News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sharing AI progress in mathematics by charcircuit on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:52AM (#49988354)
It's even better. Then tons of people can work together with it on more problems. Work with it on understanding more things. Ask it about random stuff. The time of a single human cannot be parallelized as easily.
Re:Sharing AI progress in mathematics by californical on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:07AM (#49988466)
Claude has been used to build awesome things, but it’s not “speaking from experience” when I ask it to help me prototype a weather model, for example.

It has no memory or experience of working on similar problems. Even if it made one of the foundational libraries that I use in a weather forecasting program, it still has no comprehension of the thought process it takes to understand the problem and build it from zero, and if I’m building on that library it just makes fresh assumptions about how things should work.

It’s not a human with experience or expertise, it’s a computer program that’s really good at turning English descriptions into functioning code

Re:Sharing AI progress in mathematics by charcircuit on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:19AM (#49988546)
>it still has no comprehension of the thought process it takes to understand the problem and build it from zero

If it did it once, it can do it again from zero, and this time you can watch as it works and even it ask it questions. Many of the agents that worked on the problem did not have comprehension of the whole problem. I don't think you need that many tokens to be able to query it for the insights it had during the process.

Re:Sharing AI progress in mathematics by californical on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:45AM (#49988757)
> Many of the agents that worked on the problem did not have comprehension of the whole problem

Isn’t this the issue with using it the way you’re suggesting? At best the model can come up with an after-the-fact rationalization of how to get to the solution, but it doesn’t know what actual path it took to get there - what were interesting traps it fell into, where was a place it was close to the solution but didn’t realize at the time.

Those are things that are valuable to share between humans, those which teach us how to think better, and give us deeper understanding ourselves, and which a model doesn’t have any comprehension of.

Re:Sharing AI progress in mathematics by charcircuit on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @02:36AM (#49989133)
Then have it discover it again and have it answer based off that run. Or if you are more curious have it solve it 10 times. See what it did differently each time.
Re:Sharing AI progress in mathematics by jboggan on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:59AM (#49988418)
I think you and I have fundamental disagreements about identity and consciousness.