This case gets me thinking a bit because they are probably involved in this in part so that they can get money to do more research. It's not like they're doing this as a power play to grab more market share.
That is not consistent with how I personally interpret http://www.cmu.edu/policies/documents/IntellProp.html but I am not a patent lawyer
> so that they can get money to do more research.
Some research requires massive public and private investment, and the rational for the technology transfer function of a university is to recoup the costs of R&D from commercial products that are legitimately derivative from these investments, so as to reinvest in the facilities and create more original knowledge that can lead to more commercial products.
Acquiring patents (or being complicit in doing so) and then litigating (even as a proxy) does not appear to be in the public interest.
Also, is CMU partially tax funded? If so, do they really own these patents to begin with? Should they?