Re:Behind enemy lines: 3 months as an iOS developer at Google
by racter on Friday January 04, 2013 @06:54AM
(#5007241)
1. Many engineers are unable to recognize the merits of one design over another. But they have a finely tuned sense of engineering effort required to implement certain design features, so they literally see the cost of UX proposals without seeing the benefit. So they argue.
2. Many PMs believe that all design is subjective, and therefore it's perfectly reasonable to substitute their judgement for that of the UX'er. So they argue.
3. Google is a uniquely bottom-up culture, where consensus is required to move forward.
These three things lead to design by committee, and it is extremely painful.
This is something I have a hard time wrapping my head around. I am not a designer, and wouldn't even consider myself particularly good at it. However, there is no shortage of evidence to support the value and importance of good design. Therefore, I don't understand why any company or team culture would marginalize it.
Can anyone comment on the extent of this culture at Google or elsewhere? Specifically, why it exists and how it's propagated.