News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by tokenadult on Saturday December 22, 2012 @04:09PM (#4957482)
From the article: "Kaptchuk . . . doesn’t argue that you can simply 'think yourself better.' 'Sham treatment won’t shrink tumors or cure viruses,' he says."

That's an honest statement and an important point, because many publications with Kaptchuk's name on them are overinterpreted to reach the conclusion that there is a "real" placebo effect that can actually cure disease. In fact, there is no strong evidence of that at all.

This issue has come up often enough on Hacker News that I have gathered some links that are helpful for understanding what placebo effects are all about. Some of these online links cite quite a few useful scholarly publications.

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/michael-specte...

"In other words, the best research we have strongly suggests that placebo effects are illusions, not real physiological effects. The possible exception to this are the subjective symptoms of pain and nausea, where the placebo effects are highly variable and may be due to subjective reporting."

Numerous press releases on the Web point to publications co-authored by Ted Kaptchuk, the main person profiled in the article kindly submitted here. Although Kaptchuk has the academic title of an associate professor of medicine, he has no medical training or credentials or clinical experience in independently verified patient care.

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/dummy-medicine...

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/dummy-medicine...

The article submitted here today, as befits an article from Harvard Magazine, is pretty good about giving the point of view of researchers who disagree with Kaptchuk, and is good about giving his updated opinion on issues he has changed his mind about. The statements found in some earlier articles posted to Hacker News, such as "Recent research demonstrates that placebo effects are genuine psychobiological phenomenon [sic] attributable to the overall therapeutic context, and that placebo effects can be robust in both laboratory and clinical settings" are untrue.

http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/the-rise-and-fa...

"Despite the spin of the authors – these results put placebo medicine into crystal clear perspective, and I think they are generalizable and consistent with other placebo studies. For objective physiological outcomes, there is no significant placebo effect. Placebos are no better than no treatment at all."

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20091554

"We did not find that placebo interventions have important clinical effects in general. However, in certain settings placebo interventions can influence patient-reported outcomes, especially pain and nausea, though it is difficult to distinguish patient-reported effects of placebo from biased reporting. The effect on pain varied, even among trials with low risk of bias, from negligible to clinically important. Variations in the effect of placebo were partly explained by variations in how trials were conducted and how patients were informed."

Fabrizio Benedetti, a co-author of one of the most cited papers who is also a medical doctor, sums up his view this way: "I am a doctor, it is true, but I am mainly a neurophysiologist, so I use the placebo response as a model to understand how our brain works. I am not sure that in the future it will have a clinical application."

http://www.brainsciencepodcast.com/storage/transcripts/year-...

To sum up, despite claims to the contrary that are often covered by the lay press, the best-considered view among medical practitioners with clinical experience is that the placebo response has no ethical clinical application.

See also:

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/does-thinking-...

http://www.skepdic.com/placebo.html

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/revisiting-dan...

And of course see LISP hacker and Google director of research Peter Norvig's article "Warning Signs in Experimental Design and Interpretation" on how to interpret scientific research.

http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by iskander on Saturday December 22, 2012 @11:37PM (#4958593)
Huh, your extensive research doesn't square with much of what I learned as a neuroscience undergrad. We read a few papers that demonstrated non-trivial physiological responses due to 'sham' treatments.

In particular, placebo treatments have a well established impact on pain by causing release of endogenous opioids (see http://webusers.astro.umn.edu/~larry/CLASS/NOTHING/READINGS/... and http://pharmacology.ucsd.edu/graduate/courseinfo/placebartic...).

More generally, it would be shocking if beliefs and perceptions didn't have (both beneficial and harmful) medical effects. Mental states have physical consequences. For example, stressful thoughts cause measurable differences in levels of various hormones and neurotransmitters. Over time, particular patterns of thinking can even cause changes in the morphology of the brain. The strong assertion of a mind/body split seems simplistic and outdated, there's simply too much evidence of a complex entangled relationship between the two.

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by MDS100 on Sunday December 23, 2012 @07:09AM (#4959304)
But the effects are still rather limited to nausea, pain and the systems influenced by stress response (esp. some immune system functions). You have to look at the absolute change in the body. Which is rather limited. Stress in general can be reduced by more effective means (CBT, relax. tech.) than sham treatments.

For practical application there are other OTC substances you can take (such as adaptogens/anxiolytics - e.g. Ashwaganda & l-theanine) which will have a placebo effect (obviously differing on method of deliver (white coat vs. self, injection vs. pill) and additional effects.

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by smegel on Saturday December 22, 2012 @04:53PM (#4957603)
Isn't focusing on the placebo effect ignoring the broader and more important question of the impact of state of mind on the body's ability to fight disease and heal itself? Once that question is well understood I imagine the understanding of notions like the placebo effect will simply fall out.
Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by AhtiK on Saturday December 22, 2012 @06:03PM (#4957788)
A rather deep research and clinical practice on working with the mind to cure the body has been conducted by John E Sarno.

The Mindbody Prescription [1] and The Divided Mind [2] are two of his books.

My interest in this started with the motivation to get some relief for the RSI-like symptoms and it's been part of my recovery for a few weeks together with the improved ergonomics.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/The-Mindbody-Prescription-Healing-Body...

[2] http://www.amazon.com/The-Divided-Mind-Epidemic-Disorders/dp...

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by lutusp on Saturday December 22, 2012 @09:45PM (#4958375)
> To sum up, despite claims to the contrary that are often covered by the lay press, the best-considered view among medical practitioners with clinical experience is that the placebo response has no ethical clinical application.

Of course I agree with this view, but when interpreted in its widest sense, it argues against the legitimacy of religion. It also occurs to me that few will notice the connection.

On a more practical level, it argues against most psychological treatments, which research shows cannot reliably be distinguished from a placebo effect. Few will notice this connection either.

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by StavrosK on Saturday December 22, 2012 @11:09PM (#4958543)
This research invalidated the only reason I had for not minding homeopathy. It was at least healing people by the placebo effect.

Now it doesn't even do that. Good riddance.

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by jrogers65 on Sunday December 23, 2012 @03:29PM (#4960549)
> From the article: "Kaptchuk . . . doesn’t argue that you can simply 'think yourself better.' 'Sham treatment won’t shrink tumors

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22287549

> process by which stress may potentiate carcinogenesis and how reducing body stress may prevent cancer growth and progression. The opioid peptide β-endorphin plays a critical role in bringing the stress axis to a state of homeostasis

http://www.scienceagogo.com/news/20050725232410data_trunc_sy...

> A study from the University of Michigan (U-M) has provided the first direct evidence that endorphins - the brain's own pain-fighting chemicals - do play a role in the phenomenon known as the placebo effect

Sure throws a spanner in the works.

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by MDS100 on Tuesday December 25, 2012 @12:45PM (#4966490)
You should read you sources. These are not hard data. It's guesswork.