News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by Lammy on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @01:04PM (#49613133)
If something is technically possible, one should act as though it is already happening and hope to be wrong rather than refusing to consider the issue until sufficient “proof” is given, by which it will be too late. Doubly so when advertisers are involved, who as a group are economically-incentivized to not care about consent.
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by deadbunny on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @01:15PM (#49613297)
This would be trivial to test and detect. Just like every claim that TVs will connect to open WiFi networks if you don't connect them to a network. Yet after years of these claims and being extremely trivial to test not a single shred of evidence has ever been provided.
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by cassianoleal on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @01:31PM (#49613547)
How would you test this?
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by DaSHacka on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @04:14PM (#49616353)
How do you think? By broadcasting an open WiFi network and seeing if it connects and requests a DHCP Lease.
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by deadbunny on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @01:41PM (#49613753)
If they form a mesh and route traffic via one TV that acts as an exit node you can check the packet TTLs.
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by wtallis on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @02:20PM (#49614464)
Isn't messing with TTLs a pretty obvious thing to do when communicating covertly? And wouldn't that kind of packet inspection only catch cases of TVs literally acting as packet-level routers, but not catch application-layer shenanigans like aggregating statistics in the exit node so that all the data going over your own network appears to be originating from the same device?

It's still implausible, but thoroughly verifying that your TV isn't spying on you isn't trivial.

Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by structural on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @02:46PM (#49614871)
There's no requirement that the mesh be IP-based or function as a layer-3 router...

Even if it were IP-bsaed, it would be extremely straightforward for one box to send a UDP message to another, and receive and retransmit at the application layer. No TTL nonsense, No multiple IPs showing up communicating upstream.

Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by cassianoleal on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @03:14PM (#49615351)
But if my TV is doing this, then by definition it's not acting as an exit node so how do I test it?
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by DaSHacka on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @04:16PM (#49616383)
Put a WiFi NIC in monitor mode and see if the TV is connected to another AP based on the 802.11 packets.

Or if this theoretical implementation by a manufacturer is using a custom protocol/frequency (very unlikely for a variety of reasons), you'd begin by probing with an SDR.

Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by cassianoleal on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @04:29PM (#49616576)
Which part of that qualifies as trivial?
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by DaSHacka on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @05:12PM (#49617130)
I only semi-agree with GP; it's trivial for someone who works in Tech to pull it off, but that's really all you need to blow the lid on the whole operation given manufacturers would likely have implemented the same behavior across all TVs of the same model/product segment.
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by nickff on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @01:09PM (#49613210)
This seems paranoid. There are many things which are technically possible, but there is no evidence of some super-advertiser doing. It's not even clear to me that much of the 'fingerprinting' (past basic re-targeting) actually works.
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by privong on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @01:16PM (#49613309)
> This seems paranoid. There are many things which are technically possible, but [...]

Isn't this what people said pre-Snowden? Not that NSA spying is the same as corporate "surveillance capitalism", but if companies can make more money off it and the technology exists, it seems prudent to assume companies are trying it.

Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by nickff on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @01:20PM (#49613371)
There was evidence of the NSA intercepting international communications before Snowden, but for some reason that didn't seem to make much of a lasting impression: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A

It's also significant to note that while the government is quite bad at keeping 'problematic' behavior secret, companies are much worse at it.

Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by privong on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @01:40PM (#49613736)
Analogously, there's evidence that companies will make extensive use of available techniques (browser fingerprinting, cookies, etc.) to track and surveil users without their knowledge and often against their will. The exposure of that arguably also hasn't triggered an effective backlash against those companies. So, as with the pre-Snowden evidence for domestic communication interception by the NSA, I think there's ample evidence of the willingness of companies to exploit whatever technologies they can in order to surveil users.
Re:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby by structural on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @02:51PM (#49614952)
The way this is typically handled is through compartmentalization, where no one working has enough of a global view to be able to claim that the behaviour is problematic.

There's a lot that's problematic that we suspect that is going on but don't have firm proof, because the organization actually is pretty good at keeping it secret enough. There's some exceptions where things do get leaked/revealed, but how would you know if this was 99% of wrongdoing, or 0.99% of it?