News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by steveklabnik on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @10:27AM (#4992749)
There is a person with schizophrenia who posts to HN, who is shadowbanned due to the comments they leave, which are nonsensical due to their illness. Turn 'showdead' on in your profile, then hit http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=losethos and now http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=SparrowOS .

They've been writing their own operating system in assembly for the last few years: http://www.losethos.com/ and now http://sparrowos.com/

For more: http://qaa.ath.cx/LoseThos.html

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by Xcelerate on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @02:42PM (#4993656)
Hmmph. I noticed the (dead) comments by SparrowOS a few days ago and was very curious about them. They didn't look like any sort of spam or advertising, because there were bouts of normal conversation amidst them.

I posted a "Ask HN" question inquiring about this user and his comments, and my post was marked "dead" within a minute. Only thing I've ever had marked dead on here (that I'm aware of at least).

Thank you for your explanation; I would have never guessed it was something like schizophrenia.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by Xcelerate on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @12:32AM (#4995456)
Alright, I did some reading on SparrowOS/LoseThos. See this page (http://qaa.ath.cx/LoseThos.html) to learn a bit about him and the amazing work he's done on his personal operating system.

In fact, it appears the nature of his posts has been discussed quite a bit on HN over the last few years. I'm still somewhat new here though, so I imagine as people continue to join HN questions about his postings will continue to be asked. And you can't really blame them for being asked (how was I supposed to know what that prose meant?). I suppose the best solution is that instead of downvotes and ridicule (as I found in many previous topics on here), linking to the same page I have above would eliminate a lot of contention and confusion.

EDIT: Yikes, I'm not sure I'm coming across like I meant to. I'm not implying being different is bad AT ALL. Sparrow, I really like your operating system and will download it tomorrow to learn about it.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by ars on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @10:51PM (#4995222)
> They didn't look like any sort of spam or advertising, because there were bouts of normal conversation amidst them.

If you pay attention you'll notice that the verse he quotes are relevant to the topic at hand - he's not just posting randomly.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by TheAmazingIdiot on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @10:37PM (#4995184)
There was about a year ago an Ask HN about losethos( now sparrowOS) about that very topic. There were perhaps 100 posts.

The general consensus is that he deserves to be treated like a human. He may, sadfully, have a mental illness. That's why further inquiries are shut down.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by pndmnm on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @02:53PM (#4993697)
There was a post about his operating system on Metafilter and he showed up and answered questions (in addition to some rambling). Really fascinating read: http://www.metafilter.com/119424/An-Operating-System-for-Son...
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by simcop2387 on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @05:13PM (#4994218)
Its interesting, about midway through he gets very lucid about the is and the stuff in it. More than I've seen him in other places.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by phaus on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @10:35PM (#4995179)
I also recommend reading the entire thread. The further you go, the more he opens up about the details of his work. He has accomplished some really interesting stuff.

I really liked the goal he started out with. Creating a 64bit C64 type environment for young programmers to mess around with and learn to build stuff.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by krakensden on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @01:47PM (#4993444)
I kind of wish that he'd be unbanned. No one owes him their attention, but it seems awful to hide him in the closet.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by angersock on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @12:05AM (#4995400)
That's the interesting thing happening, right?

We've got the opportunity to listen to this guy, whether we agree with him or not, or can parse out signal from noise or not, and we've instead said "Ah, fuck it!" and shadowbanned him instead of simply scrolling down.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by DanBC on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @11:33AM (#4997452)
Unfortunately it's not his posts that would be noise[1], it would be the very many replies to his posts that would be noise.

[1] Some of the comments are noise. The pretty harsh language would be challenging for some people to not respond to.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by Mz on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @12:23AM (#4995439)
You can still listen if you care to. You just have to enable "show dead". You just can't engage him in back and forth discussion. If you can track down some means to contact him individually, he might be interesting to talk with one on one. And it would be less likely to go to hell in a hand basket. A public discussion in a large forum is a very poor environment for trying to effectively accommodate such a situation. I wish I had some other answer. But I don't.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by ubercow13 on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @06:54AM (#4996227)
You can contact him via his address on his site if you wish to talk about his OS http://www.sparrowos.com/Wb/Doc/TrivialSolutions.html#l1
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by pekk on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @01:42PM (#4998362)
What kind of situation is "such a situation" and why is a public forum bad?
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by Mz on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:53PM (#4999218)
Not just a public forum, a very large public forum. If it were a small forum with more private posts, it might be possible to accommodate him in a way which would be productive for him and for the forum. But on HN, no matter how many "regulars" figured out how to talk with him humanely and respectfully and genuinely engage him as a person, too many people would pile on to kick the living shit out of him. There is essentially no hope it wouldn't be more damaging to both him and the forum than the current situation, where he is shadow banned, no doubt realizes it, and gets talked about like he isn't in the room, as if he can't possibly figure out we are talking about him just because he is shadow banned.

There are enough difficulties making this forum work with relatively "normal" people and relatively ordinary social frictions. Trying to add into the mix the need to compassionately tolerate someone whose posts are so inflammatory would become a nightmare for everyone involved. I wish I could say otherwise because I am not personally comfortable with banning someone merely because they have a mental illness. However, pg and others already lament how the forum has lost quality, already are beating their head against a wall trying to address the issues which caused that, etc. They aren't qualified to help someone like losethos fit in and get along. It is a tricky thing to do under the best circumstances and a very large, very public forum only magnifies the challenges involved. The way mental illness expresses itself is partly influenced by social factors. The social factors here would almost certainly make him behave worse, not better. Most people have no idea how to constructively interact with someone who is genuinely mentally ill and it is all too common for group response to the situation to seriously compound the problem.

If it were a smaller forum and if I were one of the moderators, including him might be constructive. But here, I don't think so.

I don't feel I am being very clear. I have a medical condition and am not at my best today. So, sorry if that doesn't clarify anything for you.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by steveklabnik on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @05:15PM (#4999649)
FWIW I think you nailed the issue 100%.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by Mz on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @07:35PM (#5000346)
I have "insider info": I went through very public withdrawal online from prescription medication. So I have been the person who couldn't manage to stop being inflammatory, no matter how hard I tried. It didn't matter how much I apologized and explained, it still created problems. In fact, my sincere apologies ultimately turned me into the group scapegoat. I could say something completely uninflammatory, someone else could overreact in an asinine way and the group response was "there she goes again". I ultimately quit taking their shit, for which I was thrown off one list.

I see no reason to suggest that subjecting losethos to a similar debacle would benefit anyone. I wish it weren't so, but the reality is that most "normal" people just aren't as nice as they would like to believe they are and they don't hesitate to do truly gruesome things as long as they can find a way to pretend it isn't really their fault (distinguishing between "IRL" and virtual interaction is a convenient way many people justify being assholes online).

An entire forum ganging up on one vulnerable individual and blaming the victim for it is an all too common testament to this ugly underbelly of humanity. The people in charge here are wise to not allow a situation which would actively foster such ugliness. In the abscence of a better answer, the current solution errs on the side of at least not sending the message that lynchmobs are welcome here. The ugliness would not stop with losethos. It would spread and soon no one would be safe here.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by steveklabnik on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @08:11PM (#5000473)
I'm sorry to hear that. :(

> (distinguishing between "IRL" and virtual interaction is a convenient way many people justify being assholes online).

Yes x 1000000.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by Mz on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @08:14PM (#5000485)
Don't be. I lived. (I have a diagnosis with "certain death" attached. Long story and not terribly relevant to this discussion.)

Have a good evening.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by catshirt on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @11:42PM (#4995344)
it's not that simple. some of his posts are off topic, or outright offensive (rude, racist, etc). it is complex because this is an unfortunate side effect of the illness.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by catshirt on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @11:39PM (#4995338)
i'm not writing this off completely, but i should ask what you hoped to bring to the conversation by sharing this? i can't help but feel it's a bit exploitative. i've been familiar with losethos for a long time, and i respect the curiosity for experiencing schizophrenia on an eye witness basis. but, given the nature of schizophrenia, i couldn't imagine being thrilled finding a post like this. surely there is another source that could satisfy your intent?
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by steveklabnik on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @08:04AM (#4996424)
The linked story is a story about love. My post is a story about rejection.

My intent is not gawking. My intent is to confront everyone with the reality that they're indirectly shunning one of their own (if anyone fits Hacker News, it's someone who wrote his own entire OS/language/demos/etc) due to mental illness. Due to the way that hellbanning works, he continues to reach out to us, and we ignore him.

I consider this to be one of the great failures of this community.

Furthermore, as you can see by some of my sibling replies, many people are _not_ actually aware of Terry or his accomplishments. SparrowOS is actually pretty amazing, for a number of reasons, and so I wanted to draw attention to them in a time when it's conversationally appropriate.

I am not religious in any way, but since Terry quotes the word of God so often,

    > “Then the King will answer, 
    > ‘I tell you the truth, anything you did for even the least of my people here, 
    > you also did for me.’
    > 
    > Matthew 25:40
Terry, like the woman in the story, needs our compassion and support. Compare the HN shadowban with the way that MetaFilter engaged him: http://www.metafilter.com/119424/An-Operating-System-for-Son...

I'm not saying the right answer is to un-shadow ban him either. I don't know what the right answer is. But I can tell you that I think about him and it a lot. I wish more people would. Frankly, I saw http://i.imgur.com/USsN6.png this morning and almost cried.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by pekk on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @01:54PM (#4998458)
I don't disagree with your points about SparrowOS.

But I don't agree in practice that HN is the best place to find discussion of things like a hobbyist OS written in ASM, because it is so strongly oriented toward the business end of the startup scene. It is very typical to see posts about how engineers are arrogant and socially inept, or how annoying it is that there is so much technical stuff on HN, or how RMS is dangerous and revolting, etc. So frequently the yardstick for judging things is popularity and money and ability to manipulate perceptions, rather than knowledge or playfulness or building things which are really high quality for its own sake.

So while (say) Zuckerberg's "Hacker" concept might go down well here, I don't think that old school "Hacker" values really have much place here.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by steveklabnik on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:14PM (#4998980)
Originally, this place was "Startup News," but it got changed to "Hacker News" to broaden its scope. That said, there's always a difference between 'in theory' and 'in practice,' and so I sorta agree and disagree with you at the same time.

I would like to see it more and more away from Zuckerberg and more and more towards old school, so I'm attempting to be the change I want to see in the world. ;)

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by anigbrowl on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @09:41PM (#4995037)
Thanks for that explanation. I keep showdead set to on and have been puzzled by SparrowOS's comments, until now. Glad to learn about the SparrowOS project, and best wishes to its creator.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by IamBren on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @12:13PM (#4993088)
Wow - those are some troubling comments.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by corin_ on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @12:21PM (#4993116)
While I feel I probably ought to be more compassionate, I have to say that every time I see one of his comments, reading it brings a smile to my face.

Would love him to read a (short) autobiography some day, he does seem incredibly interesting, smart, intense and of course somewhat unstable.

For anyone interested, here's a video in which he introduces his OS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WAr-xYtBFbY

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by DanBC on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @01:03PM (#4993260)
Anyone who's used Usenet will be aware of Mike Corley - the MI5 guy. He has been banned from most UK ISPs for breaching their TOS - his rate of posting to Usenet was prolific.

(http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/place-london/plain/A694523)

(http://www.mi5.com/)

Responses to him ranged from people interested in him as a person, and in his treatment (or lack of); through to hostility at his very many posts and his attempts to evade filters; to really unpleasant baiting of a person with a mental illness or nasty mocking.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by bitwize on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @06:37PM (#4994493)
Wow, that was... Ulillillia-like in its magnificence.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by pekk on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @02:03PM (#4998510)
This video was really useful in introducing me to Mr. Davis' achievements, that I wasn't aware of. Very cool.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by fwr on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @01:10PM (#4993302)
This is fascinating, I highly recommend reading through the last two links, truly riveting stuff.
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by jrogers65 on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @08:24AM (#4996525)
Shadow banning is a terrible way to moderate a forum. If the HN guys are reading this - make your process fair and transparent!
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by bdg on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @03:12PM (#4993784)
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by steveklabnik on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @08:18AM (#4996491)
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by kamaal on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @02:50AM (#4995734)
I'm curious to know more. They can't have normal conversation with people, but can write a operating system?
Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by steveklabnik on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @08:15AM (#4996472)
Your usage of 'they' makes me uncomfortable viscerally, but given that you may not know his gender, it actually makes sense. I think it's because 'they' produces an Other-ing effect as well. Just something to think about, and something I wanted to draw attention to off the bat. While I don't think what you said is _wrong_, something like "Someone who has schizophrenia can't..." instead. Or maybe not. Just figured I'd share.

Anyway, schizophrenia is a very complex illness, with five major subtypes and many related disorders. I am not a doctor, and I'm not privy to his medical history, but what I can tell you is that it affects individuals in different ways. It's entirely possible that Terry is only lucid when he's talking about CS stuff; I don't know if that's true or not.

For more, I'd start here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedhealth/PMH0001925/

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by jwdunne on Monday January 14, 2013 @03:40AM (#5053835)
One of the core things about schizophrenia is a loss in touch with reality, as if the suffering is literally in a world of their own. It might be that this world for SparrowOS doesn't do him well in everyday life but may be very helpful with endeavours which require a leap in thinking.

The OP does have an interesting question because a characteristic symptom of schizophrenia is a loss in train of thought. This seems apparent in his posts because they seem, in a lot if ways, to diverge away from the actual topic (such as meeting God, which also demonstrates delusional thinking).

It's interesting because such losses would make it hard to sit down and focus on writing something coherent, which seems like it'd apply to programming just as much as writing and speech. Though, if he becomes very lucid when discussing CS stuff, perhaps programming as an activity itself provides that lucidity.

Programming may be his therapy. Occupational therapy is often pushed in mental hospitals (I speak from experience).

Either way, it's not even a good idea to try and approach, even it with the best intentions, for you don't know of the damage you may be causing. It's hard to believe but you have to be very, very careful of what you say or you risk furthering his mental health problems. It sounds cruel but the best thing would be to let them be, or at most focus 100% on CS.

I speak from my experiences as a mental health patient and becoming very close friends with a schizophrenic.

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by graue on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @07:32PM (#5000332)
Steve, you used the word "they" yourself up above:

> They've been writing their own operating system...

Not criticizing, just pointing it out. I read it and wasn't sure why you had used "they".

Re:How I Fell in Love with a Schizophrenic by steveklabnik on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @08:28PM (#5000542)
> I read it and wasn't sure why you had used "they".

I actually used 'they' because I generally don't try to gender someone unless I know what pronoun they wish me to use. It's just default speech for me. You'll note that I replaced it with 'someone with schizophrenia' and tend to use "Terry" rather than 'he' even; "Terry" can certainly be a woman's name.

That said, something about the above sentence tripped my othering-detector, so I had a moment of 'ugh,' but as I said, it went away. I don't think it was incorrect/wrong usage, I was just sharing a strange moment that happened in my own head. I don't know why my brain parsed it as "those people can't have a normal conversation" instead of my usual genderless usage.