Re:Progressive JPEGs: a new best practice
by csense on Saturday December 29, 2012 @08:21PM
(#4984127)
The real limitation is the number of colors that can be distinguished by the human eye. I've read that medical scanners and other science-y imaging gear can sample intensity with 16-bit resolution.
But if you're talking about hardware whose sole purpose is displaying images for humans to view, having more than 8 bits is just a waste of resources.
Re:Progressive JPEGs: a new best practice
by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 29, 2012 @09:51PM
(#4984383)
I might buy 10 bits, but it's pretty easy to distinguish 8-bit brightness levels.
Edit: Found a source quoting 450 light levels the eye can distinguish, so adding a bit of buffer for smooth transitions and imperfect gamma you'd need 10 or 12 bits.
Also it depends on the color, for blue, 8 bits may be sufficient, but definitely not green.
Re:Progressive JPEGs: a new best practice
by Dylan16807 on Sunday December 30, 2012 @01:08AM
(#4984864)
Rods pick up blue just fine, so I don't think you can skimp on any color.
Re:Progressive JPEGs: a new best practice
by mistercow on Sunday December 30, 2012 @03:52PM
(#4987057)
Red is picked up about half as well as green, and blue is discerned about half as well as red. You can definitely skimp on blue.
Re:Progressive JPEGs: a new best practice
by Dylan16807 on Sunday December 30, 2012 @04:53PM
(#4987261)
I strongly disagree. Blue is less bright to rods, that's it. If you happen to be looking at even gray, then sure the fact that blue seems a quarter as bright means you can chop off two bits. But if you look at pictures that are blue, without a lot of other colors to wash it out, you're going to have the exact same 450 distinct brightness levels over the 100:1 contrast ratio that the eye picks up.
Re:Progressive JPEGs: a new best practice
by mistercow on Saturday December 29, 2012 @11:56PM
(#4984699)
Lot's of cameras can capture more than 8 bpc too, but there's no point in displaying them that way. The reason it's useful is that it reduces loss of quality when manipulating the colors in the images.
Re:Progressive JPEGs: a new best practice
by Terretta on Sunday December 30, 2012 @01:31PM
(#4986611)
Not just "science-y" imaging gear.
I'm scanning slides today with a Nikon Coolscan 5000ED, and it's a full 16 bits per channel of R, G, and B, and 16 bits of infrared (48 bits + 16 bits). The "raw" TIFFs are 182 MB, while the final JPEGs range between 2.2 and 6.9 MB.
Re:Progressive JPEGs: a new best practice
by majormajor on Saturday December 29, 2012 @09:42PM
(#4984359)
There's plenty of room for increased dynamic range, if not more colors, than what 8 bits per channel gives us. See raw files from digital cameras, HDR, etc.
Um, no. Nobody is serving anything more than 8 bpc on a web page, and nobody has a monitor that could show it to them if they did.