Like you said, a balance of consulting and products is a good way to go.
What is your thought process for charging 100% up front if you don't mind me asking.
One of the problems is also, that some clients are not realistic enough, they are very optimistic, which may lead to not being able to pay you.
But you're happy furnishing work to people they've yet to pay for?
I agree that it's possible to build a roster of clients that always pay you, but when you start casting your net wider (which we did), you encounter a greater variety of clients. We grew to a team of 20+ developers and aimed to keep our pipeline near 100% utilization.
With that said, we only had a handful of clients that didn't or couldn't pay. This was early in our existence and we learned quickly how to avoid, and dump, bad clients.
Depends on your strategy. Building a consultancy with employees can be great strategy. Just ask places like Thoughtworks.
I'm using my consulting work to fund our product development work. The stuff I'm doing isn't angel/VC friendly and using consulting work as a funding source seems to be a pretty good strategy to me ;-)
All clients enter into a contract with us. So when they don't pay, we have legal recourse. In #1, there's little we can do, except go to court and get in line as a debtor. In #2, we ended up with a promissory note stating they're legally bound to pay us as soon as they are able to. There are other avenues one can pursue, this is just the deal we worked out with them and all the lawyers involved.
The biggest problems are:
* The client doesn't have any money to get - especially common with startups.
* The company disappears - bankruptcy almost always means that you will see nothing to very-little since you're likely one of many debtors.
* The amount of time it takes. Every hour you spend on dealing with debt collection, legal issues, etc. is an hour you're not spending on making clients happy, finding new work, developing your own product, etc.
The most cost effective solution is often to just write it off - and learn from the mistake you made in picking a client who could not pay.
Occasionally you can sell the debt on to a third party for some %age of the total figure - but that only works if the company looks like it can pay, and still involves admin work on your part.
How is it excusable to have a finite sum of money, commit to paying you some of it, use all of it and then simply say "crap, we ran out of money". Some of the founders I've seen in the valley come off as incredibly immature and irresponsible, but this just amazes me, I genuinely cannot imagine being a businessperson and doing that.
The simple answer is "it's not." You're completely right that the people who do this crap are immature, irresponsible and have no business having the financial well-being of their employees in their hands.
If you've got $10k earmarked and you need it for something else (such as electricity), it's your responsibility to contact the vendor, cancel work immediately, pay whatever portion of the $10k you're legally obligated to pay them because you signed a goddamned contract and hope that you have enough left over for whatever you need.
My consulting contract specifically states that not only is the agreement between myself and the client company, but also between myself and the client company's principal(s) personally. I make it exceedingly clear both in the contract and in face-to-face discussions that I run a business, I'm not in the business of doing work without getting paid, and I will not waste months trying to get my money before turning to more serious measures (such as litigation, which has only had to happen once and was settled for the full amount within 24 hours of the original summons).
Don't be so quick to judge.
I am a consultant and have to deal with clients not paying on-time too - so I am not excusing it, but these things happen much more frequently than you may think.
I don't understand. Do you NOT think people who do what you said above are irresponsible? If you have 50k in the bank and will need to use all of it on your employees and whatnot in the next 4-8 weeks, you absolutely, 100% should not be committing 10k to a project, it seems super irresponsible and amateurish. If I'm committing 10k to a project, I'm going to make damned sure I actually have 10k set aside for it. If you don't you absolutely should not be hiring anyone.
It's easy to judge people when you have never been through it. As much as you are responsible, the very art of starting a company from scratch means you have to deal with things that come up that were unexpected - on a regular basis. i.e. you can't plan for EVERY. SINGLE. Eventuality. It's literally impossible.
Yes, you may have gone through it and never had that issue - but not everybody has the same experience that you did. Don't assume because they don't have your exact experience that means they are irresponsible.
I say this as someone who ran a business, lost a lot of money, had checks bouncing, and all that. It was not pretty, but I didn't for one minute try to pin the blame on anyone but myself - I made poor financial decisions. I was irresponsible. It didn't seem like it at the time, but it was.
I'm not asking anyone to plan for every eventuality, but if you can't afford to pay someone, and still hire them anyway, I frankly don't think you deserve to run a business ever again. I feel like these founders should be named and shamed every single time this happens.
This is exactly why I left the consulting biz too. I had a web development agency with a bunch of friends & ex-colleagues that was about to make $1M in profits after 3 years. That number would be much higher, had it not been for clients (mostly startups and small businesses) that weren't able to pay (so they claimed) or went out of business. This is despite collecting a deposit of 50% of the estimated costs up-front.
Before we broke $1M, I saw a great opportunity to develop a product, so I shifted my focus and have been doing that ever since.
Consulting is good for getting (relative) immediate cash up-front, while products can take a long time to begin earning that same amount of cash. However, if done well, products can scale and earn much more revenue in the long run.
Nathan is definitely taking the right approach for an individual entrepreneur. He's diversifying his income (consulting, apps, books) while presumably moving his focus away from consulting as his income from apps and books increases.
Good luck man!