More generally, anything can be said about anything.
In the end, nothing can be said about many things and many things say nothing. Those things are then left to interpretation.
/s
It's a small machine, so it might get bogged down
And agreed that this isn’t a faithful simulation of a fly brain. I’m using the connectome as the network structure/parameters for a computational model, then using its outputs as the teacher for the classifier. Not sure how the ChessFly uses it
Edit: in any case, these are just fun demos, they aren’t research papers trying to claim accurate physiological fly brain software simulations
That sounds like you're saying that they got you on a minor technicality only. That's not the case; they're right, you're wrong – you did not "download a real fly's brain's weights".
There's a lot more going on at synaptic clefts, so just knowing the number of synapses doesn't tell you enough to model anything. You still need to know which neurotransmitters are used, how much, second-order effects like G proteins, basal firing rates, distance to the axon hillock, the shape of the neuron's effect on potential decay, etc.
And that's all to predict whether one neuron will fire. You could get very different behavior between different two neuronal pairs having the same synaptic count.
As far as I understand, you downloaded the structure of a neural network, ran it with essentially arbitrary weights, trained a classifier on the essentially arbitrary behavior, then simulated an approximation of that arbitrary behavior.
You could argue that there might be biases towards certain behaviors encoded in the connectivity, and I'm sure you'd be right, but your experiment is incapable of differentiating between those interesting behaviors and random noise. Especially because flies sorta act random anyway.
It took me (using Claude code and some codex), about 3 hours to put it together
And even though it was a cool demo, it seemed so easy, that it also felt like it wasn’t worth sharing
0: ChessFly (not mine), uses the FlyWire connectome (the fly’s brain’s weights) to play chess https://huggingface.co/spaces/mlabonne/chessfly