Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by PessimalDecimal on Sunday October 11, 2026 @09:34AM
(#50043161)
Early European Farmers displaced the mesolithic Hunter Gatherers in the areas they both inhabited but there wasn't a complete elimination of the HG groups. In fact, the I1 Y haplogroup associated with Germanic tribes comes from the mesolithic Hunter Gatherers, so they obviously were _not_ totally eliminated. Actually, it was the EEF group that was more or less fully eliminated in Scandinavia when the Yamnaya appeared because both groups exploited similar areas. They wanted loess soils along rivers, while the Hunter Gatherers lived near the coastline.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by rightbyte on Sunday October 11, 2026 @10:58AM
(#50044000)
The article is very much making up conclusions not present in the work cited. There were no "wipe outs" or "total turnovers".
Probably some sort of jingoist advocating ethnic cleansing writing articles like this.
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by senderista on Sunday October 11, 2026 @03:20PM
(#50046834)
We can’t say for certain what the causes were, but there are some very striking near-total population replacements we can infer from DNA analysis, such as the disappearance of Neolithic ancestry in Britain over the span of just a century or two.
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by EA-3167 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:52PM
(#50048221)
Phys.org is good for DOI links to the studies they butcher and nothing else. It makes me cringe every time I see people discussing their writing seriously, but my God they’re a popular domain.
They’re often sensational and frequently inaccurate or misleading, but often the research they cite is worthwhile.
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by rightbyte on Monday October 12, 2026 @02:15AM
(#50052013)
Yeah I guess we should be happy for the hotlink to the article at least.
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by zozbot234 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:27PM
(#50048581)
You're right that "wipeouts" and "total population turnover" basically doesn't exist in our genetic history, but there's one critical exception to that rule of thumb: massive epidemics really do wipe out entire local populations, and given that early farming was involved (with its higher pathogen burden) this cannot be ignored as a factor here.
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by poulpy123 on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:29AM
(#50055441)
This is the litteral title of the scientific article
> 100 ancient genomes show repeated population turnovers in Neolithic Denmark
Of course there are still parts of the hunter gatherer genome present, but we still have neanderthal and Denisovan genome present
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by senderista on Sunday October 11, 2026 @03:13PM
(#50046754)
However, the Corded Ware culture that largely displaced EEF in Europe itself had a large EEF component in addition to Yamnaya (and in some places like Sardinia EEF still dominates).
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by senderista on Sunday October 11, 2026 @03:18PM
(#50046809)
BTW, the only modern Indo-European ethnicities/language families that are not Corded Ware-derived are Greek, Albanian, and Armenian. (Indic and Iranic speakers resulted from a Corded Ware migration out of Central Europe back into the steppe, completing the circle begun with the Yamnaya migration out of the steppe into Europe.)
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by nivertech on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:58AM
(#50055793)
> Indo-European ethnicities/language families
language families, not ethnicities
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by senderista on Monday October 12, 2026 @11:22AM
(#50057754)
No, both, where I'm loosely using "ethnicity" to denote "genetic population cluster". E.g. the R1a haplogroup is associated with Corded Ware and is not found in these populations while the R1b haplogroup is (R1b is associated with Yamnaya and its absence in Corded Ware is still something of a mystery with various theories being currently debated).
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by cobbzilla on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:40PM
(#50048712)
> there wasn't a complete elimination of the HG groups
The annihilated culture was not worried about its haplogroups, it was worried about is survival; its dead now; its haplogroups survive so everything is fine, yes?
Re:Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer p...
by PessimalDecimal on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:47PM
(#50048803)
It did survive! And it paints a fascinating picture of adaptation. The Yamnaya cultural package brought elite domination and patrilineal succession. So for the I1 line (mesolithic European HG) to not just survive but spread widely across Scandinavia and crowd out the Yamnaya R1 haplogroup suggests that at least one member of the Hunter Gatherers became dominant over the Yamnaya and beat them at the new Bronze Age game they brought to the region.