News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by hypfer on Saturday September 05, 2026 @03:11AM (#49573946)
I feel like this confrontational approach to the problem has achieved basically all it can achieve over the last 55 years.

We're heavy in the diminishing returns here - if it hasn't even inverted already.

New tools and approaches will have to be found to further push these goals.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by skeptical1884 on Saturday September 05, 2026 @03:13AM (#49573960)
What kind of confrontational approach do you mean?
Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by hypfer on Saturday September 05, 2026 @03:17AM (#49573980)
The essay there weaponizes sarcasm + the emotional experience of that reality to hit the reader over the head with, in an attempt to break their script and force them to a change in perspective.

This - evidently - worked and works, but there are trade-offs to it.

Specifically, it is zero-sum, which eventually led to the gender war we have now. Since the defenses have been (for the most part) broken down, a modern pivot would likely move towards more unification again, I guess.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by disdegeneration on Saturday September 05, 2026 @03:25AM (#49574017)
The social mechanics to decouple woman permanently from reproduction are already in the making. Incubators and AI educators and people can have children with a company, the rest of the social problems (the social network harem effect) then go out the window. If you need to be a millionaire to have a conventional family, tradition is out, corporate cloning is in. The working alternative to religious fundamentalism.
Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by wojciii on Saturday September 05, 2026 @04:12AM (#49574306)
While I support equality between biological sexes this had some ill effects.

Giving birth is a woman job. Breastfeeding is a woman's job. Replacing breast milk with something else might be one of the causes of allergies and other ill effects (I'm guessing).

To me it looks like women want to be compensated for the unpaid work of birthing children and taking care of them during their upbringing. No one fucking likes unpaid work. It's not right.

For me this if the current feminism and I do support it.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by exmadscientist on Saturday September 05, 2026 @04:20AM (#49574355)
> (I'm guessing)

Please don't do this. It's not helpful.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by christkv on Saturday September 05, 2026 @04:30AM (#49574432)
The fact that everything in life is compared to monetary value is the problem. There abstraction of paternalism to the state is another. For the state you are a number for your family and friends you have a name
Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by swagasaurus-rex on Saturday September 05, 2026 @04:34AM (#49574467)
Isn’t being a stay at home wife being compensated to do that work?

Your bills and mortgage are paid for, so is the food. You get to spend time with the kids. Sounds way less stressful than a high stakes job.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by sersi on Saturday September 05, 2026 @05:01AM (#49574674)
You also have no way to get out of a bad relationship if things turn sour. Being stay at home is extremely risky, you give up freedom.
Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by hypfer on Saturday September 05, 2026 @05:06AM (#49574702)
Tbf, that's a very "modern"-ish way of viewing the idea of "committing".

And there are good reasons for that, of course, but with that thinking, you're always going to be not fully there, which might be harmful in different ways than the ways it tries to protect against.

It's a hard problem to solve, because Humans and interpersonal stuff is hard, but, ideally, one would frontload the friction, so that there is no need to keep an out on hot standby.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by sersi on Saturday September 05, 2026 @05:39AM (#49574843)
Sure in our modern era there are a lot more divorce and it's probably partly because people are less inclined to make efforts to stay in a relationship. But there's also statistically less abuse and domestic violence and that's partly because women by and large have a lot more options than they used to.

I don't think the trade off of having less divorce and more long lasting relationships is worth the increase of domestic violence and abuse so I do believe that people in any relationship should have an out (even if it's not in case of abuse or a breakdown of a relationship but instead for supporting oneself after the death of the only parent bring money home).

That still means that I would teach my kid that the secret behind any successful relationship is to make efforts and that one should not give up at the first problem but you never know what the future might bring and having some way out is always useful

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by hypfer on Saturday September 05, 2026 @05:53AM (#49574934)
> there are a lot more divorce

That is not what I was talking about. Mainly because it's a dumb talking point.

You've I think replied to what you expected one would write and not to what was written.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by sersi on Saturday September 05, 2026 @08:28AM (#49575893)
Then I'm confused by what you're trying to say. Reread it a few times, let me try to state how I understand your argument: - thinking about having a way out (so not being a stay at home wife for example) is a modern way of thinking about "committing".

- By thinking this way, you're not fully in the relation, so it's harmful to the relationship stability. (which I interpreted as divorce)

ok, I admit the last part, I'm not sure what you mean by front-loading the friction... I just focused on not keeping a hot standby.

Sorry for my confusion, not trying to be difficult here, I really don't get what you mean if not what I originally interpreted it as

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by hypfer on Saturday September 05, 2026 @09:53AM (#49576523)
Aah, okay, I see.

No, I wasn't referring to divorce, because divorce is actually a pretty healthy failure mode (or can be, at least). The worse failure modes are the ones where people do not disengage for whatever reason and stay in the situation indefinitely.

What I wanted to get at is that "relationship turning sour" is (usually) nothing one has zero control over. Because the logical chain proposed was "Things can always turn sour" -> "You always need a way out". Or at least that's how I read it.

So I've put the prerequisite into question there.

My point, in a gist, is that I think it should be possible to greatly reduce the probability of "things turning sour" by doing much much more work upfront (before committing to a situation), and through that, the need for an out could be shrunk.

Probabilities are of course probabilities, but still.

Or, even simpler, I feel like people, generally speaking, could spend more time _actually_ getting to know each other before moving forward; and it would only do them good + they would treat each other better + they'd actually see each other (more).

___

Moving fast and breaking things is everywhere, and it seems to be breaking people too.

=> So the friction of _really_ looking at who a person _actually_ is (which might be unpleasant) might be necessary. Even though SV would love to have you believe that frictionless existence is desirable.

It is, up until it isn't. And then you're fucked.

But the solution is not to assume that everything is broken, but to build healthy stuff instead.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by sersi on Saturday September 05, 2026 @02:18PM (#49579196)
Oh, now I get it. Thanks. For what it's worth, I agree with you about spending time getting to know each other before moving forward. I just believe that doing that doesn't reduce the necessity of not putting oneself in a situation with no alternatives or way out.
Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by ndriscoll on Saturday September 05, 2026 @12:26PM (#49578095)
The thing is, assuming you get married as a step toward building your own family, once you have kids, there isn't an out that doesn't involve damaging them for life. Your contingency plan is going to be bad no matter what, and not being present in their lives and putting them in daycare is making a real sacrifice to mitigate a risk that is better mitigated by being discerning in the first place.

Being able to spend all of your time with your family is the freedom to strive for, not a loss of freedom. It is the ultimate form of being your own boss; you are accountable to no one, not even customers/market forces. The loss of freedom is trading your time to accomplish someone else's goals that you're not really invested in while you pay someone for their time to watch your kids who they're not really invested in. And this trade can only really make sense after overhead if you outsource to people who make a decent amount less than you, further decreasing their likelihood to be capable or driven to do a good job.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by dvfjsdhgfv on Saturday September 05, 2026 @05:25AM (#49574790)
> Sounds way less stressful than a high stakes job.

If it's by choice, then yes. Otherwise, it could be really bad.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by noosphr on Saturday September 05, 2026 @05:04AM (#49574690)
Given that surrogacy runs to 20-80k for the woman carrying the child I don't think women will appreciate their new wages if we convert all social relations into market ones.
Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by ndriscoll on Saturday September 05, 2026 @10:26AM (#49576820)
People absolutely do like unpaid work, so much so that the phrase "do-it-yourself" appeared as a marketing term. I do all the unpaid labor I can. It builds competence, lets you ensure quality, and is generally cheaper/more efficient (out of the formal economy = no taxes, which is immediately a huge drag).

Wanting compensation for raising your kids is like wanting compensation for making yourself a nice dinner. The compensation is right in front of you.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by wojciii on Saturday September 05, 2026 @01:31PM (#49578722)
Some unpaid work might be character building yes, but what I'm talking about is not.

Getting kids will give a guy high fives at work while a woman will be asked if she is going to get any more when looking for work. Also a guy salary will not be set back by 3-5 years of child bearing and it will also reflect badly on a woman's pension saving because exactly of this.

While having children is rewarding is not an economical reward for all involved.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by ndriscoll on Saturday September 05, 2026 @02:59PM (#49579572)
Raising children is probably the epitome of character building, self-actualizing work. There are no external stakeholders to motivate you. No one's going to do it for you if you don't. You get out of it exactly what you decide to put in, and you're efforts go purely to something you care about. It is the most important project you can do, and you and your spouse are solely responsible for it.

It's not supposed to be economically rewarding to have children. It's the reward that economics are meant to enable.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by wojciii on Sunday September 06, 2026 @02:28PM (#49589387)
> It's not supposed to be economically rewarding to have children. It's the reward that economics are meant to enable.

It's not fair that one sex had to pay while the other gets the rewards. This is the situation as I see it now.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by ndriscoll on Sunday September 06, 2026 @05:23PM (#49591103)
I'm not sure who's even meant to be whom in your sentence, but it's approaching things from an entirely wrong angle.

Like, my wife is a full-time mother. Economically, I bring in the income for everything, but we're married. Everything is shared. It's not I pay; it's we pay. And we both get the reward for the work we put into our family. No one is losing. We are all winning.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by hypfer on Saturday September 05, 2026 @03:30AM (#49574051)
This comment was dead on arrival, but I've vouched for it, because I believe it's interesting.

I do not believe the conspiracy part, but I do also believe that this decoupling will happen eventually. It seems like the logical conclusion of the trajectory we're on. Leaving biological reality behind in the pursuit of individualism.

It might be a good thing, but we might also find that we were not ready for the total freedom from said biological reality. But that is to be said about a lot of things, SV is pushing towards.

But maybe we will also see stuff crashing down in the near-ish future, and then, pondering about the "end of biological reality" will seem like unreal hallucinations.

___

Hmm. The LLM I've been feeding this comment section pointed me at the Universe 25 Experiment. I've never heard of that before.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by keiferski on Saturday September 05, 2026 @06:02AM (#49574980)
Check out a book called Shall the Religious Inherit the Earth?

It’s looking far more likely that traditional approaches to these questions will become more popular with time, simply because the people that have kids don’t have the opinions you’ve mentioned here.

Which makes a lot of sense in a cultural evolution sense - you wouldn’t really expect individualism to outcompete group activity on a long timeline.

Re:I Want a Wife (1971) [pdf] by makeitdouble on Saturday September 05, 2026 @08:26AM (#49575877)
> zero-sum

One direction out of it is reducing the social burden on the family in the first place. Perhaps at some point we end at a zero-sum state, but IMHO we're still a long way from there.

I'm thinking about suits and Y-shirts and other garment that require either special care or cost enough to need babying for instance. Many professions still set them as standard job attire, which makes dealing with them either costly or time consuming. Meals are another point where the expectation on the level of meals cooked in a family will directly impact the QOL of the primary care giver. Home design will also bring more or less chores etc.

Looking at countries with high men/women gap, they tend to keep high maintenance traditions alive and social expectations are more punishing towards families that "cut corners".