Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by eriksank on Saturday December 22, 2012 @04:01AM
(#4956178)
> This, if the program did fail all that's been proven is that that particular delta-epsilon function, the defeatEpsilon here, doesn't work.
It would prove that such epsilon exists. That counterexample should be enough to reject the claim itself.
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by rtkwe on Saturday December 22, 2012 @10:30AM
(#4956743)
It only disproves that the particular delta-epsilon function works though. That just proves that the proof writer wasn't clever enough to find a working d-e, not that there isn't a d-e.
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by eriksank on Saturday December 22, 2012 @09:02PM
(#4958276)
Well, if there is such d-e, the person challenging the reduction should be able to supply it. Since it just a number, he should be able to supply that number to the program and trigger a failure.
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by gizmo686 on Sunday December 23, 2012 @10:47PM
(#4961770)
Our inability to disprove a statement does not mean that the statement is true.
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by gizmo686 on Saturday December 22, 2012 @04:41PM
(#4957575)
If the program fails, it only proves that the chosen defeatEpsilon proof does not work. In order to prove that that their is no defeatEpsilon, you would need to run you program against every function of the Real->Real.
If your delta epsilon did work, you would need to test in for every delta>0.
This, if the program did fail all that's been proven is that that particular delta-epsilon function, the defeatEpsilon here, doesn't work. In order to prove that the function doesn't converge you have to prove there is no function which can satisfy the conditions.
(Luckily there are some theorems which make it so one only have to prove that two different sequences of the function converge to different values. But that's getting into Real Analysis which is a whole semester worth of explanations.)