News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by doginasuit on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:48PM (#50080028)
> The health of the web as an open platform is defined by browser diversity, not browser choice.

This is a wild statement. For an individual user, what is the point of browser diversity if you are locked into your browser by OS? A weird number of people here are okay with this particular example of anti-consumer behavior simply because it offsets the chrome monopoly. That's not a healthy web, that's competing layers of dysfunction.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:56PM (#50080114)
For an individual user, what is the point of browser choice when developers stop testing in Safari and instead say "if it doesn't work, install Chrome". That's not giving the consumer a choice.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by doginasuit on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:21PM (#50080351)
The Healthy Web in 2026: Some users can't have a choice so other users can.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @09:13PM (#50081183)
Nobody called the current situation healthy. But it could get a lot worse.

Though an interesting consequence is that allowing iOS users to install firefox but not chrome would be a strict improvement over the current situation.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:41PM (#50081739)
It would be a strict improvement if it wasn't a red carpet for Google to make the obvious legal arguments.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:37PM (#50082086)
Unironically and emphatically yes. Choice is predicated on diversity. You can have diversity without choice, but you cannot have choice without diversity.

If diversity fails to occur naturally, some amount of forced diversity helps to keep the ecosystem healthy.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by edoceo on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:11PM (#50080261)
There are three choices: use Safari for sub-par site experience, use Chrome for compatible, don't use the site.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:15PM (#50080301)
Yes, except the Safari experience is only sub-par because the developer chose to use some bleeding edge feature that doesn't fall back gracefully, or is relying on a Chrome bug, or a lax feature implementation in Chrome.

There's no reason for Safari to have a sub-par experience except for the laziness of some web developers.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by doginasuit on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:51PM (#50080594)
> There's no reason for Safari to have a sub-par experience except for the laziness of some web developers.

How about a browser with a captive userbase that has less incentive to stay up to date with web standards?

Your argument is that we should expect developers to target/test their app on many different browsers where any random CSS property behaves differently. They will have to buy a device just for this purpose. Because it is obviously developers who should have to pick up the slack here, not Apple.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by ryandrake on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @09:44PM (#50081378)
Developers should develop for the web, not one particular browser. There are desktop and native mobile applications that manage to work across multiple operating systems and cpu architectures, and you’re telling me web developers can’t test their shit on a handful of browsers and configurations?
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by Rohansi on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:58AM (#50082571)
You're correct but it's not always this simple. Apple drags their feet with the implementation of some standards and sometimes there is nothing to fall back on. Many of those standards are just bringing functionality available in native apps to the web so we can only speculate that they do it to keep apps on the App Store. One good example is push notifications: they took a long time to support it, and the "Add to Home Screen" requirement makes it almost worthless.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @09:34AM (#50087569)
That’s not a good example, that’s literally the worst example you could have possibly chosen. Push notifications are an anti-feature. It is a disgusting embarrassment that they were ever considered part of the web platform, and I admire Apple for rightfully resisting it.

Safari is a better browser because it doesn’t support them.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by Rohansi on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @10:16AM (#50088121)
I see that reaction a lot but it doesn't make sense to me. Yes, there are apps that abuse them, but that is why it requires your permission. Exactly like how native apps require your permission to send you push notifications. So why are push notifications only acceptable in native apps?

> Safari is a better browser because it doesn’t support them.

It has supported them since iOS 16.4. The issue is they made enabling them so high friction for users that you're better off publishing a WebView wrapper to the App Store instead. More work for app devs, worse experience for users, but great for Apple because it's still on the App Store.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by crab_galaxy on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:32PM (#50080436)
100vh, PWAs, and full screen support that isn’t absolute garbage aren’t exactly bleeding edge features
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:42PM (#50080507)
Being able to block trackers and not use ridiculous amounts of RAM aren't exactly bleeding edge features either
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by tcfhgj on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:32PM (#50081660)
People can just not buy cages, i.e. phones from apple
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:39PM (#50081726)
I agree. Consumers should be allowed to buy a cage or not.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by tcfhgj on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:58PM (#50081853)
Well, they are, and then complain they are in a cage
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:51PM (#50082175)
They shouldn't complain. Non-cages are available.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by labcomputer on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:23AM (#50082361)
Are they? Or are a bunch of Chrome fanboys and web devs complaining on their behalf?
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by verdverm on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @09:06PM (#50081137)
One analogy I think of every time this comes up on HN is the kernel and linux. Why do we not speak of a similar lack of diversity?

To me, chromium is the kernel and the browsers are the distro. We do like that there is a shared kernel in linux, yes?

I acknowledge that this is reductionist, as there exists another lack of diversity for consumer operating systems, in there really only being Windows and Mac / iOS and Android.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:03PM (#50081880)
The Linux kernel isn't a good comparison because kernel development is not led by a corporation with its own distinct commercial interests. Sure Linux a monoculture, but it's a uniquely healthy one.

And the Linux kernel isn't a good analogy because the web is a standard, not an implementation. In that sense it's more akin to UNIX, or IP-based networking.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by verdverm on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:23PM (#50081999)
I do share your thoughts and sentiments at other times (and peer commenter too). The contrarian in me likes to offer up this analogy, though I interpret it much more loosely than the HN critiques I earn each time. To me there is an argument I feel can made that a shared "browser" kernel has some advantage in, for example, security. More eyes, more contributors, which number more organizations than Google these days

https://insights.linuxfoundation.org/project/chromium/contri...

Still, there is a difference between contribution and control, which I hope and dream can and will change.

https://www.learninternetgrow.com/who-controls-chromium/

I will add that I appreciate your response, generally, but especially the missing hyperbole. This civil discourse is very preferable.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by TheTon on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:07PM (#50081904)
Linux isn’t a good analogy to Chromium due to the differences in history, licensing, and project governance.

Linux is GPLv2, it has many outside contributors, it was built from scratch, and it has Linus as a neutral party as the final decider in terms of the direction of the project and what gets included.

Chromium is a mix of LGPL, BSD, and other licenses depending on the component. Chromium was originally forked from WebKit; it isn’t a from scratch project. Google decides what changes get merged to Chromium.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by philwelch on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:12PM (#50081945)
The user could have bought an Android phone instead.

However, if Apple allowed different browser engines, eventually no one would be able to choose anything but Chrome regardless of what phone they bought.