News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by JKCalhoun on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @12:54PM (#49819038)
And arrested?

I doubt you are pro-Flock, perhaps you don't like civil disobedience?

Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by dekhn on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @01:01PM (#49819139)
Many of us on this thread have experience with city councils and are anti-Flock and pro-civil disobedience. We're arguing with you from a point of praticality related to city business meetings. Practicing civil disobedience at a city council meeting is fraught with peril- for example, you're preventing other people from having their topics discussed/voted on. From my perspective, if your goal is to make actual change, getting arrested at a city council meeting speaking on the wrong topic is not a particularly effective method.
Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by techjamie on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @01:49PM (#49819876)
I disagree with your assessment. These city councils undoubtedly are aware that Flock/ALPRs are a controversial issue, and in many cases, including this one, they don't allow people to speak on the topic.

I recall watching a meeting, I think it was in Austin? Where on every topic, most people coming up to talk did so because they refused to hear comments on the cameras. Instead, they had to deal with the frustration of constantly sending people off the podium.

The lesson being, if you know people will feel strongly, it should behoove you to schedule time for them to speak properly.

Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by dekhn on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @02:52PM (#49820725)
Thanks for being polite and thoughtful and laying out your thinking.

The issue is that city council meetings that schedule open discussion on topics often end up running late into the night (after midnight) and the discussion doesn't achieve much.

I don't thikn we can say with certainty that the chair tabled the discussion with the intent of disallowing people their right to discuss it. That's interpreting subjective intent.

Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by someonebaggy on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @03:13PM (#49821054)
Clearly, the best solution to a discussion taking forever, is for the powerful person to terminate the discussion and declare that the outcome was whatever the powerful person wanted.
Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by dekhn on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @03:14PM (#49821067)
They didn't do that, though. They sent it to committee. That doesn't achieve the city council's goals.
Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by someonebaggy on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @02:29PM (#49820408)
Where should civil disobedience be practiced?
Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by JKCalhoun on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @04:19PM (#49821929)
You could be right.

An alternative of course is to saw down the Flock cameras. I suspect people like the woman in the article though are trying to find legal ways to be heard—to elicit change.

Is there a legal alternative that you can think of that would be effective?

Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by someonebaggy on Thursday September 24, 2026 @01:41AM (#49826670)
Everything that works is illegal because it works
Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @12:56PM (#49819068)
The point of civil disobedience is to be arrested. That's the goal of civil disobedience.
Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by someonebaggy on Thursday September 24, 2026 @09:25PM (#49839101)
The point is slightly to prevent a thing from happening, but mostly to provoke a massive government overreaction and make it lose face. Such as in this case where a woman was arrested for speaking her opinion at a city meeting.
Re:Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock a... by Manuel_D on Monday September 28, 2026 @03:00PM (#49882810)
She was arrested for making an off-topic opinion. Someone delivering a rant about abortion on a city council meeting would likewise be removed.

I don't see a government losing face, I see a bunch of online commenters demonstrating they don't understand that city council meetings have rules.