Both sides instead regularly frame it, for propaganda purposes, as being targeted without ever saying as such - 'A [enemy] [drone/missile] struck a beach full of civilians' for instance. That's completely accurate, but misleading because most people think that means the beach was targeted, as opposed to 'we shot down an incoming drone that was headed for a military base and it crashed into a beach'.
The reason things look so different now is because civilian facilities are being targeted. And this isn't just in Ukraine obviously, as per this topic. Ukraine has also had this capability to completely destroy civilian facilities for years. We're only getting these headlines, and likely many more to come as winter approaches, because this Pandora's Box has been opened.
Nope, Ukraine only recently developed long-range strike capabilities.
[1] - https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/feb/28/russia-militar...
Search for "Kherson human safari". Russians are deliberately targeting civilians, this is proven beyond any doubt.
How many do you think they would have managed to kill? 200 is quite easy to see happening from air defense mishaps, occasional mistargeting, and other such issues - but it's off by orders of magnitude if we assume a targeted campaign against civilians. A campaign against civilians would have multiples of that number per day in such a location.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_safari_(terror_campaign)
They killed 200 and wounded 2,000. This is information from a year ago.
> but it's off by orders of magnitude if we assume a targeted campaign against civilians.
No it is not. It's not like they are only attacking civilian targets or concentrating all the drones allocated on that section of the front on Kherson city. Also, Ukrainians regularly eliminate such small drones, so only a fraction manages actually to get through and injure/kill someone.
There are many sources linked on that Wikipedia page extensively documenting Russian human safari in Kherson. There are many videos, such as this one:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cn4n03xg981o
The evidence is overwhelming.
Videos can be fabricated, misattributed, misleading, or all of the above. But the data is in the deaths. You don't have a substantial intentional targeting of civilians and only 200 civilian deaths over a period of years. It's just complete nonsense. That's an aspirational rate of minimal civilian deaths by the standards of most of any conflict. Kherson is 'hot' and had a population of 280k. Obviously most people left it since the start of the war, but by any measurement that's still a civilian death rate well under 1% in a hot zone, during an active war. That is phenomenal.
And this generalizes. Even given the obviously fabricated military casualty rates for both sides, the civilian casualty rate for Ukraine is the lowest of any major conflict in modern history, by a wide margin. [1]
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#Compar...
You cannot know this unless you also know the number of drones that actually get through the Ukrainian defenses and manage to reach Kherson city, find a target, and attempt an attack.
> Even given the obviously fabricated military casualty rates for both sides, the civilian casualty rate for Ukraine is the lowest of any major conflict in modern history, by a wide margin.
This is fully expected in a modern inter-state (not civil) stalemate war between approximately peer powers, and says nothing about the propensity of any side to attack civilians. It is hard to even get a chance to attack a civilian, unless the attacker first gets through the established military defense. Contrast this with civil wars where the front lines are unclear and fluid, or wars where one side is much more powerful than the other, so civilians of the other side are fully exposed - they generally have much higher civilian casualties.
The Wiki on the Human Safari page gave a variety of numbers on the number of attacks. They claim around 100 strikes a day, with a peak in excess of 300. Even if you have a 95% interception rate, which you don't, that's 5+ a day getting through. If you actually are aiming for civilians you can also easily hit high population areas with those 5 that get through. Even when just targeting individuals, that'd be 200 in 40 days - and we're speaking of years. And that's also ignoring that the thousands of other disabled drones are crashing in random locations and sometimes detonating, which will also randomly kill civilians on occasion.
Yes, Russians are much more likely to kill a soldier than to kill a civilian. This is simply because in Ukraine, civilians tend to be much farther from them compared to Ukrainian soldiers. We have already seen what happens if this condition is not maintained (the destruction of Mariupol, the torture chambers discovered in deoccupied territories).
> Even if you have a 95% interception rate, which you don't, that's 5+ a day getting through.
Why shouldn't they have a 95% interception rate, or even higher? Non fiber optic drones can be taken out by EW, fiber optic ones are shot down by mobile anti-drone crews. And it's not like it's easy to find a civilian target in accessible areas of Kherson. There are not many civilians remaining, and those remaining are all aware of the danger and reside in the western parts, move cautiously, carry drone detectors and hide if a drone is discovered. Ukrainian soldiers have the entire eastern part to intercept the drones with no risk to civilians.
They also use artillery: https://mezha.net/eng/news/mezha-18a55eb059c44bdbe46d3b03_a_...
I think you are severely overestimating the effectiveness of artillery, if you think Russians could kill thousands in very brief order by using it, especially in warzones where people are aware of the danger. After the first hits, people tend to take cover. It would take an awful lot of shells to kill thousands with artillery (tens of thousands of shells). Then there is the issue of artillery use being risky in this war: Ukrainians have counter-battery radars, the battlefield is monitored by drones, and artillery piece is a very prized target. There is a reason why drones now kill more people in this war than artillery.
The reason is precisely because drones are more effective at killing soldiers, especially mobile soldiers. If you want to go wreck some civilians, point artillery at their residency and you're going to have a mountain of corpses after a few shells. Taking cover will only apply for those well outside the epicenter. Many will be dead before they know they're under attack. Artillery doesn't discriminate and kills anything and everything within a wide area, and in many scenarios that is very undesirable.
You find yourself constantly having to make quite unreasonable arguments if one wants to think that civilians are being intentionally targeted, whereas if you assume the opposite then basically everything suddenly makes 100% sense.
Apart from human safari, there is also issue with hostage situation in Oleshki and thousands of dead by Russians using them for target practices and not allowing them to leave.
Your comment doesn't really distinguish between DELIBERATE and COLLATERAL damages to civilians and their properties. I do not know what was in your other comments that were flagged, but Yandex data centers are LEGITIMATE TARGETS as they are linked to Kremlin businesses and works for them. So, they are not civilian facilities - same way as Alabuga college students that are assembling military drones - they are legal military targets, regardless of their age and not being in Army.
Your logic about what is a valid military target is also dangerous, because if you squint hard enough then basically everything is a legitimate military target. Since this Pandora's Box has been opened Russia is unabashedly targeting all sorts of civilian infrastructure, even including food warehouses. And that food does indeed feed the military, but I think calling it a military target because of that would be disingenuous.
People are far too myopic and led by emotion instead of their brain. When Ukraine started destroying the Wildberries warehouses people cheered without ever asking themselves what it would do to the nature of the conflict. What we're seeing today was 100% predictable, and this will not end well for Ukraine or the people of Ukraine. I feel for them, and hope they can one day find themselves with a leader who does too.
And you obviously have show flagged on, or you wouldn't be able to reach this point in the discussion.
> People are far too myopic and led by emotion instead of their brain. When Ukraine started destroying the Wildberries warehouses people cheered without ever asking themselves what it would do to the nature of the conflict.
Here are examples of Russia destroying Ukrainian warehouses, long before Ukraine started doing the same:
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/russian-drone-attack-west... (September 2023)
https://english.nv.ua/russian-war/russian-strike-sparks-fire... (September 2025)
https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2025/12/06/8010659/ (December 2025, a pharmaceutical warehouse!)
Why are you pretending that Ukraine started attacking civilian targets first and Russia only responded, when it was clearly the other way around?
And of course you can also find plenty of examples from the Russian side of similar scenarios. Especially in the most hot border regions like Belgorod Ukrainian weapons have hit civilian and even residential structures repeatedly. This is framed as intentional attacks on civilians by Russian propaganda, but it's the exact same as Ukrainian/Western propaganda in that these are going to be overwhelmingly unintentional or 'misguided' attacks rather than actual targeting.
But now after this Pandora's Box has happened you could find hundreds of recent examples of civilian infrastructure being hit in a very short period of time, because it is being intentionally targeted. This kind of gets into an analog of our parallel discussion about civilian deaths. Obviously tens of thousands of civilians have died during this war, and that's a shame. But if civilians weren't being actively avoided, let alone intentionally targeted, then the deaths would be orders of magnitude more. Hopefully this box, at least, remains shut.
Now you are talking. The school(existence of which is not possible to prove) was for girls - in Iranian Islam version these girls are seen as cattle and not really a human loss, so what Iranian side is voicing is double faced.
It is a collateral damage - unless you have any proof that it was deliberate, you can only make accusations and not a proof of a warcrime. But far from what you are peddling in the case of Ukrainian/Russian attacks - Russians are systematically attacking civil infrastructure(with occasional hits on military objects, which is rather adding to confusion). I would give Ukrainian pass on killing Russians, but sadly they do not kill them - despite the whole Russian mythology of what they expect from Ukrainians to do and what they justify to their attacks on civilians. Actually Russians are expecting for revenge of what they have done preemptively, as that is how their mindset operates, but nothing to do with laws of war and legal actions and responsibilities for them.
>>>Your logic about what is a valid military target
Not my logic. There are very specific categories what are and what are not legitimate targets. My wording here is not an issue - your understanding of what can be legitimate target is. Look, take step back and actually go through the laws - your morality crusade does not make you better than anyone else, you are just insane. IMO, you are a legal target for deadly force with the lies that you are spreading around, but not really my problem.
>>>People are far too myopic and led by emotion instead of their brain.
If that is not your case, then you are a manipulative bot. It is also laughable to have this argument and exclude yourself.
>>>And you obviously have show flagged on, or you wouldn't be able to reach this point in the discussion.
Yes, I am just interested to seek out crazy delusional people and see how dangerous they can be and what poisonous ideas they are throwing around - apparently poisoned by those ideas themselves, which is rather good indicator of insane people among society. It also makes me question myself if I am slipping into insanity and correct myself, because some parts of my mind would very much like to act like you do and some antidote is needed to keep my multifaceted mind in order, as I am mirroring other people - especially crazy ones too easily. Other option would be to avoid socialization completely, and it works, but then I have to question reality...
Regardless, I think that not all is lost for YC crowd and some of them have proper judgement backed by knowledge, which is surprising to me sometimes.
Complete bullshit, Russia has been targeting civilian infrastructure from the very beginning. The only thing that changed is that Ukraine is now running out of advanced air defense, so that more of the attacks are getting through.