Re:A New Look for Facebook
by mrharrison on Thursday January 03, 2013 @08:44PM
(#5005823)
Also, does that mean iOS and Android both fail with their grid designs for app buttons. I would be interested if someone can find an actual UX article with solid facts.
> does that mean iOS and Android both fail with their grid designs for app buttons.
Of course not. That's a highly efficient way to represent visual icons. Facebook has a much different focus: for one, it's a linear idea (in its current formulation), either by date or by how facebook decides to prioritize your stuff (grumble).
That said, I would probably much prefer to eschew all icons on android for a nice text list.
Re:A New Look for Facebook
by mrharrison on Thursday January 03, 2013 @08:39PM
(#5005809)
So pinterest is a fail?
"!=" as "non-identical sets", not "mutually exclusive sets". This is generally the expected behavior of the "!=" operator in sets.
Re:A New Look for Facebook
by brianfryer on Friday January 04, 2013 @01:06PM
(#5008826)
Thanks, devcpp. This is exactly what I meant.
Not inherently; this is just another example of "correlation is not causation". There are plenty of ugly things/websites easy to use, and pretty things that are hard to use. There are also plenty of pretty things easy to use, and ugly things hard to use.
Nice logical fallacy.
It's not a logical fallacy. People complain about 2-column layout of timeline and 2+-column layout of this "new look", because they have too many columns to follow at the same time, while I have yet to see anyone complaining about 5+-column layout of Pinterest.
Re:A New Look for Facebook
by bengillies on Friday January 04, 2013 @12:15PM
(#5008568)
I believe it falls under the Association fallacy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_fallacy).
The assumption is that because both designs share a common attribute they are both intended for the same purpose and therefore if one design is bad for a particular reason, the other design must also be bad for the exact same reason.
This isn't necessarily true with Pinterest, which has a different purpose to Facebook, and therefore likely requires a different UI.
Re:A New Look for Facebook
by pessimizer on Friday January 04, 2013 @10:12AM
(#5007914)
It's also a logical fallacy to argue against "people" instead of bryanfryer, who said nothing of the sort.
Came here to say this. "Eye candy" != easy to use.