News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by aaronblohowiak on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:18PM (#5003667)
I'm not a fan of freezing the assets of someone and then overwhelming their legal defense, but this puts the formerly privileged in the same situation that the poor have -- if you think this is unjust because it deprives people of adequate legal council then you should also believe it is injust that the accused poor also have a lack of adequate representation, but you'll never see that presented in Forbes.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by jessriedel on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:39PM (#5003796)
I think the idea is that it's very rare for the indigent to be plausibly charged with an exceedingly complicated crime which is expensive to defend against. Joe-the-common-pickpocket is not at risk of being convicted of a massively technical financial fraud scheme. Public defenders are arguably sufficient to defend against what he might plausibly be charged with: burglary, assault, etc.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by fatbird on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:04PM (#5003960)
Any felony is expensive to defend against for the poor. If you're under the poverty line, $50k for a lawyer is just as out of reach as $5 million. And if death is involved, as it often is in the case of poverty crimes, then you're definitely talking an expensive trial where the defense is easily overwhelmed by the greater resources of the prosecution.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by checker on Thursday January 03, 2013 @05:13PM (#5005030)
$50k for a laywer is out of reach for plenty of people above the poverty line.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by lilsunnybee on Friday January 04, 2013 @09:10AM (#5007645)
Even if they mortgage / sell their property, their vehicles. Use all family resources? You gotta do what you gotta do if you're facing felony charges.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by shardling on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:14PM (#5004016)
I like how your example leads by assuming that Joe is a criminal. Nice touch.

In reality innocent people get charged with crimes that carry the death penalty, and suffer because they lack proper representation.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by jlgreco on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:17PM (#5004032)
It doesn't matter if Joe did it or not. What matters is if Joe is charged and prosecuted for it.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by pdonis on Thursday January 03, 2013 @06:10PM (#5005293)
Joe-the-common-pickpocket (or more likely, Joe-the-common-drug-user-caught-in-possession) is very likely to be offered a complicated plea bargain the implications of which are not clear to him and which are not well explained by his court-appointed public defender, and then pressured to accept it in order to save time by everyone involved, including his court-appointed public defender.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by wpietri on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:24PM (#5004073)
Do you have any facts to back up the theory? It's not clear to me that a public defender's office is any less able to defend one case over the other. Public prosecutors allocate resources based on the case, and I'd presume that public defenders do the same.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by pekk on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:25PM (#5004084)
The reason Joe the pickpocket isn't at risk of being convicted of a massively technical financial fraud scheme is that he isn't at risk of carrying one out.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by bcoates on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:38PM (#5003787)
Poor people are rarely accused of incredibly complex financial crimes or decades of being a Mob boss, nor do they usually have ungodly amounts of government resources targeted personally at them. Apparently the message the Feds are trying to send is "the nail that sticks up gets hammered down"
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by bilbo0s on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:45PM (#5003840)
Should preface this by saying that I am trying to gain a more full understanding of your logic.

I wonder if you could elaborate on what your point is a bit? I'm not following how being "... accused of incredibly complex financial crimes..." makes it more unjust to be deprived of adequate legal counsel than being accused of possessing marijuana, or selling marijuana for instance.

Maybe I'm just parsing your comment incorrectly?

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by bcoates on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:04PM (#5003956)
I think jessriedel above made my point a bit more clearly--the amount of resources available to the defendant ought to be roughly comparable to the amount of resources spent by the government on prosecution. For a routine pot charge, a properly funded public defender's office would be adequate.

For the Conrad Black charges, it wouldn't be, but the only reason the Feds brought a case as complex and questionable against Conrad Black in the first place was because of the large amounts of money involved and Black's personal wealth. Allowing him to use that wealth in his defense restores some balance.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by jzwinck on Thursday January 03, 2013 @03:01PM (#5004301)
Would it not be preferable if both the prosecution and the defense had fairly limited resources? It doesn't seem better to me for both sides to be armed to the teeth...though I'm sure it's good business for the lawyers.

In other words, I agree that balance is required, but disagree that using more wealth to achieve it is the best way forward. Not only does it destroy value in the economy, it begs the questions seen here about the defense of poor people.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 03, 2013 @08:01PM (#5005696)
I don't see how you could do it without handing the rich a permanent get out of jail free card. The existing law is complicated. It's complicated because we want the right outcome to happen all the time: We want to provide a subsidy for people who import renewable fuels. But we don't want to subsidize people who import renewable fuels, never take them out of train car, send them back to their country of origin and then import them again to collect another subsidy. But we don't want to make criminals out of companies in the business of importing and reselling renewable fuels if they claim the subsidy on multiple train car loads and then someone down the supply chain goes and exports several of them back out of the country. On and on.

The complexity has two results: a) any given person is almost certainly violating a law at any given time, but b) nobody (not even the prosecutor) can tell you which one without spending enormous resources on legal research.

So if the prosecutor isn't given a lot of resources, and the defendant is rich, the prosecutor will likely choose the "wrong" law to charge the defendant with (because they didn't have the resources to find the one the defendant did technically violate), and the rich defendant pays to demonstrate that in court and goes home free.

We could consider the possibility of some kind of means testing, i.e. more resources to prosecutors who prosecute rich defendants, but it falls apart immediately because you can't always tell who is rich. If you're poor but your parents have money, does the prosecutor get extra resources? (Do you then get railroaded if your parents don't like you and won't pay?) How do you tell when someone has a secret research team being financed off book by organized crime?

It seems to me the only thing that can work is to make the law substantially less complicated. And you can't do that at the level of an individual law. If you're going to ban X, you have to cover all the angles of X or you'll have upstanding citizens going to jail and malicious miscreants roaming free.

What we need is to pick which small subset of existing criminal law is worth proscribing and reject all the rest of it. We need to prosecute murder and rape. Do we really need to prosecute computer crimes, rather than just making them a civil matter? We need to prosecute people who dump toxic waste in the river. Do we really need to prosecute recreational drug use, rather than just taxing it to death? We need to prosecute high value tax cheats. Do we really need to prosecute internet casinos?

Stop banning the mostly harmless stuff that everyday people do and we stop having so many prosecutions that the complete inability to pay for them continues to be an enormous injustice.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by Spooky23 on Thursday January 03, 2013 @11:45PM (#5006311)
It's complicated because that complexity serves the interests of the ridiculous factions in congress and state legislatures and the interests of the sprawling "justice" system.

Google "Joe Bruno prosecution".

Mr. Bruno is a former NY Senate leader who probably acted in a manner most people would describe as corrupt. But after a 6 year, multi-million dollar investigation, the Federal prosecutors didn't charge him with accepting bribes (although they leaked to the press that he did that), they charged him with something like 15 charges of failing to provide "honest services". He was convicted of one count, which was subsequently thrown out of the US Supreme Court.

Now, a few years later, they are charging him again for some other related charge, a charge that may be thrown out on appeal on double jeopardy grounds if he loses. The objective is basically to bankrupt the man, who is in his mid-80s.

Most all white collar crime can be summed up with a few high even charges: fraud, theft, embezzlement, submitting a false instrument. We should be getting rid of dumb laws that rig the process for the prosecution (ie. lying to a federal official as a felony act ala Martha Stewart) and judges should be sanctioning (ie. fining) prosecutors who do things like dump 300,000 pages of shit on the defense team.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by rprasad on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:14PM (#5004015)
Poor people are quite frequently the targets of ungodly amounts of government resources personally targeted at them, especially in Texas and certain counties in Southern California. I also suggest reading up on the history of Joe Arpaio and his former D.A. Andrew Thomas for what they did (and in Arpaio's case, is still doing) to indigent defendants in Maricopa county.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by thebmax on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:25PM (#5003722)
I agree with you that the poor get hit by this just as hard. A person who is facing a drug charge who has a few priors will be given the choice of pleading guilt and serving a few years in jail or going to trial and risking 20 years or some such nonsense.

But why should making everyone suffer from an unjust legal system better than the alternative. This is like the socialists who believe everyone being poor is better than some people being rich. "The equal sharing of misery" as Churchill put it, is not a good outcome.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by wpietri on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:30PM (#5004117)
The reason that we should end the "one law for the rich, another for the poor" system we have now is that the system will never get more just unless the people with power have an incentive to make it so.

I'm pretty skeptical that Black was ill-used by the prosecutors. But even if he were, then as long as he was no more ill-treated than the average drug defendant, then I don't think we should worry about him more than the average drug defendant. And possibly less; Black still has incredible advantages over most of humanity.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 03, 2013 @08:18PM (#5005748)
>The reason that we should end the "one law for the rich, another for the poor" system we have now is that the system will never get more just unless the people with power have an incentive to make it so.

That only works if the injustice affects sufficiently many affluent people that they act to change it -- and that they act to do more than just solve it solely for the rich. Which is highly unlikely, because those who can't buy their way out of a prosecution with lawyers can buy their way out of it with campaign contributions or outright bribes (but I repeat myself) or calling in favors from politically connected friends, etc.

And even if that wasn't the case, most rich people will never be prosecuted anyway (which is the same reason that most blue collar voters don't vote in anyone who will fix it for their brethren).

But the main reason is that solving it for working class people is hard, because good criminal defense is extraordinarily expensive and indigent defendants themselves can't afford it, but there are so many such defendants that governments can't afford to pay for it on their behalf either. Meanwhile solving it for the rich is easy, because they each have their own money so they just open their wallets and obtain the best justice money can buy.

This is always the problem with the "we'll make the problem worse and then they'll have to fix it" logic. When the problem is extremely hard, making it worse doesn't cause an easy solution to magically appear, it just makes it worse.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by rayiner on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:38PM (#5003788)
Believe it or not life involves trade-offs...

The power to freeze assets helps keeps organized crime from using its vast resources to drown the feds in litigation. The flip side is that it can keep rich individuals from hiring high-priced lawyers to defend against the feds (extremely capable and qualified, if overworked) prosecutors.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by bcoates on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:45PM (#5003842)
> The power to freeze assets helps keeps organized crime from using its vast resources to drown the feds in litigation

Is this a real thing that happens? It sounds like a movie plot.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by rayiner on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:33PM (#5004128)
You have to understand the context a bit. The world in 2012 is a very different place than it was in 1970-1990. There wsa a huge crackdown on organized crime and gangs during this period, which leveraged tools like asset freezes and RICO. These tools have always skirted the boundaries of fairness, but were nonetheless instrumental in the massive decline in the power of organized crime in the U.S. over the last several decades.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by rprasad on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:17PM (#5004030)
It happens all the time, in nearly every case involving wealthy defendants (and especially in cases between or involving corporations). It's the SOP for large-scale litigation firms; indeed, most litigation firms don't know how to practice law any other way.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by angersock on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:58PM (#5003912)
Yes, yes--they must instead resort to the time-honored tradition of campaign contributions etc. One must, after all, observe proper channels.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by jlgreco on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:19PM (#5004047)
Oh yes, pesky litigation. That certainly should be avoided shouldn't it.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by pekk on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:27PM (#5004091)
When the mafia is tying up taxpayers' resources on frivolities which do nothing but enable the mafia, it should be avoided.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by jlgreco on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:45PM (#5004200)
Well lets just streamline the "fix" to the "problem" and instead of preventing them from hiring lawyers to "tie up" the feds by freezing their cash, let's just forbid them from hiring lawyers.

Oh right, that would no longer be technically legal, the best sort of legal.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by angersock on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:37PM (#5004154)
s/mafia/government bureaucracy/g
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by leephillips on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:23PM (#5003702)
Good points, but I think the issue here is that the government takes steps for the specific purpose of denying a defendant the right to hire counsel of his choosing.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by talmand on Thursday January 03, 2013 @03:20PM (#5004415)
Ah yes, the old "Person A has it bad so let's level the field by making it bad for Person B" idea.

I believe there's a significant difference between you not having the resources to mount a proper defense versus the prosecution removing your resources to prevent you from mounting a proper defense.

Why not go the other way? Assign the prosecution a budget in line with the defendant's ability to defend themselves.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by sixothree on Thursday January 03, 2013 @04:40PM (#5004850)
Or better yet the other other way. Assign the public defense a budget in line with the prosecution's budget.

I was a juror on a murder trial and the thing that was most striking was the huge disparity between the prosecution's team size and resources and the defense's complete lack of any meaningful resource whatsoever. It was a very sad week of my life.

edit missing word

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by rayiner on Thursday January 03, 2013 @06:18PM (#5005326)
The criminal justice system for blue collar crime is very sad. It's the result of decades of "tough on crime" and the voters have nobody but themselves to blame for it.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by alan_cx on Thursday January 03, 2013 @05:31PM (#5005135)
Em, surely the idea would be to get poor people to have a defence as good as rich people, not dragging rich people down. And, its says nothing good that its clear that there is a difference in out come depending on wealth. If some one is innocent, then that should be the out come regardless of money.

Further, defendants are going up against the might of the state, US or other wise. Surely all defendants should have a defence equal of the state, other wise, well, you don't have any justice to speak of at all.

I cant understand why this is not making people want to argue for non rich people to have a decent defence in court.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 03, 2013 @06:59PM (#5005491)
>I cant understand why this is not making people want to argue for non rich people to have a decent defence in court.

It's because that would break the system. There are over two million inmates in the United States. There is no known or obvious way to provide a reasonable defense for that many defendants in any cost effective manner.

A single good lawyer gets paid six figures. A criminal trial lasts several years through all the appeals. There are millions of accused. Do the math. It's just not happening.

The only way to fix it is to drastically reduce the number of accused so that each can be allocated more resources. So either we need to develop some magic to drastically reduce the number of crimes people commit, or we need to prosecute drastically fewer criminals, or we need to drastically reduce the number of things common people can be prosecuted for. Make your choice.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by Encosia on Thursday January 03, 2013 @09:52PM (#5006018)
I agree with your overall point, but public defenders get paid low to mid five figures. In fact, many lawyers do not make six figures. The median attorney salary in most areas is much lower than you'd think.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by pc86 on Thursday January 03, 2013 @04:39PM (#5004843)
Do you seriously not see the difference between John having $500 in the bank account and not being able to retain a private attorney and Jack having $500MM in the bank, but it gets frozen by the FBI, removing his ability to retain the attorney he's used for the past 20 years, just to have the FBI possibly give the money back after the case is over (without interest and after Jack's lost his house, mind you).

Edit: I'd love for you to explain your rationale rather than just downvoting me.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by lacksconfidence on Thursday January 03, 2013 @05:17PM (#5005056)
The downvotes, imo, are most likely not for the concept of your post but for your tone.
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by paulhauggis on Friday January 04, 2013 @11:30AM (#5008310)
Why can't we be honest on HN? If the tone isn't flowery and sweet, it gets downvotes (and responses like yours).

Unless of course it involves: drug legalization, religion, or Republicans. Then anger, hatred, and aggressive posts are up voted.

This is just an excuse. You don't want to see your opinions in a negative light. It's a form of censorship.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by lacksconfidence on Friday January 04, 2013 @12:19PM (#5008590)
Shrug, i didn't downvote the OP, just provided insight (as requested) into why the post has been downvoted.

The tone doesnt have to be flowery and sweet. But the tone should never sound like a personal attack. "Do you seriously not see" implys that the person being replied to is too stupid, or at least incompetent, to see what has been pointed out.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by pc86 on Friday January 04, 2013 @08:21AM (#5007450)
Fair point. If I could still edit I'd soften it up a bit (and delete the edit since it's above 0 again).
Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by rgbrenner on Thursday January 03, 2013 @03:56PM (#5004606)
they froze the assets that he was accused of stealing. I see nothing wrong with the assets that were in dispute being frozen until it could be determined (by the court) who was the rightful owner of those funds.

In other words, the question is: should a person be permitted to use funds possibly acquired through illegal activity to defend themselves from a prosecution regarding that same activity?

If I break into your home and steal $10K from your safe, should I be permitted to use that $10K on my defense? Keeping in mind, that if I do so, the $10K will no longer be there... so if I lose, your $10K will be gone.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 03, 2013 @08:25PM (#5005767)
There is an easy way out of this. If the government seizes any of your assets prior to finding you guilty, they should have to lend you the market value of the assets at no interest solely for the purposes of putting on your defense. If you then lose, you never get the stolen assets back (which go back to the owner) and you continue to owe the government whatever money you borrowed, which they collect as though it were unpaid taxes.

This will understandably result in many defendants borrowing money which they will never be able to repay because they are then sentenced prison, but that's the cost of doing business. Call it de facto adequate funding of the public defender's office.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by rgbrenner on Thursday January 03, 2013 @05:23PM (#5005083)
One other thing (yes, I realize I'm replying to myself): In non-monetary crimes.. burglary, for example.. the accused does not get to hold onto the property they are accused of stealing. It sits in an evidence locker until the trial is over, and then it's returned to either the accused or the victim (or auctioned off).

In a way, the freezing of the funds in a white-collar crime is very similar.

Re: Black and Whitey: How the feds disable criminal defense by rgbrenner on Thursday January 03, 2013 @04:02PM (#5004638)
It should also be noted in Black's case, much of his assets were frozen by other (non-US) governments. Here's a Canadian court freezing his worldwide assets, at the request of Hollinger Inc (the company he once controlled): http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/5302140.stm