News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:University wins $1.17 billion hard disk patent verdict ag... by rwmj on Thursday December 27, 2012 @04:33AM (#4972874)
Considering everything that goes into making a hard drive, the two patents[1][2] describe such a tiny detail (a tiny incremental improvement on distinguishing magnetic domains), how can $1.17bn be a just award?

[1] http://www.google.com/patents/US6201839 [2] http://www.google.com/patents/US6438180

Re:University wins $1.17 billion hard disk patent verdict ag... by tzs on Thursday December 27, 2012 @05:30AM (#4972960)
One thing to keep in mind is that the alleged infringement has been ongoing for nearly 10 years. Over that time, they sold over 2 billion of the infringing chips. A billion dollars sounds huge, but $0.50 per chip doesn't necessarily sound huge.

I believe that the current standard for figuring out what damages should be is based on trying to figure out what deal the parties would have made had their been a negotiated license deal under the constraint that both parties feel that they MUST come to an agreement. This should take into account royalties that the defendant has paid to license similar patents before, and the importance of the patents to the defendants business. There is a whole big list of factors used to guide this hypothetical negotiation. They were established in a case involving Georgia Pacific, so googling for that along with patent damages will get more information if you are curious.

To find out exactly what happened in this case, you'd need to get records from the trial. Both sides would have had hired experts prepare damage reports that look at the Georgia Pacific factors and argue for what royalty should result. It sounds like the jury decided to go with the plaintiffs estimate.

Re:University wins $1.17 billion hard disk patent verdict ag... by btian on Thursday December 27, 2012 @09:18AM (#4973364)
$0.50 per chip is HUGE. This is not the ultra-expensive Intel Core i7. ARM makes only $.10 per licensed chip[1]

[1] http://www.quora.com/ARM-Processor-Architecture/How-much-doe...

Re:University wins $1.17 billion hard disk patent verdict ag... by wallflower on Thursday December 27, 2012 @12:29PM (#4974084)
> $0.50 per chip doesn't necessarily sound huge.

One of my relative's husbands is a hard drive engineer.

He used to talk about how if they could eliminate one single bolt from the HDD assembly (3 cent cost) - it could end up saving millions over the total life of the production run.

$0.50 is huge

Re:University wins $1.17 billion hard disk patent verdict ag... by aaronbrethorst on Thursday December 27, 2012 @04:36AM (#4972883)

    Since the jury found the infringement by Marvell
    had been “willful,” meaning the company knew it
    was using the patented technology, the judge can
    award up to three times the verdict amount,
    according to a statement by K&L Gates, the law
    firm representing Carnegie Mellon.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/27/technology/marvell-ordered...
Re:University wins $1.17 billion hard disk patent verdict ag... by kansface on Thursday December 27, 2012 @01:57PM (#4974557)
This was a Pittsburgh jury that decided in favor of a Pittsburgh institution against a Silicon Valley company. I'd imagine the results would be a bit different if the trial took place in San Francisco.