News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by rayiner on Friday December 28, 2012 @03:40PM (#4979390)
As a new parent who is unexpectedly a parent earlier than I thought I would be...

I can see why people choose not to have kids. They're expensive, they're noisy, and they really limit your ability to be spontaneous.

That being said, it seems to have become fairly popular to rag on having kids, and I think at least some of the angst is derived from buying into certain cultural expectations about having kids despite rejecting the general cultural expectation to have kids.

American culture makes parenting out to be a lot harder than it is. If you're a mom who doesn't stay at home with her kids, bake cookies for the PTA, send them to a dozen after school activities, etc, you're a bad parent and your kids will grow up to be unsuccessful degenerates.

I think that's overstated. Right now, I'm in New York working while my wife is with my parents in DC taking care of our newborn while she finishes final exams for law school. Out of 5 weeks of the baby's life, I've missed half. And you know what? She'll never remember it. American culture creates this huge conflict between careers and raising young children that doesn't need to be so big. We say "these are the best years, you shouldn't miss them" but that's for us, not the kids. I miss my daughter terribly. She has no idea that I (or anything else) continue to exist when she can't see me. My dad travelled internationally 50% of the time while my brother and I were small children. How was it affected us? Not at all--I don't even remember anything before 5 or 6 or so.

The same thing is true for activities when the child is older. Suburban parents spend enormous amounts of time just driving around, from ballet class to soccer practice, etc. But nobody on their death bed has ever lamented they didn't do ballet as a child instead of just running around in the back yard with friends. Suburbia itself creates huge artificial roadblocks. Commutes that suck away time, big houses that get filled with toys, etc. All that is unnecessary. Entire generations of kids grew up in the city where they could be ditched with the neighbor on short notice if necessary. Those cities still exist. It's still possible to walk from work to your apartment, picking up the kid and some dinner on the way.

All this is not to say that having kids doesn't create real challenges. Infancy is going to be a rough deal for you if you're not good at sleeping in 3 hour blocks. When you go to work, you have to find somewhere to put them for 8-10 hours a day, preferably somewhere they won't get killed. But there is a middle ground between not having kids and having kids then abandoning your career, hobbies, etc, and moving to the sururbs and joining the PTA.

Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by vacri on Friday December 28, 2012 @05:31PM (#4979949)
I think the popularity of ragging on having kids is because it's finally able to be done in polite conversation without being seen as a monster. Some of us don't want kids, but find that we become second-class citizens when the topic comes up. Last night we had a barbeque with parents of a one-year- and two-year old in attendance. All night the conversation fluttered around nappies and toddler-proofing houses and more stuff about dealing with baby poo and vomit and whatnot.

On the one hand, it's fine, because these are new sets of parents using a pressure release valve, but on the other hand, it's screamingly boring because I've had to deal with the exact same conversation with new parents throughout my life. Try and change the topic and it comes back to baby vomit on the car seats or how the cat doesn't deal well with fistfuls of fur pulled out of her. It's not socially acceptable to indicate that it's boring to be in this conversation yet again - because to these parents, these kids are special. Which is fine, for them, but for me, the only thing that ever changes are the names.

I guess this is a long-winded way of saying that the ragging on having kids is also an escape valve; that it's a way of highlighting that not having kids is also a valid life choice rather than just bearing it silently. We'll never get to a point where it's perfectly acceptable to say 'No, I don't want kids' without speaking up from time to time.

Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by dhimes on Saturday December 29, 2012 @07:09AM (#4981877)
On the one hand, it's fine, because these are new sets of parents using a pressure release valve

Actually, that's not why we do it. It's because in that time of our life it's all we really know that we can talk about to the general population.

If you have specific common interests, then there's that too. But we don't know the stats on the sports teams any more, at least not reliably. We used to be deep into the details of politics or current events, but now we're a little fuzzy on the fifth-paragraph stuff. And some subjects we just let go entirely.

We know what we work at and taking care of the kids.

There are exceptions, of course. There is that guy that still seems to be able to do everything he did before having kids. But you can spot his wife at that same party, and you don't need to be introduced in order to do so. She's surrounded by girlfriends at the party, she looks a bit unhappy around the eyes, and she holds your gaze for a moment too long.

Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by pekk on Friday December 28, 2012 @05:40PM (#4979986)
It's pretty unfair to the kid, who will spend many years being an adult, if they are mostly only valued for the 'puppy' years.
Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by ErrantX on Friday December 28, 2012 @04:56PM (#4979813)
At the death, as it were, you've produced one of my favourite posts of 2012. I don't have kids yet, in the works, but this resonated with me a lot.
Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by dbrannan on Friday December 28, 2012 @03:51PM (#4979458)
Sounds like the outline of a good book. I'm not being facetious, you are on to some great truths in your comments.
Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by kungfooey on Friday December 28, 2012 @04:40PM (#4979719)
It is a good book. Check out "Selfish Reason To Have More Kids" by Bryan Caplan (economist at George Mason U). He goes through all the research supporting the idea that you shouldn't worry about parenting too much. The biggest predictor of a kid's success is genetics, not private schooling and piano lessons.
Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by Evbn on Friday December 28, 2012 @04:03PM (#4979521)
You are smart and lucky to have grandparents to help out. Give it a few more weeks before you declare how easy parenting is, though.

You said yourself that you miss your baby terribly. So how is that a winning situation for you?

Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by rayiner on Friday December 28, 2012 @04:15PM (#4979586)
As a technical matter, everyone has parents. Most people even have parents who are alive. One of the big features of American culture that I've noticed that makes parenting harder is that unlike nearly everywhere else in the world, Americans go out of their way to avoid getting help from their parents.

Now, of course not everyone has parents who can help and sometimes life makes it very hard to live near one's parents, but we have this very entrenched cultural phenomenon where older folks live by themselves and are lonely while younger folks live by themselves and complain about the hassle and expense of child care.

The show "Everybody Loves Raymond" is really illustrative. When I was a small child in Bangladesh, my mom lived in the same city with her sisters, brothers, and mother. The idea that living near your in laws could be the premise of a running joke would've gone over their heads.

Re: saying that parenting is easy--I never said it was easy, and I'm not speaking from my vast experiene as a parent for all of one month. I'm speaking from my experience as a child who grew up with non-American parents who didn't have the same cultural expectations about parenting.

Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by mattdeboard on Saturday December 29, 2012 @11:47AM (#4982564)
Yeah, I thought parenting was easy too until I realized my kid is actually a human being with wants and needs. She's about to turn 9 and it's getting HARDER to be a good parent. The more I come to love my kid the more I recognize I'm a terrible parent. :)
Re:What Is It Like To Be an Adult and Not Have Kids? by rayiner on Saturday December 29, 2012 @12:44PM (#4982725)
Is your kid alive and not malnourished? Then you're an above-average parent!