News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX's Starship launching to orbit for first time ever ... by geokon on Tuesday September 29, 2026 @12:27AM (#49888285)
The issue is that there is ultimately a limited market for having access to space. SpaceX's business model is premised that if you make access cheap enough that there will be a market for multiple launches a day. But to me demand seems very finite? You can make it 10x cheaper or 50x and it sort of doesn't matter.

There just isn't much to do in space. You have:

- Telecommunications.. Can scale only so much. Starlink is cool. Compared to Iridium it's way way cheaper. But demand is .. modest? It seems to only beats fiber on the ground in special situations

- Telescopes looking up. This is limited by science budgets that aren't going to change much.

- Telescopes looking down. Those people have infinite budgets and already have all the satellites they'd want. If you're not in NATO then can't depend on SpaceX anyway - so they're not capturing that market.

- Tourism. Vomiting for several hours in zero-G will be a thrill for some for a bit, but I don't see this being a huge industry. Maybe on par with basejumping or something.

- Mining.. seems impractical scifi.. premised on wanting to build huge structures in space - but again, for what goal ultimately?

It's sort of like if you made access to Antarctica 100x cheaper. It'd be great, but it's hard to imagine it's going to suddenly open up a ton of demand.

But I'd love to hear counter arguments :)

Re:SpaceX's Starship launching to orbit for first time ever ... by librasteve on Tuesday September 29, 2026 @03:52AM (#49889658)
the demand for bandwidth is infinite… this used to mean copper -> fibre, but it’s that squared for orbital bandwidth, as they lower and close up the sat formation, the antenna gets smaller and the data rate gets faster … I think Musk killing all terrestrial telcos is quite likely
Re:SpaceX's Starship launching to orbit for first time ever ... by perilunar on Tuesday September 29, 2026 @04:16AM (#49889852)
> the demand for bandwidth is infinite

Is it really? Our brains have a limited bandwidth, and there's no need of more than a small multiple of that per person.

Re:SpaceX's Starship launching to orbit for first time ever ... by librasteve on Wednesday September 30, 2026 @08:04AM (#49907689)
human brains are soon to be overtaken
Re:SpaceX's Starship launching to orbit for first time ever ... by paulus_magnus2 on Tuesday September 29, 2026 @01:50AM (#49888774)
Indeed SpaceX is boiling multiple oceans at the same time and betting the timing will align.

-- SpaceX is building a starship factory, not just starship. The market won't deliver enough demand, they need to create their own

-- V3 Starlink constellation targets 100k sats. With 50 sats per flight (100t to orbit) you need 2000 flights to build constellation and then 400 flights per year to replace sats after 5y lifespan.

-- There was that idea of ballistic human travel but this is unlikely to materialize

-- There also was solarsat/powersat where solar power is beamed from space and if you massaged your math the right way the numbers were ~promising

-- AI saves the day. We "need" 1mln AI sats. That solves the demand and justifies the spending. for now

Re:SpaceX's Starship launching to orbit for first time ever ... by testing22321 on Tuesday September 29, 2026 @01:19AM (#49888600)
> Telecommunications.. Can scale only so much. Starlink is cool. Compared to Iridium it's way way cheaper. But demand is .. modest? It seems to only beats fiber on the ground in special situations

It is not designed to compete with finer. Go somewhere truly remote and see how it’s changing the world very quickly. I’ve seen it first hand in Arctic Canada, Australia and North Africa. Before starlink the best they had was dialup. Now they video chat family and doctors, do school online and so much more. Easily a few billion people will use it.

You also forgot about AI data centres in orbit, on which SpaceX have pegged virtually all their valuation in.