News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by mschuster91 on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @04:50AM (#49533606)
The problem is... being opposed to a national ID card scheme is bipartisan in the US [1]. The Republicans go as far as to yap about "mark of the beast", the Democrats and the ACLU fear them being used as part of a surveillance state.

[1] https://www.nyclu.org/commentary/letter-beware-mark-beast-wa...

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by vidarh on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @06:56AM (#49534500)
You don't need a national ID card scheme to do this, though.

The EU/EEA is rolling out a digital identity mechanism with interoperable wallets that can hold any range of identity documents and other credentials. You don't need to pick a single wallet provider - several EU countries are approving multiple, including private providers. You don't need to standardise on a single ID.

This is already the case for many already in-use ID solutions in Europe. E.g. in Norway, there are at least 3 signing providers, and only one provider is government issued - the by far most popular (BankID) is private. You identify yourself to the provider when requesting issuance, not to the government (unless you sign up with a government provider).

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by alistairSH on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @05:11AM (#49533749)
Which is insane. The federal government already knows who we are, via SSN, tax returns, and whatever else. The state already knows via tax returns, driver's license, and whatever else.

If we, collectively, don't want a true national ID, then federal regulations on state-issued IDs should be available (something roughly akin to ReadID, but with the ability to use the ID as a proof of age or other attribute as needed).

We'll get there eventually, but not before we try everything else first.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by cucumber3732842 on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @06:10AM (#49534203)
>Which is insane. The federal government already knows who we are, via SSN, tax returns, and whatever else. The state already knows via tax returns, driver's license, and whatever else.

"They can already send a drone to watch you and track your cell location and, and, and, why does it matter if they also slap up a million AI powered cameras?"

The comprehensiveness of the system matters.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by alistairSH on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:36AM (#49534787)
Not sure how you jump from "ID with chip" to "AI-based drone and camera network". We can do one without the other.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by skinfaxi on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @08:48AM (#49535459)
They are already doing the camera thing with flock.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by cucumber3732842 on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @09:20AM (#49535802)
The point was to compare the proposed ID change with the state of surveillance before (bad but still not all that comprehensive) and after Flock et al (more comprehensive).
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by mulmen on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @04:43PM (#49542267)
Your failure of imagination doesn’t make national ID a good idea.

This is Chesterton’s Fence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Chesterton#Chesterton's_...

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by mulmen on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @04:57PM (#49542453)
> […] ability to use the ID as a proof of age or other attribute as needed

What attributes should require proof? Where do you draw the line?

Age?

Gender?

Race?

Religion?

Political party?

Citizenship?

> We'll get there eventually, but not before we try everything else first.

We got here by trying everything else first.

The “good old days” are now. Thousands of years of progress and blood delivered our liberal societies. Don’t give it up so easily.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by alistairSH on Thursday September 03, 2026 @10:40AM (#49550537)
Whatever society needs... this is why we have elections and stuff.

Really, the broader point is I'm tired of giving away massive chunks of my PII (SSN, DL copies, etc) instead of just having something from the government that will say "Yep. He is who he claims."

If we, collectively, decide we need age-gated websites, then let's enable that properly. I shouldn't have to give NYT a scan of my DL and my SSN to gain access.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by mulmen on Thursday September 03, 2026 @03:23PM (#49555322)
> If we, collectively, decide we need age-gated websites

We haven’t decided this.

> having something from the government that will say "Yep. He is who he claims."

You’re literally trading liberty for convenience.

I understand your position. I just fundamentally disagree that the tradeoff you are so eager to make is worthwhile.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by alistairSH on Friday September 04, 2026 @03:55PM (#49569435)
What liberty am I trading? The government already knows who I am.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by mulmen on Friday September 04, 2026 @06:05PM (#49570791)
They don’t know what you do.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by bayindirh on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @06:56AM (#49534499)
> the Democrats and the ACLU fear them being used as part of a surveillance state.

AFAICS from the other side of the pond, United States Government can track people well enough even without a national ID card. They have successfully worked around that problem.

So, it's a moot point now. No?

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by swed420 on Friday September 04, 2026 @12:31PM (#49566856)
Correct. The challenge is convincing enough people of that.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by nobodyandproud on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @05:36AM (#49533922)
I grew up in that tradition, so I can shed some light: The fear of a national ID isn’t just about tracking and privacy, but that an individual cannot participate in society or survive if the government decides to revoke the id.

Meaning, I can’t buy food; rent or buy a home; or hold any sort of job and earn and save.

What we have today isn’t better, but until recently I was hard pressed to see how such fears were even warranted.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @06:59AM (#49534512)
Exactly. You do not want to hand the US government the ability to “turn off” someone’s daily life at the press of a button.

Things are already bad enough as it is, but at least it’s still possible to get by even if the system takes a dislike to you.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:08AM (#49534597)
> Exactly. You do not want to hand the US government the ability to “turn off” someone’s daily life at the press of a button.

If you're within the borders of the US, this ability already exists, they have a monopoly on violence in the country, something the government is very eager to demonstrate this year.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:30AM (#49534730)
There’s a lot of room between violence and financial isolation. The government has shown multiple times that it is willing to go after otherwise law-abiding citizens who take up disfavored careers, whether it’s gun dealers and payday lenders in Operation Choke Point, cannabis dispensaries in states where it was legal, or online cam girls. In all of these cases, going to cash or using alternatives to the banking system was possible and even necessary for them to survive.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:39AM (#49534804)
And none of those examples you use, involve SSNs, these are all 100% paperless people/companies? Makes me wonder how they got bank accounts in the first place if they're so disconnected from society.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:49AM (#49534894)
The individuals had SSNs, but did not have a hypothetical national ID connected to systems that could have been used to fully isolate them. As long as backchannels exist in the system to accommodate those without SSNs/DLs, it is possible to get by even if the system tries to cut you off.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @08:22AM (#49535197)
> As long as backchannels exist in the system to accommodate those without SSNs/DLs, it is possible to get by even if the system tries to cut you off

And again, as long as backchannels exists in the system to accommodate those without a Government ID, it is possible to get by even if the system tries to cut you off.

Don't you see and understand you already have government ID? You're just calling it by another name...

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @09:04AM (#49535591)
Once the official ID exists, those backchannels will be cut off, as they have been in much of Europe.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @11:12AM (#49537542)
> Once the official ID exists, those backchannels will be cut off,

Do you seriously not get it yet? You have IDs now, and you claim those backchannels exists now, and haven't been cut off. Why would calling something something else suddenly make those backchannels be cut off? How come they exists today in the first place then?

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @02:32PM (#49540416)
Official IDs don’t exist now. The “surrogate” IDs (SSN, DLs) are not universal nor mandatory, and there are legal barriers to using them as an official national ID.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Saturday September 05, 2026 @05:53AM (#49574931)
So "REAL ID Act of 2005" isn't the creation of a official ID and existed since 2015 or so?
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by r3trohack3r on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @08:41AM (#49535387)
> they have a monopoly on violence in the country

I have not seen a definition of this that is simultaneously true and useful

The sole provider of violence in the U.S. is not the government.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @09:32AM (#49535968)
"Monopoly on violence" isn't some new concept I just invented here, it's a established concept about "legal use of force", which the government typically is the sole arbiter of. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence

Of course many engage in "violence", or "provide it", that is not in doubt.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by r3trohack3r on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @10:27AM (#49536795)
I know it’s not new, thus why I said I’ve never seen a definition that is both true and useful.

In the U.S. I can lawfully use violence in many ways under many circumstances. I.E. if you’re in my house and I didn’t invite you there, I can slay you lawfully.

In the U.S. the federal government is not the only institution responsible for law making or law enforcement. It is not only entity that can lawfully use violence. Etc.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @11:12AM (#49537558)
> In the U.S. I can lawfully use violence in many ways under many circumstances. I.E. if you’re in my house and I didn’t invite you there, I can slay you lawfully.

Yes, and you can do so, because the government and state says it's OK to do so. If they didn't, it wouldn't. This is the core idea.

> In the U.S. the federal government is not the only institution responsible for law making or law enforcement. It is not only entity that can lawfully use violence. Etc.

Hence the whole "sole arbiter of" and last paragraph in my last comment. All those entities are "allowed to use violence" because your government says it's OK.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by r3trohack3r on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @11:25AM (#49537731)
If you define the entity as “all institutions that are allowed to create and enforce laws” and then say “that entity has a monopoly on creating and enforcing laws” you’ve created a tautology.

There are clear counter examples to your statement in the U.S.

States are not “allowed” to use violence because the Federal government says it’s okay. States have a right to create and enforce laws.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @02:46PM (#49540621)
All those entities are "allowed to use violence" because your government says it's OK.

I don't know if you're in the US, but that's simply not how our Constitution works. "Monopoly on violence" is just something some people made up. It's meaningless, just some empty words on paper.

(Which is also true for the Constitution itself, of course. But if you're talking about the theoretical and philosophical basis for lawmaking in the US, that's what determines both. Theoretically.)

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @04:31PM (#49542067)
It’s funny because the whole notion of a monopoly on violence is very traditional and tightly coupled to the Westphalian notion of statehood, yet I often see that the first people to cite the monopoly on violence are also the ones undermining the Westphalian state model.

In any case all the old gods are dead or dying, including old ideas of statehood, so enjoy the ride, everyone.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @10:49AM (#49537173)
Not to mention the increasing use of private security and even private police, and the increasing use of military PMCs and privately owned/controlled “kill chain” components like Palantir and Starlink/Starshield.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @06:56AM (#49534496)
> but that an individual cannot participate in society or survive if the government decides to revoke the id

What would happen today if your government revokes a SSN which is your de facto "personal identification number" today? Can you still rent/buy a home? Can you have a job?

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:00AM (#49534520)
Some US citizens don’t even have SSNs, believe it or not. The Amish get by just fine.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:08AM (#49534592)
Is it generally considered that The Amish "participates in society"? I thought the whole point for them was that they're "outside of modern society", to some degree at least.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by iamnothere on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:35AM (#49534778)
They participate in their own society, which allows them to survive in their own way. In other countries, national IDs have often been followed by mandatory registration requirements for renting or owning property, employment, etc. At present there are ways to get around using ID for many things, and it should stay that way.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by nobodyandproud on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:10AM (#49534607)
Before my time, but I believe SSN was and probably still is controversial in my circle. I definitely recall rumblings about it even 30 years ago.

But while cash is printed (physical currency): Not having an SSN becomes a major impediment but not impossible to make transactions and survive.

Our migrant workers—who are basically carrying white collar workers like me—are proof of this.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:25AM (#49534698)
Isn't all of those cases then also proof that if the SSN was a government ID instead, all of those things would have been the same? The ID wouldn't "impossible to make transactions and survive", just an impediment, just like not having a SSN is today.

Point is, the US already basically have a de facto "ID card", they just don't call it as such (yet?), so claiming somehow correctly labeling this thing would make things worse or more difficult, doesn't make much sense.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by dghlsakjg on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @05:16PM (#49542697)
You can't really identify someone by their SSN. My card is literally just a piece of cardstock paper with a name and number, and no one has ever asked to see it. There is no photo. There is no security.
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by embedding-shape on Saturday September 05, 2026 @05:53AM (#49574938)
Say you go to your local bank today and ask to sign up for a new bank account, what sort of documents do they ask for? Passport? Drivers license?
Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by dghlsakjg on Saturday September 05, 2026 @03:57PM (#49580122)
Government issued id with a photo is typically the requirement depending on the bank and their KYC.

That can be a military id, passport, NEXUS card, DL, state ID.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by Tangurena2 on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @08:52AM (#49535498)
> The fear of a national ID isn’t just about tracking and privacy, but that an individual cannot participate in society or survive if the government decides to revoke the id.

This is because the US made a critical flaw by tying the authentication and authorization tokens into one single token - your driving license/ID. They should be separate things. Your authentication token (who are you?) should have your picture and be forgery resistant. Your authorization token (what can you do?) should be a piece of plastic with zero pictures (like your insurance card). Did you get stopped for DUI? The officer takes your authorization token, instead, the officer confiscates both tokens and hands you a paper receipt.

The FAA does it the smart way, your authorization token (pilot's license) has no photo. You do something stupid, the ATC tells you to "call this number" and if it is really badly stupid, then the local FAA person confiscates your authorization token.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by lotsofpulp on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @06:05AM (#49534153)
A national ID card scheme has existed for many decades. It’s called a passport.

There is no reason a digital equivalent can’t be made using the passport system, and it can be left optional, just like passports are optional.

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by logifail on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:01AM (#49534533)
> just like passports are optional

"Border controls aren’t supposed to exist between EU member states – that’s the promise of the 1985 Schengen treaty. Yet today, travelers routinely face checks when crossing borders within the [European] union"

https://euobserver.com/198454/law-professor-sues-germany-for...

Re:FBI Probes Service Selling 153M+ Drivers Licenses by lotsofpulp on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @07:28AM (#49534716)
What relevance does that have to the US federal government offering a digital ID verification system on top of existing passport infrastructure?

EU did border checks without digital IDs being a thing, so why couldn’t US states do a border check without digital IDs?

Digital IDs are not a causal factor for these concerns, seeing as how those government abuses already happen without digital IDs.