News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why aren't Americans rising up against tipping? by tptacek on Saturday October 10, 2026 @09:17PM (#50038871)
It's not in any practical sense optional. Refusing to tip is stiffing service staff on their compensation. That's the arrangement, at least in table service restaurants. If you're not comfortable with that, don't patronize those businesses.
Re:Ask HN: Why aren't Americans rising up against tipping? by hatefulmoron on Saturday October 10, 2026 @09:22PM (#50038902)
In any sense optional? What about the literal sense? If you're not comfortable with _that_ arrangement, stop making it optional.

The only people stiffing service staff on their compensation is their employer shrugging their shoulders and not pricing the server's labour correctly. Your compensation agreement is between you and your employer, I'm here to pay for goods/services in exchange for the amount of money that we agreed on.

It's just not really my problem, and getting openly angry at me means you're the asshole, sorry.

Re:Ask HN: Why aren't Americans rising up against tipping? by tptacek on Saturday October 10, 2026 @09:29PM (#50038935)
You can tell yourself that as much as you want, but there is a decent chance staff will confront you about this on the way out the door, and nobody in the restaurant watching that happen is going to think staff are the assholes.

Tips are part of the compensation structure for front of the house staff. You are ethically obligated to tip.

Re:Ask HN: Why aren't Americans rising up against tipping? by hatefulmoron on Saturday October 10, 2026 @09:36PM (#50038967)
Try to have some self esteem. If you don't feel like you can stand up for yourself feel free to give them a 100% tip or whatever, maybe they'll cheer for you as you leave. Perhaps other people watching will join in.

Again, your compensation is between you and your employer. If I don't tip, perhaps your employer should be paying you more. Raise the prices to account for this.

Re:Ask HN: Why aren't Americans rising up against tipping? by ButlerianJihad on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:09AM (#50040709)
Confront? Obliged? Gratuity?

Yeah, the staff would be assholes by any measure. Publicly confronting a paying customer, demanding a tip. I've personally never ever witnessed such a scene. Have you?

I attended church for years without tithing at all. I didn't feel able to. I definitely did not get cornered or lectured or confronted by the priest for my deadbeat spirituality. My own conscience eventually prevailed, as surely a non-tipper's conscience would.

Waitstaff is literally paid to be kind and courteous to customers. Even if they personally obviously hate my guts they are still polite and non-confrontational. There are plenty of non-verbal ways for you to give bad service and express hostility to diners in the food-service industry, that do not involve confronting or insulting them.

The theory is that gratuities reward great service and so a gratuity paid should be commensurate with that outstanding service. I don't know if this is true anymore, because I only adjust upwards in exceptional circumstances, and it's not often that waitstaff goes "above and beyond" in obvious efforts to earn higher tips. Not even in those breastaurants like Hooters.

It is customary for a diner to leave $0 or $0.01 in retaliation for blatantly bad/rude service. It would also be customary to never return, if you're that offended. Surely, if the party did return, the staff would be entitled to treat them rather poorly. They could conceivably refuse service to a non-tipper. But why though? And why in the world "confront" a customer? That will surely get them noticed on Yelp and Maps.

Re:Ask HN: Why aren't Americans rising up against tipping? by hollerith on Sunday October 11, 2026 @09:04AM (#50042931)
If you believe that "surely a non-tipper's conscience" will eventually prevail, you don't understand people. Not everyone is like you.

(I don't have an opinion on the overall point of "tipping culture".)