Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by monochromatic on Saturday December 22, 2012 @02:43AM
(#4956083)
assert(0)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by gizmo686 on Saturday December 22, 2012 @05:09PM
(#4957659)
This might be the most elegant post I have seen.
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by eriksank on Saturday December 22, 2012 @02:58AM
(#4956102)
If your claim is void (zero), you could put a bit more effort into elaborating that ;-)
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by gizmo686 on Saturday December 22, 2012 @05:17PM
(#4957675)
You state:
"Gödel's 1931 Second Incompleteness Theorem insists that it is strictly forbidden to ever claim the truth of any scientific or mathematical statement"
That claim is false, therefore, the truth of that claim is equivilent to the truth of 'false'. Becuase your article is true iff all of the statements within it are true, and your article contains a statement which is false, then your entire article is false. Using this, we can 'reduce' the 'proof' of your into assert(false). I suspect that the parent is using 0 as an alias for false.
More generally, for any contemporary mathamatical proof, what you call a reduction, you can reduce the proof of the form you describe to either assert(true) xor assert(false), depending on what the mathametical proof/reduction shows.
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by monochromatic on Saturday December 22, 2012 @09:14PM
(#4958313)
using 0 as an alias for false
Oops, my python roots are showing.
Re:This is what is wrong with contemporary mathematics
by eriksank on Saturday December 22, 2012 @09:11PM
(#4958302)
The claim follows trivially from Gödel's Incompleteness. Claiming the truth of a theory amounts to extending it with a statement about its consistency, automatically making the whole inconsistent.