Re:Mamdani Bans AI in NYC Schools
by charcircuit on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @06:50PM
(#49543678)
LLMs have been better than many teachers I've had in my life. To no fault of the teachers, it's hard to compete with something that has understanding of every subject, is hooked up to the internet, and is given 1:1 time with the person learning at any time of the day, answering promptly.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
LLMs have enormous capacity for supporting a person who is motivated to learn and wants individualized support and instruction. That doesn’t describe all students and there’s no reason why seat time in the classroom should be used that way - students can still use an LLM to help them learn if they’re motivated to do that, but not during class.
Confidently pretends to have understanding of every subject but is frequently spectacularly wrong
Sure, classroom sizes can be a detriment to those that require more hands on instruction time. But that's not everyone and not every school suffers from overcrowding.
Re:Mamdani Bans AI in NYC Schools
by UtopiaPunk on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:13PM
(#49543888)
LLMs are also more flattering
Re:Mamdani Bans AI in NYC Schools
by andrekandre on Friday September 04, 2026 @09:48PM
(#49572303)
your absolutely right!
Re:Mamdani Bans AI in NYC Schools
by preg_match on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @09:23PM
(#49544846)
LLMs are very good at convincing people they are learning, because they give answers quickly and fairly accurately. But that makes them bad teachers, not better teachers. The fact that LLMs are good problem solvers is to their detriment when it comes to teaching. We don't want to solve problems in this domain, we want to slowly trickle information and build practice so students can solve problems.
I think people conflate productivity for learning. LLMs can greatly help with productivity. But... so can hiring an employee. Well, what have you learned? Nothing, you outsourced 90% of it. You decidedly learned less than if you were less productive and did it yourself.