I think there has been much topical research on this now, and from what I can glean, there are at least two forces working at the same time.
1. Gendered preferences didn't change, but society did. Women still prefer men who earn more than them (by a very wide margin). This would be okay if we still lived in the 1940s, but childless women outearn men now in most metro cities. Sometimes by a wide margin. Women are graduating in high-paying professions at ratios of 60:40, 70:30, and even higher, meaning this problem is getting much worse. Increasingly, the majority of women are focused on the top 10-20% of men who outearn them, to the exclusion of all other men. This is compounded because incomes are just one of many selectors. There is also height (which remains a surprisingly strong preference for women), attractiveness, many personality traits, social standing, wealth, political affiliation, etc.
2. Dating apps have made the above exponentially worse. It's very easy for a woman of average attractiveness (I say this in a academic sense, not derogatorily) to only swipe right on the most attractive men. Those men are perfectly happy to have a lot of casual sex with said women, but would never consider them for marriage. This has warped the perception of their "league." Many of these women end up 40 and alone and deeply unhappy. Or they "settle" for a man of average attractiveness and income and resent him.
This is almost impossible to untangle. We don't want women to be less educated, or earn less. We don't want them to feel like they're "settling." At the same time, there are many amazing men out there in their league, and they could have a happy marriage. I applaud Singapore trying something, because the future of the West looks like a lot of angry, bitter, single, childless, lonely people.
In the short term; longer term that culture will die out and the future will be evangelicals, ultra-orthodox Jews, the Amish and whatever other high-fertility subgroups migrate in in large enough number. Natural selection applies to culture just like it applies to genes, and cultures that don't produce enough children will be replaced by those that do.
https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/demography-in-israel-no-long...
>Haredi women average roughly 6.75 children, while non-ultra-Orthodox Jewish women have a rate of 2.3.
They are also, ironically, more educated than Haredi men - girls’ schools are run almost entirely by female staff and teachers, and they give themselves a good secular education (performing well against national averages of high school education).
It is women who drive the perpetuation of Haredi culture amongst girls and women (and to some extent their boys), and most of them will tell you that they’re very happy to be Haredi.
https://news-archive.hds.harvard.edu/news/2015/03/24/heredi-...
>There is a paradox: on one hand, Haredi women are excluded in the Haredi public sphere. On the other hand, we must remember that Haredi women are the main bread winners of the community since the leaders decided that almost all men need to dedicate their lives to the study of the Talmud.
Power dynamics and individual rights are nuanced. In Western liberal cultures women were officially given “the right to work”, but what it actually did was remove the right of women to choose not to work and raise kids instead.
Many women in developed countries feel like they can’t afford the children they want, and that is because the cost of living has been adjusted for two working adults per household.
Western liberal cultures are also breeding grounds for modern misogynistic movements and behaviors like the manosphere, (due to a large number of involuntarily celibate and childless men).
While it’s easy to point to traditional ritualistic differences between men and women in Haredi society, in practice it’s hard to be a misogynist when you have like 3 daughters.
I don’t know, pretty much all women I have spoken to, almost all in the 90th percentile in income/wealth with the ability to to have more kids and have luxuries still choose to have 2 at most. Maybe 3 if they end up with 2 boys or 2 girls first. And that is because pregnancy and birth and breastfeeding and infant rearing suck.
Hell, as a man, I didn’t have to do any of that and I still wouldn’t want to have more than 2 kids. So whatever mentality leads to financially independent women choosing to have 7 kids is certainly very unique.
>in practice it’s hard to be a misogynist when you have like 3 daughters.
I have seen a lot of people be discriminatory towards groups of people, but choose to treat some members of that group of people better, e.g. if they are useful in some way or perhaps relatives, etc. They can even do it with traits they themselves have!
Oh, it's very easy to undo, you just don't have the stomach for it, so your mind will not even make an attempt at considering. I have learnt that we can do anything we want if we get enough people together. This idea deserves repeating.
> We don't want women to be less educated, or earn less. We don't want them to feel like they're "settling."
If that is what it takes to heal the damage sustained by the perverse social experiments in our society in the preceding handful of generations, then we must want. Tax the shit out of tertiary education for women in their fertile years. Arrest the sexism demagogues, divorce industrialists and related elements that want to destroy families and the fabric of the state and put them in a box for the rest of their lives so they can do no more harm. Cut off the head of the snake in the universities. Everyone in society must come to the understanding that it is not acceptable anymore to propagandise girls so they feel the need to develop in the gender role of becoming second-rate men, instead of first-rate women. Those who sabotage this goal must be arrested and put in a box. Stop the preferential treatment and propping up of women in education and the workplace, we return to merit. Again, saboteurs go in a box. Stop the coddling when it comes to living in a infantilised fantasy world and especially to the sexual instincts: men and boys are held to the standard of not acting out their sex drive and raping anything that's not up a tree at the count of three, so women and girls need to learn about and accept the responsibility of keeping their hypergamy in check.
This is the agreeable, generous, common sense, milquetoast proposal. If reading this made anyone angry or at unease (e.g. this site's delulu cuck brigade), then you will certainly faint at what the radicals at the fringe have to say.
> the future of the West looks like a lot of angry, bitter, single, childless, lonely people
I do not want this, nobody in the West should want this, this is not good. Meaningful action is required to prevent this bad outcome before it's too late.
The way our society developed with the immense pressure on women to marry and general lack of autonomy led to the situation that given a choice they would often prefer to avoid this.
The irony with all this data is that as women have achieved parity with men in all kinds of domains, their happiness has commensurately declined. This is one of those hot button topics which most sociologists refuse to research.
25 years married, so pardon my knowledge of modern dating being what I've heard on social media (which is always from people complaining about it, of either gender) as I'm not on any!
As I understand it, for a lot of young men, one of their preferences for settling down is that their partner's list of ex-partners is not longer than their own. (If so, there's is no point debating the gender-political rights or wrongs of their preferences because you're not going to be able to argue someone into falling in love or wanting to marry someone.) On swipe-dating apps, that creates an incentive for neither party to settle down. One party is so successful that the app keeps signalling they should keep their options open (here's more matches, why settle for this one). The other finds that matches pass their visible preferences for dating but not their invisible preferences for settling down with (because not being too successful at the dating game was one of their hidden preferences). The vitality of the market for dating kills the market for marriage.