News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hamming: "dubious that great programmers can be trained.." by Joeri on Sunday December 23, 2012 @02:24PM (#4960330)
If you spend 10.000 hours playing the same simple tune on a guitar you're not going to be a great musician. Similarly, if you spend 10.000 hours programming the same mediocre kind of code, you will not have become a great programmer.

Programming is a craft, and like any craft it requires dedication to the craft to achieve a high level of skill in it. People without a passion for programming are not going to have that dedication, and therefore will not reach a high skill level.

Re:Hamming: "dubious that great programmers can be trained.." by SoftwareMaven on Sunday December 23, 2012 @06:17PM (#4961082)
I'm not sure how you could spend 10000 hours programming the same mediocre code if you were actually doing the things I outlined. The whole point of the list is to ensure you aren't spending the time doing that.

I can't tell if you are disagreeing with me or not (I think you are), because you've said almost the same things I did. What you call dedication, I call self-selection.

Re:Hamming: "dubious that great programmers can be trained.." by mikeleeorg on Sunday December 23, 2012 @02:38PM (#4960363)
One of the assumptions of the 10,000-Hour Rule, as Malcolm Gladwell asserts, is that a person spending 10,000 hours on an activity naturally has a strong proclivity for it.

So working off that assumption:

IF 10,000 hours = passion

AND passion = great at a craft

THEN 10,000 hours = great at a craft

Re:Hamming: "dubious that great programmers can be trained.." by georgemcbay on Sunday December 23, 2012 @03:28PM (#4960545)
That assumption is obviously wrong when you mix financial compensation into it.

I've worked with more than a few programmers who were in it for a paycheck, some of them were perfectly competent at creating code for their little niche (CRUD apps, whatever), but were single-language, single-framework, lots-of-maintenance types of guys.

Needless to say, them putting 10,000 hours into programming isn't the same as someone who is really passionate about it.

To paraphrase: "Some people put in 10,000 hours, some people put in 1000 hours 10 times".