News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Creepy Crawlies by paytonjjones on Sunday August 30, 2026 @01:28PM (#49500771)
In this case, because there's a vastly more efficient economic path for the adversaries (cloning).

They're not trying to engage in an arms race, they're trying to channel a racing river into its natural course.

Re:Creepy Crawlies by pbronez on Sunday August 30, 2026 @02:08PM (#49501181)
It’s more economical at a compute level, but not at the developer level. The moment you start customizing your crawler to use protocol X for site Y your scale story collapses.
Re:Creepy Crawlies by paytonjjones on Sunday August 30, 2026 @02:26PM (#49501370)
It's a good point, but in practice it depends on how easy those customizations are to implement / maintain, and how much money and effort you save. At some point the compute cost can disrupt even the nicest scale story.

I think the path forward is that websites offer one path for humans, and another for scrapers. But the huge catch is the path for scrapers must be _genuinely_ and _reliably_ the more economical and scalable path (either through something like PoW arms races, or through fear of litigation). Otherwise they will continue to ignore instructions and intrude on the human path.

Re:Creepy Crawlies by inigyou on Sunday August 30, 2026 @03:24PM (#49501921)
Why aren't we litigating against scrapers, anyway? DDoS is a felony.
Re:Creepy Crawlies by ekidd on Sunday August 30, 2026 @04:00PM (#49502216)
Largely because they're residential botnets in places like Brazil (a real example from one of my sites that was crawled to near-destruction). Someone could probably do something about this, but it's out of reach for individual site owners.
Re:Creepy Crawlies by inigyou on Sunday August 30, 2026 @04:07PM (#49502274)
If you block Brazil, they'll find an alternative, maybe then you can sue them.
Re:Creepy Crawlies by afdbcreid on Sunday August 30, 2026 @10:03PM (#49504815)
But they operate from neither. You can at most sue the one renting them IP addresses. Which will do basically nothing.

(Also, blocking a whole country is likely not what you do, but you probably know that).

Re:Creepy Crawlies by inigyou on Monday August 31, 2026 @01:24AM (#49505930)
Why do you think you can only use the one who's renting them IP addresses?
Re:Creepy Crawlies by semiquaver on Monday August 31, 2026 @07:35AM (#49508446)
How good are you personally at iteratively and sequentially jumping through the legal systems of dozens of countries over the course of years, interleaved with genuinely difficult technical investigation, to unmask successive onion-layers of identity in order to unmask one offender?

Oh, and it also only takes a few minutes to reconfigure everything and invalidate those years of legal and investigatory work.

Re:Creepy Crawlies by inigyou on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:40PM (#49511773)
Why do you think OpenAI, Anthropic, Bright Data, and Comcast aren't US companies?
Re:Creepy Crawlies by miki123211 on Monday August 31, 2026 @04:24AM (#49507057)
Because they're all in countries who would ignore such litigation.
Re:Creepy Crawlies by articulatepang on Monday August 31, 2026 @01:00PM (#49512027)
Who’s “we”? I don’t want to do that work. I don’t think kernel maintainers do, either. Do you?
Re:Creepy Crawlies by miki123211 on Monday August 31, 2026 @04:23AM (#49507054)
The temptation to offer different / inferior / limited content to scrapers will be too strong, so such solutions are doomed to fail.

This would likely work as "Cloudflare SideChannel", a (hypothetical) Cloudflare product that would let scrapers download the pages that humans actually visit, as they are added to the CF cache. It wouldn't work for the non-Cloudflare part of the internet where humans connect directly to the servers that have their content.

Re:Creepy Crawlies by simonw on Monday August 31, 2026 @09:17AM (#49509419)
The moment we establish a standard for offering a "optimized for scrapers" version of a site, people who do not want to be scraped will weaponise that to serve junk to scrapers... and scrapers will subsequently refuse to use it.
Re:Creepy Crawlies by eru on Sunday August 30, 2026 @09:54PM (#49504759)
> It’s more economical at a compute level, but not at the developer level.

Developers and compute are interchangeable now.

Re:Creepy Crawlies by nozzlegear on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:18PM (#49505214)
Who's proompting the machine to do it differently without a developer there to ask the right questions?
Re:Creepy Crawlies by eru on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:20PM (#49505222)
You can have a high level prompt of: make our crawling cheaper and more reliable to run.
Re:Creepy Crawlies by miki123211 on Monday August 31, 2026 @04:20AM (#49507026)
I highly doubt the adversaries actually care about kernel.org in particular.

It's more likely that they're trying to scrape the entire internet, and cgit is just unfortunate enough to have autogenerated pages, where each page seems to contain text entirely distinct from its neighbors. This probably bypasses the scrapers' heuristics, which normally prevent them from getting trapped in a maze of twisty little autogenerated pages, all alike.

The way you normally deal with datasets at that scale is to move postprocessing (particularly expensive postprocessing) as late in the pipeline as possible.