News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by ndriscoll on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @03:08PM (#49820989)
No, ads are approximately never to your benefit, and if they are, it's entirely by accident. Their entire purpose is to corrupt your preferences or misinform you to the benefit of the advertiser. If you actually wanted to buy the thing, they wouldn't need to spend money on ads (and anyone competent would measure lift over a baseline, not just raw "did people buy the thing" for campaign effectiveness).

If you're to see any ads at all, it is vastly preferable that you see random ads for things that you would never be interested in and that register as pure noise to you. Things you could be convinced to buy, or propaganda that elicits some response (positive or negative) are the worst case to encounter.

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by consensus1 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @04:23PM (#49821988)
Maybe you think so, but if Youtube offered a choice between targeted ads or 5x more untargeted I bet that > 90% of people would take the former.
Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by AshleyGrant on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @08:59PM (#49824837)
There is no reason we have to make the false choice you present. That is simply Google holding a gun to our heads to encourage us to choose something that is in Google's best interests rather than our own.

The choice should be between X targeted ads or X non-targeted ads. They can still target ads based on the content of the page, no different from how television and print ads worked prior to all of this data collection.

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by twoodfin on Thursday September 24, 2026 @01:26PM (#49833959)
“Holding a gun to our heads”?

How is that metaphor apt?

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by AshleyGrant on Thursday September 24, 2026 @06:29PM (#49837622)
Because in OP's hypothetical, it is the equivalent of a gangster saying "I can shoot you in the face or punch you in the face, which do you prefer?"

They present a false choice where Google is saying "We can do this the easy way or the hard way" and we are forced to choose between bad and worse. There is no reason we should not have a less bad choice: the same amount of ads but non-targeted. We, as customers, should not be held hostage by the massive corporations.

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by twoodfin on Thursday September 24, 2026 @08:57PM (#49838901)
Sorry, what?

We’re talking about offering users a choice of ad options on a site they’re choosing to visit.

That’s nothing at all like a gangster threatening physical harm.

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by AshleyGrant on Wednesday September 30, 2026 @04:48PM (#49914203)
And businesses that are offered the option of paying "protection money" can simply go out of business, right?

Acting like YouTube is a service that is not functionally required to use in the modern world is a disingenuous argument at best and intellectually dishonest at worst.

There is so much content that folks end up needing to access for so many valid reasons that is only available on YouTube. Plenty of companies only post troubleshooting explainers on YouTube, as one example. I am not "choosing to visit" YouTube in those cases, I am forced by a third party. And I'm being forced because YouTube has functionally built a monopoly on this type of content.

You might as well be telling someone to "Just buy a helicopter and fly yourself" because they are unhappy with the quality of roads in their city.

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by consensus1 on Thursday September 24, 2026 @10:49PM (#49839663)
This is Youtube. You can just not go there. You have no right to set the terms they offer their services by.
Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by AshleyGrant on Wednesday September 30, 2026 @04:40PM (#49914087)
This is like saying "You can just sail to Europe for your week of meetings." While it may be pedantically true, it's absolutely false from a functional standpoint for most people.

YouTube holds an absolutely dominant position in user created content. I have purchased products from many companies who post their troubleshooting video content on YouTube and only on YouTube. In many cases, those videos are literally the only content they provide. They do not provide any textual troubleshooting content.

Telling people "Just don't use YouTube" is a functionally useless piece of advice as they cannot "just not go there."

Also, I'm a paying customer of YouTube, why would I "have not right to set the terms they offer their services by?" Why is it that Google gets dictator-level control over the relationship, especially when they are operating as a monopoly?

We the People absolutely have the power to dictate terms to Google or any other company.

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by baggy_trough on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @04:54PM (#49822430)
Quite a delusional point of view!
Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by ndriscoll on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @05:09PM (#49822661)
So delusional that targeted advertising (a massively expensive thing to build) makes more money than random advertising, and advertisers are willing to pay a premium, leading to some of the biggest companies on the planet being in the business of targeting advertising! Almost like it's effective at manipulating people into making decisions they wouldn't otherwise make.

And then entirely unsurprisingly, professional propagandists also manage to convince people that the proper reaction to being manipulated is "thank you sir, may I have another?"

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by baggy_trough on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @05:31PM (#49822866)
It's not a mystery that targeted advertising works better than random advertising and therefore commands a premium. It's an unjustified leap from that to the scary sounding 'manipulation'.
Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by ndriscoll on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @05:41PM (#49822976)
Taking wikipedia's definition:

> In psychology, manipulation is defined as an deliberate action that aims to influence or control another person in an underhanded or subtle manner which facilitates one's personal motives.

Does that not describe pretty much all advertising? It's not like advertisers are going out and researching all other deals that are out there and making sure that theirs really is the best, and then paying to put theirs in front of you because they're just so great and want to help you out.

No, they're putting themselves in front of you and hoping you don't notice that they're just another white label of some Alibaba special that costs 10% more than the other Alibaba white label. Or trying to pound into your head through constant repeated messaging that you want their thing when you don't, actually (oh and ignore that it will make you fat, give you cancer, lead to your financial ruin, etc. It's fun. And cool people do it. In fact only uncool people don't). Playing happy music when it's them. Playing stern music when it's their opponents. Look, if you gamble with us, you can be a BIG WINNER! LOOK HOW HAPPY AND RICH YOU COULD BE! etc.

Then to make it extra effective, they spy on you to learn everything about your life, and intentionally feed your insecurities to make you into a softer target. Some kids might end up killing themselves when they take that a bit too far, but hey, what can you do?

There is no ethical low to which that segment of society will not sink.

Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by baggy_trough on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @07:03PM (#49823860)
No, it does not. I would not describe most advertising as underhanded or subtle.
Re:Seattle City Council votes to ban surveillance pricing in... by tzs on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @11:33PM (#49825917)
The ads I receive in the mail from local grocery stores serve to inform me when stores that I normally don't shop at have something I already want on sale at a better price than my usual stores.

How is this corrupting my preferences or misinforming me?