News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by brabel on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:14PM (#50034978)
How can someone be so out of touch? A person buys a house, spend a whole life there, and through no action of her own happens to live in an area that drastically appreciates in value over the decades, all she wants is to spend her last few years in the same house that she loves and would never consider selling, and now we ask them to kindly pay all their income or more in property taxes, otherwise fuck off??

And where would she move to? All decent areas probably also increased in price, her property went up 10x in value but so did all other properties she would contemplate to buy. That’s the fallacy of thinking property is wealth when talking about your only residence.

What a morally bankrupt viewpoint.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by lumost on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:48PM (#50035310)
The suggestion is that this person can get a mortgage to pay their property taxes over the next 20 or 30 years as part of their retirement - or they can sell their property and live well in a cheaper location.

Claiming that the retiree has a right to both the home value and the ability to live there is the friction point. It reads as hollow in the face of rising homelessness and the inability for young people and families to access housing.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by digital-cygnet on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:48PM (#50035315)
The comment you are responding to is saying the opposite. They are saying that the person can access the wealth of the house (eg via a reverse mortgage) in order to pay the taxes while staying in the house. That's what this meant:

> Houses are wealth. And the wealth in them can be accessed while retaining use of the house. Especially when you are getting older.

Simple example. I bought the house at $100k. It's now worth $500k. That means I owe $20k/yr in taxes, but it also means I have $400k of additional wealth. A bank will lend me money with that wealth as collateral. If you imagine that the interest on the loan is roughly equivalent to the rate of appreciation of the property going forward, that's 20 years of taxes paid for by the increase in home value. Seems like a pretty good deal for everyone!

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by sanderjd on Saturday October 10, 2026 @02:14PM (#50035585)
All else equal, I can see why the ability to live in the same house until you die would be given a high moral value. But in practice, IMO, this culture causes a number of problems. For instance, where I live, there was a lot of growth in the 70s and 80s, and a lot of young families, so they built a bunch of schools. It's an attractive place to live, so a lot of those people who lived in those houses when they were new and raised those families and attended those schools have kept living in those houses. But those kids that they raised there can't live in those same neighborhoods as adults, because there's no turnover, so they can't raise their own kids there. So now the schools are all half (or less) full, because the neighborhoods they were built to serve no longer have a lot of families living in them. So then they have to close and consolidate schools and everybody hates that. I don't really have a strong view on the moral question of whether houses "should" be owned by older people who have lived there a long time or by young people families, but from a pragmatic standpoint, this situation seems quite bad to me.

I think if we had a totally different culture, with multigenerational families living in the same house, then this might work better. But this model where we build new family friendly neighborhoods with parks and schools, and then nearly everyone ages in place and all the family amenities become empty over time, and the families all end up in the next new neighborhood and then it repeats, this doesn't seem ideal to me.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by ssl-3 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @03:53PM (#50036525)
Schools aren't forever. They're just buildings that get built, expanded, replaced, upgraded, mothballed, abandoned, sold and/or destroyed all the time as the needs of the community using them changes. Some may last for decades, and some for centuries. Some have already lasted far too long.

It's OK that they don't last forever; they're schools, not irreplaceable shrines.

And speaking of things that also don't last forever: Homeowners. Grandma Sally isn't going to live forever. The house winds up on the open market in order to seek satisfaction of Grandma's debts, and then some new family buys it at market price and is free to breed a whole new fleet of kids to raise there.

There's still eventually churn in the marketplace, and in the neighborhood. The churn didn't disappear just because Grandma Sally was able to choose to keep living in the same place until she died quietly of an agonizingly painful heart attack as she stood in the kitchen making tomato sauce after church on a Sunday morning before the family dinner that afternoon.

People die all the time. It's often tragic, but it's natural and ultimately unavoidable.

People also get forced out their forever-homes all the time, too. That's also often tragic, but it happens for artificial reasons that could be avoided if we bothered with trying to do so.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by pixelatedindex on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:22PM (#50036759)
> Schools aren't forever… Some may last for decades, and some for centuries. Some have already lasted far too long.

That seems a bit ironic?

> Grandma Sally isn't going to live forever. The house winds up on the open market in order to seek satisfaction of Grandma's debts

Not always, grandma can pass the home down to whoever. IIRC there are ways to do it without triggering a reevaluation on the original purchase price.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by ssl-3 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:26PM (#50036807)
Ironic? Is it ferrous or something?

Anyway, Grandma is as dead as that Sunday dinner. She won't care that the new occupants are being complete heathens about smoking dope and makin' babies on the sofa.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by johnnyanmac on Sunday October 11, 2026 @03:13AM (#50040472)
Yes, ironic how in such a discussion over how we value land, we choose there to be intrinsic value in a private dwelling and little value in an institution that raised that person and an entire community. Grandma Sally gets to die with dignity while her grandchildren wonder thy they need to change schools all of a sudden and separate from their friends.

Perfectly encapsulates modern society's attitudes by generation.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by ssl-3 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:04AM (#50040678)
I also weep for the children. I still remember being a kid.

And I feel a lot more reverence for the memories of the house that my grandma and grandpa always lived in for the entirety of the time that our lives overlapped than I do for the memories of the school buildings I attended that are now abandoned or demolished.

I spent more years with them around than I did attending school.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by sanderjd on Saturday October 10, 2026 @06:27PM (#50037821)
Schools closing are a symptom of a community that has not retained a healthy mix of people at different stages of life.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by ssl-3 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @10:18PM (#50039187)
Unhealthy for whom? The people who get to keep living there?
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by sanderjd on Sunday October 11, 2026 @11:07AM (#50044108)
For the whole community. For everyone.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by ssl-3 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @02:18PM (#50046129)
So: "We're from the community, and we're here to tell you that you can't live here anymore" is...healthy?

It has never left me in a particularly healthy-feeling state when outside forces beyond my control have made me pack up and move.

Was I doing it wrong? Should I learn to embrace the masochism, instead?

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by sanderjd on Monday October 12, 2026 @11:49AM (#50058160)
No? I don't really understand what "outside forces" you're talking about. Property taxes? I'm sorry but that's just an incredibly silly and entitled way to think about land ownership.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by ssl-3 on Friday October 23, 2026 @03:04AM (#50205388)
Entitlement isn't a sin, my good sir! It is instead a thing that is worthy of accomplishing!

If you have a degree in mathematics from 1984, then you're still entitled to that degree today in 2026.

And if you bought a house and the land that it sits on in 1984, and paid for it wholly and own the title for it, then you're literally-entitled as the owner of that house and the property upon which it rests.

Words have meaning. Please do not disenfranchise them.

Pretty please.

---

Anyway: Everyone else loves what you and others have done with the neighborhood since you moved there in 1984, and they decide they love it so much that they want to move there too. It's a pretty great place to live.

Value goes up. You may not have changed anything more on your property, but they love what you've done with the place so far and want to be near it.

You had the place paid off and were entitled to it in 2014 after you completed the terms of the 30-year mortgage you took out in '84.

But now: Value goes up. Property taxes increase. And, fuckin' hell: You can't afford to stay there anymore.

You own the place, there's no question about that at all. It's completely your entitlement, and you absolutely paid for that entitlement, and everyone agrees that this is true: This entitlement is even recorded at the courthouse!

But you have to move, anyway, because you just can't afford to stay in the house that you fucking absolutely own and are entitled to anymore because the cool kids (nearby, and also on on the other side of the state, and nationally/globally because of inflation) are pushing you out.

---

So I guess that you aim to suggest that we shall own and keep nothing, and be happy about it? Fuck that! We're already fucking temporary! We're already run-limited by virtue of being human! We should be able to pay for decades of risk and eventually own a place, and then live the rest of our short fucking life in that same place without being forced to move around!

We all die. The property we were once entitled to will get recycled into the churn soon-enough no matter what our intention may have once been, after we check out.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by kccqzy on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:42PM (#50035245)
GP is not forcing the retiree to move. GP is instead advocating retaining the use of property while reducing the cash flow burden. Asking someone to get a cash out refinance is not morally bankrupt; it is a pragmatic and fair solution. Some states also have deferred property tax schemes; these are even better. It is only fair for someone who, by luck, paid $100k to get a house that is now worth $500k and lives in a neighborhood that is now far better than when she bought the house.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by em500 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:37PM (#50035201)
Defered property tax for elderly can be (and usually is) implemented as a lien on the estate, to be settled upon the owners death. Do you heve any problem with that? Or should we now also think of (inheritance of) the children?
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by simoncion on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:41PM (#50035241)
Yeah, _seriously_.

"And where would she move to?" -- Either the graveyard or the incinerator? She's dead... the bill doesn't come due until after her death and is settled from the value of the house.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by xingped on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:26PM (#50035089)
It's classic neoliberalism think which for some reason the tech crowd is unreasonably susceptible to. "Oh you're poor? Can't afford your bills? Must be your fault." It's utterly disgusting.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by ForHackernews on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:32PM (#50036876)
Everyone needs a place to live, not only boomers. There's a generational injustice at play in the idea that you get for $10 what I must pay $100.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by xingped on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:47PM (#50037016)
You're not wrong, but that's an entirely different discussion from whether or not someone should be forced out of their house simply because gentrification and inflation causes their taxes to go up year after year likely long after they're done working. Oftentimes people buy homes in low-cost areas because that's what they can afford. It's not their fault when the area gentrifies and their taxes skyrocket past their means through no fault of their own. We can advocate both for homes to be more affordable for people that need one and for people to not lose their homes due to constantly rising taxes.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by johnnyanmac on Sunday October 11, 2026 @03:08AM (#50040454)
>all she wants is to spend her last few years in the same house that she loves and would never consider selling, and now we ask them to kindly pay all their income or more in property taxes, otherwise fuck off??

Change that older lady to a 30 year old woman and the sentiment quickly shifts to "big deal, live in a house you can afford in. people need to move, get jobs, and work. Get hustling". And that is likely the story for a generation of renters.

Yes, it is morally bankrupt. But sympathy is a two way street and can quickly be lost when one side suffers pain.