News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musk, the Movie by ajross on Monday September 28, 2026 @12:15AM (#49873571)
I... just don't understand your confusion? Of course it's a "hit piece". There's a market for hit pieces because there are people willing to pay to see content aimed at their favorite targets. And the trailer starts with Musk sniping to substantiate what it's about and clarify who its for.

Maybe it's that you think "hit piece" means "illigitimate?". Documentary cinema is absolutely allowed to have perspective. Musk's own communication is hardly unbiased or coolly considered, and he's been known to engage in some "creative advocacy" of his own. Would you apply the same logic there?

My own opinion is that he's a complicated guy and a seemingly textbook bipolar case with a lot of good technical instincts and a really destructive egomaniacal streak. He could do with some hit pieces, honestly.

Re:Musk, the Movie by Isamu on Monday September 28, 2026 @12:23AM (#49873618)
“Hit piece” is an accusation of unfairness, unbalanced reporting. Not about something being unflattering but true.

I have no opinion about this movie.

Re:Musk, the Movie by ajross on Monday September 28, 2026 @10:41AM (#49878771)
Seriously, do kids not use scare quotes anymore or know how they work? There are no less than three replies here interpreting what I said entirely wrong.

I said it's a "hit piece", not a hit piece. And I gave a definition for what I meant in the very next sentences. Because, obviously, the traditional definition is one that is going to be subjective and silly and not worth discussing. But the idea of documentary filmaking having opinion and perspective is important, nonetheless.

Re:Musk, the Movie by JumpCrisscross on Monday September 28, 2026 @12:39AM (#49873705)
> that you think "hit piece" means "illigitimate?

Yes, "presenting false or biased information in a way that appears objective and truthful" is an essential part of being a hit piece [1].

[1] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hit_piece

Re:Musk, the Movie by 8n4vidtmkvmk on Monday September 28, 2026 @01:36AM (#49874032)
It can be both biased and truthful. We've yet to see if it's false.
Re:Musk, the Movie by JumpCrisscross on Monday September 28, 2026 @02:47AM (#49874435)
> We've yet to see if it's false

Sure. Which is why it's nonsense to prematurely conclude that "of course it's a 'hit piece'."

Re:Musk, the Movie by ajross on Monday September 28, 2026 @10:36AM (#49878696)
Since you like definitions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scare_quotes
Re:Musk, the Movie by DonHopkins on Saturday October 03, 2026 @03:32AM (#49942131)
>The use of scare quotes is sometimes discouraged in "formal" or "academic" writing. ;)
Re:Musk, the Movie by wallst07 on Monday September 28, 2026 @07:12AM (#49876239)
Like just about every Netflix documentary... they're all one sided.
Re:Musk, the Movie by ajross on Monday September 28, 2026 @10:35AM (#49878686)
That's a purely semantic argument. Was Oppenheimer a hit piece? Lots of people think so!

"Biased" is a weasel word when used in arguments like this. I really doubt anything in this film is actually materially false.

Re:Musk, the Movie by datsci_est_2015 on Monday September 28, 2026 @02:32PM (#49882374)
The linked definition doesn’t unequivocally support your argument.
Re:Musk, the Movie by CursedSilicon on Monday September 28, 2026 @02:28AM (#49874330)
"a lot of good technical instincts"

Like when he wanted to abandon UNIX for Windows NT at PayPal? [1]

[1] https://archive.is/L3ue8

Re:Musk, the Movie by ajross on Monday September 28, 2026 @10:39AM (#49878733)
Discourse about this man is cursed.

That bit was wrong. He was wrong about lots of other stuff too.

But Tesla's product design and market fit was right on the whole. SpaceX was almost all right and not wrong. Starlink was almost 100% right. PayPal was a lot more right than wrong. Obviously you can nitpick about anything, but when you make that many great bets on things that other people tried and failed at, I think you need to at least nod that maybe his instincts were... good. Which is what I said.

Re:Musk, the Movie by irthomasthomas on Monday September 28, 2026 @11:57AM (#49880082)
Paypal was invented at Confinity which was part owned by Thiel and had nothing to do with Musk. Thiel bought Musk's x.com in a merger deal that also made Musk ceo of the new company for 6 months before he was fired for incompetence. Beyond the windows server transition he also insisted on rebranding paypal to x.com, the everything app. I don't know where he was mostly right at paypal?
Re:Musk, the Movie by CursedSilicon on Monday September 28, 2026 @10:42PM (#49887439)
>Tesla's product design and market fit was right on the whole

The company he invested in, then sued to be declared "Founder" and now parades as his own, personal invention?

>SpaceX was almost all right and not wrong

Except about the things Elon opines on. Because he doesn't know shit about rocketry

>PayPal was a lot more right than wrong

He was kicked out of Paypal for all his stupid ideas