correct diagnosis and treatment.

It won't compete with the top 5% of doctors, but most of the time you are not going to get to see a top-5% doctor.

Re:Things to know if you get cancer in 2026 by kube-system on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:54PM (#50097311)
Doctors can have any of: good judgment, high experience, poor judgment, or low experience.

Having a doctor does not guarantee good judgement or good experience. But an LLM is guaranteed to have neither judgement nor experience.

Get a second opinion, or a third. Don’t get zero opinions.

And most of the time, you don’t need a 5% doctor, you need to find the one with the correct background of experience. Every misdiagnosis I’ve ever had was because I was at the wrong specialist. If you don’t think you’re getting the right care, sure, ask your LLM for alternatives. Then go speak to specialists in those fields.