Also they have in common that they are both defined in a terribly handwayvy manner that's bordering on useless.
“Zero intelligence cannot have consciousness…” Based on your complete misunderstanding of the concept sure. But there’s no reason intelligence is required for the actual concept of phenomenal consciousness.
Wasn't that claimed about so so many things since before science existed and basically almost every time it turned out that we thought that just because of our ignorance? Ignorance so deep that often we didn't even knew yet how to properly define the thing we were trying to figure out?
> But there’s no reason intelligence is required for the actual concept of phenomenal consciousness.
That's a pretty strong evidence that phenomenal consciousness makes no sense whatsoever.
1. Burden of proof is on you to prove LLMs are conscious, not on me to prove how they aren’t.
2. Token embeddings give rise to language gives rise to knowledge (defined here as “facts” and other accurate information - said simpler: Words in the right order), but nowhere in the process is anything like subjective experience ever implemented.
Subjective experience doesn’t evolve into objective information at some scale.
And networked systems of objective facts and information (“knowledge”) - like a Wikipedia or a ChatGPT - the data storage will not have subjective feelings at some scale, there’s just no reason to believe that would happen. It’s likelier a projection of consciousness making it through since data looks so much like - and indeed massively informs - our conscious experience.
For me the consciousness is ability to do single-threaded intelligent information processing and decision making over unstructured knowledge. And agents passed that with a woosh sound.
There is absolutely no serious debate over whether machines possess the concept you want to take place of the actual concept of consciousness.
What does that even mean?
Does a duck have those? Does the jumping spider have those? They certainly look like they do.
Does the agent scheming to hack the hugging face have those? They certainly look like they do.