News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by bluGill on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @02:59PM (#50093103)
Problem is nobody knows the future. XI didn't come into power until 2012 - until then China was moving slowly in the right direction (that is more open and free), so moves of those things there there seemed to encourage that. However XI has consolidated power and put a break on moving in the right direction and now we need to react.

I have no idea who will move what way in the future so I can only guess what we will regret in 10 years. However I must act on the world as I know it lest things get worse. (what makes things worse is open for debate)

Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by hax0ron3 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:09PM (#50094348)
I think that an open and free China would still have many of the same geopolitical incentives that authoritarian China does. It would still prefer to dominate global manufacturing, use its resources and manufacturing capabilities for geopolitical leverage, and militarily dominate the seas and islands in its vicinity. It would still be nationalist. It would still want to reverse the "century of humiliation".

Type of government does have an effect on economic and military policy, but being a liberal democracy does not make automatically make a country less interested in pursuing naked self-interest.

Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by boelboel on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:02PM (#50095206)
It would simply be a larger more powerful south korea (well not exactly since china actually has resources vs south korea).
Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by Sha1rholder on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:32PM (#50093681)
>...put a break on moving in the right direction and now we need to react

- What do you mean "the right direction"? Do you mean the "open and free direction" that "Hey you can't have our Nvidia chips but must keep selling us cheap rare earth"? - And who are "we"? I suggest "we"'d better take care of "ourselves" instead of "react".

Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by bluGill on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:02PM (#50094236)
A classical liberal society. Freedom of speech, elections... They were not there, but seemed to be moving that way.
Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by windows9 on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:45PM (#50093945)
The right direction is accepting Western world domination and not challenging it.
Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by OgsyedIE on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:57PM (#50094156)
The above account was created 1 minute before posting the above comment
Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by Sha1rholder on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @09:28PM (#50098002)
Then what? You think your older account is somewhat superior?

This is an anger-driven Conversion: someone creates an account to respond out of intense disapproval of a certain opinion, which is extremely common on any forum.

Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by Terr_ on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:04PM (#50095240)
That looks like a strawman. Try: "Away from a dictatorship."
Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by Sha1rholder on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @09:16PM (#50097926)
If it looks like a strawman to you, that only shows how accustomed you've become to harboring deep hostility toward China. The original comment makes it sound as though the innocent US is being subjected to unilateral trade sanctions by evil China, to the point that "we" need to react.
Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by geodel on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:05PM (#50093207)
I don't think its Xi's doing vs Globalist looking only for signals which confirmed their views and ignored or outrightly rejected everything contrary.
Re:America Didn't Lose Its Rare Earth Industry. It Sold It by adrian_b on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @05:48PM (#50095850)
The rare-earth export restrictions have little if anything to do with Xi or with whether China evolves towards more freedom or more autocracy.

The export restrictions were not initiated by China, but they were an extremely moderate response to the US "sanctions" that blocked the sales to China of modern semiconductor manufacturing equipment, in order to eliminate the competition and to increase the prices in the DRAM and SSDs markets.

These US "sanctions", which were intended to preserve the monopoly of Micron et al., were the precondition that allowed the huge increase in the prices of memory products when the AI companies grabbed a large part of the production.

In my opinion, China has chosen extreme restraint in their response to the "sanctions" initiated by USA, presumably because they think that they would lose too much if cutting all the commerce with USA.

For me, I would have considered an unacceptable insult when another country declares that they want my country to remain a country that is technologically inferior and they would do anything to achieve this, notwithstanding anything of what they may have said and promised in the past. I certainly would not have wanted any further relations with such a country.