Someone sends an email or speaks on a voice call on the other side of world and a receiver still gets that note at the speed of light, there is slight latency. It's still completely reasonable to measure that latency as we can effectuate improvements to our machines and networks when it increases. The same as if someone wrote a letter in the 1860s and the horses were sick, causing a delay. Simply because information was received by us, the common understanding is that the notification was sent previously, because that is how cause and effect work.
Pluto is around five light hours away from us.
If an astronaut goes to Pluto and films herself doing activity A and then broadcasts that back to Earth, it would take around five hours for the broadcast to reach us.
So you’re saying that it is not correct to say her recorded activity happened five hours ago?
This becomes painfully apparent when dealing with black holes. Person A falling into a black hole passes through the event horizon normally and reaches the singularity in finite time. However, Person B observing from outside never sees Person A pass through the event horizon. From Person B's perspective, it doesn't make sense to ask what happens simultaneously with Person A reaching the singularity - it takes infinite time just to reach the event horizon. Even asking the question becomes nonsense.
But from the Earth’s reference frame wasn’t the Pluto activity I mentioned earlier simultaneous with what happened 5 hours ago on Earth?
So couldn’t you say from Earth’s reference frame this black hole’s activity happened simultaneously with events 20 million years ago?
I think the difference in the scenario you proposed is that we can conceive of a practical situation in which someone on Pluto sends a message and waits for a reply. We can then say that they are going to have to wait at least 10 hours to receive a reply. This has meaning.
But when the distances become too great the urge is to resist believing that things have an existence beyond the interactions of particles. There is no practical reality to that object beyond our ability to observe it when the light reaches us.
It's obviously fair to say they happened at the same time in this scenario.
No. Special relativity says that simultaneity is relative for things moving at different velocities. The classic example is a fast-moving train and a platform disagreeing on simultaneity, even when they're right next to each other. Distance, and light travel time, has nothing to do with it; that's a separate (and mostly less interesting) problem.
Relativity absolutely lets you calculate what was happening simultaneously with a given past event within your own reference frame (i.e. other things moving at roughly the same velocity you are). In fact, you can think of that process, figuring out a consistent version of events after you've gathered all the data, as being exactly what it means to "observe" something in relativity. This is as opposed to "seeing it", which is what happens the exact moment the photons hit your eyes/sensors.
Just to see if I understand what you’re saying…
So a hypothetical photon from the big bang (era?) gets observed now means the big bang is happening now?
A dinosaur decays to bones and now gets observed means the dinosaur died just now - not that it died millions of years ago?
(Dinosaur = photon from a star or something. Decay = red shift. Or a real dinosaur— guess it’s the same now.)
> So a hypothetical photon from the big bang (era?) gets observed now means the big bang is happening now?
Yes. More specifically, the big bang would be happening now, at the location from where we perceive that photon. Hey, this stuff is not intuitive.However the early universe absorbed all the big bang photons. The furthest back we can observe photons from is the CMB. And yes, the phase change is happening now, there... Complicated by the Hubble expansion of course.
> A dinosaur decays to bones and now gets observed means the dinosaur died just now - not that it died millions of years ago?
No, that is incorrect. But you already knew that. Analogies don't work for light and for time and for relativity - it is too different from our everyday experiences for analogies to hold.As for _our_ reference frame, I've explained in other comments but a debate has developed between those few who do understand because they've studied physics, and those who think that their intuition is more correct than Einstein. I decline to elaborate further, HN comments are not long enough to cover it all. In short: you are in fact missing something but that is fine, everybody is. Einstein himself stated that in his day maybe three people on the planet understood, and he was uncertain if he was among those three.
But go ahead, you win the internet argument. When I thought this was a discussion, and I could potentially learn something or help somebody understand, I was happy to participate. But I have no interest in an argument consisting of insults and accusations and no exchange of information. You win, congratulations.
I tried to explain within the confines of an HN comment so that GGP could understand. Any answer that fits in this box will be incomplete. The most complete answer that is correct, would be a simple "No" but I felt that was too dismissive and not informative enough.
I'll repeat: reference frames in relativity are about motion, not any kind of distance, spatial or temporal.
I also used reference frame when referring to distant objects, for the simple reason that the conversation is (was at that point) confined to light traveling between those objects - the light being in a different reference frame from the two objects. I agree, now the morning after, that this was poorly phased and can not be generalized to two arbitrary objects no matter how distant.
As I've stated, an answer in the confines of an HN comment on this topic will always be incomplete. We can answer very specific situations, but those answers can not be generalized to other situations.
I'll repeat once more: reference frames are about motion, not distance. A nearby (relatively) fast-moving object has a different frame, but a far away object that's (relatively) motionless has the same frame. Simultaneity is defined per reference frame. The reference frame of the light traveling between objects is entirely a distraction for our purposes.
This isn't actually that hard to explain in a comment. See also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49691488
Please, pedantically correct my phrase "break the reference frame". I'd like to know how to phrase that properly. "Change reference frame" maybe?
I anticipate your reply that the light is just sending information about what happened. But a moving observer could perceive _our_ now as occurring before the events that we now observe in light from the hypothetical 20 million light year distant object.
There is no "now" and no relative, definite "past" for distant objects, even if they are in the same reference frame. It is not intuitive, I understand that. I didn't make the rules.
I do appreciate you insisting that I improve my terminology. And I do appreciate being made to defend myself, I had to go look some of this stuff up. It is fascinating - especially the pre-Einstein work that left everybody puzzled.
LATE EDIT:
> According to the special theory of relativity introduced by Albert Einstein, it is impossible to say in an absolute sense that two distinct events occur at the same time if those events are separated in space. If one reference frame assigns precisely the same time to two events that are at different points in space, a reference frame that is moving relative to the first will generally assign different times to the two events.
That's from here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneityI'll not say that Wikipedia is a particularly good source, I'm happy to be corrected if you have something that contradicts that.
Note that the "separated in space" requirement doesn't require any particular distance scale. A moving observer could disagree with you about simultaneity of events on opposite ends of your desk.
And yet, coming back to the original point, we don't need to worry about the infinity of hypothetically possible moving observers to notice that we and a not-too-distant galaxy have approximately the same reference frame, and thus can approximately establish a shared timeline. That's plenty to make it meaningful to say we're looking at things that happened 20mya. (Please note that I was explicit about this being approximate in my first reply.)
Hell, we don't actually have to care about the galaxy's frame at all. Even within our own reference frame, we can calculate what nearby events we observe to be simultaneous with distant events we see (not observe) now, and it'll still be basically the naive time-in-the-past estimate based on light travel time. The worst you can say about that is that it's not wrong, right? We don't need to consider all possible frames before giving a time in the past of our own frame.
> But a moving observer could perceive _our_ now as occurring before the events that we now observe in light from the hypothetical 20 million light year distant object.
Actually, if by "our now" you mean after we've received the photons from the distant event (or really even the same time), I'm pretty sure that would be a superluminal observer. So, uh, lol no. It's kind of important that no real reference frames disagree about causal order.
Also, quit telling me relativity is "unintuitive" like I don't realize that. I've literally done the math on this.