News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by sedan_baklazhan on Sunday October 04, 2026 @06:57AM (#49952765)
AI is not intelligent and will never be.

Creating an artificial intelligent being is something to be accomplished in the future - but not now and not with this approach.

Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by mdp2021 on Sunday October 04, 2026 @08:21AM (#49953285)
> AI [will never exist, but maybe one day it will]

Please, please fix your language. (Then, you may want to present the info and insight.)

Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by sedan_baklazhan on Sunday October 04, 2026 @12:40PM (#49955444)
AI is what is currently known as AI.

Artificial Intelligent Being is something far beyond and completely different.

There’s no contradiction.

Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by mdp2021 on Monday October 05, 2026 @03:02AM (#49961557)
> currently known as

"Currently known" by whom? The contract is that the "man in the street" does not ask to adhere to its twisted dictionary, and I let it live. When something esoteric in Academia reaches the mainstream news, "Alarm!" and extra care.

["Classical deterministic"] AI is "simulation of intelligence". That it "is" or not is not a problem: the validity of the output counts.

The Discipline of AI is about the relation between computing and intelligence.

A statement about AI [systems] being intelligent or not, or being capable of becoming intelligent or not, requires support.

An «Artificially Intelligent [Entity]» is still an "AI system".

Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by lukifer on Sunday October 04, 2026 @12:27PM (#49955322)
I've yet to encounter a robust definition of intelligence which would rule in every human, while ruling out every form of existing AI (noting that we're talking about agents and "reasoning models", where the LLM itself is a component in a larger system). If you can offer such a definition, I'd be eager to hear it.

I personally prefer a practical, behaviorist definition: a feedback loop capable of prediction, modeling, and steering, towards arbitrary goal states. That makes it clear that we're merely talking about degrees of sophistication and capability, rather than a magical leap where mindless mechanism stops, and "real intelligence" begins.

Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by sedan_baklazhan on Sunday October 04, 2026 @12:39PM (#49955441)
A software cannot be intelligent.

This is very easily proven by a mind experiment where you replace all the transistors by billions of humans calculating the same software output.

They will not create a new intelligence by doing so.

Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by lukifer on Sunday October 04, 2026 @12:59PM (#49955632)
Run the same thought experiment the other direction: at a low level, the human brain is just physics and chemical mechanisms, which in principle could be perfectly imitated by transistors calculating the same output. (Yes, such a thing isn't realistic, but neither is billions of humans doing perfect matrix math by hand.)

I still haven't seen a robust definition of "intelligence" that would allow me to tell the difference. (Bear in mind, this is a definitional struggle even in biology: if we were walk back the evolutionary chain from a human, to a protozoan, it's not clear that you could pick a single point where a non-intelligent creature gave birth to an intelligent one. It's a Paradox of the Heap.)

Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by sedan_baklazhan on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:26PM (#49955888)
No. There is serious scientific evidence already that our brain functions on the level of quantum mechanics. Human brain is not just an automata; wavefunction collapse may be very essential to our concept of free will.
Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by lukifer on Sunday October 04, 2026 @02:19PM (#49956414)
I haven't dug into these claims in detail; I take seriously a possible relationship between quantum mechanics and the brain. But "free will" is hardly a settled question either (I'm closer to the "compatibilist" position, but Sapolsky's "Determined" makes a robust case).

And even if quantum physics are essential to human brains, it's not clear that introducing dice transcends determinism into free will, as opposed to simply adding unpredictability. ("The physics made me do it" -> "the dice made me do it") Let's not forget, there's a significant amount of randomness in AIs as well ("temperature"). And sure, it's simulated algorithmic randomness; but does that imply, if we somehow wired every `rand()` call into radioactive atom decay, that means the AI "wakes up"?

And all that is besides the point: I don't see any reason to assume "intelligence" requires "free will". I'm entirely capable of conceiving, in the abstract, a being which is both intelligent, and deterministic. You still haven't given me a definition (or better yet, a test), to distinguish a "real intelligence" from unintelligent mechanism.

Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by twobitshifter on Sunday October 04, 2026 @02:32PM (#49956525)
And quantum mechanics are what other than random probabilities?
Re:AI 'godfather' LeCun has 'zero concerns' about human exti... by hardbass on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:49AM (#49962717)
Everything functions on quantum mechanics. Electronics esp current gpus and cpus needs a lot of qm. Free will is not a proven concept.